6 ms·
Catalonia Fines Airbnb, Threatens to Block Locals From Using Site
- ChuckMcM 12y agoAreas with high unemployment like Spain are particularly vulnerable to disruption of the form that AirBnB is bringing to the hospitality industry, but I chuckled at this paragraph; "Catalonia’s regional government said Tuesday that Airbnb is in “serious” breach of regional law and that it has ordered the company to pay €30,000 ($41,000) in fines within the month or begin adhering to Catalan law." I'm guessing they meant to write "and begin adhering to the law" but so often we hear that you can either follow the law or bribe the officials to look the other way, it reads a bit like the latter :-). I'm curious what the folks in Spain think of this, is AirBnB a good thing or a bad thing?
- RBerenguel 12y agoThe problem is, they are helping people break the law (the fine is for advertising illegal touristic rents) If someone rents a place repeatedly (for vacationing) they need a permit (which includes checking the place for safety measures, specially for the tenant) as well as paying another type of taxes. Likewise for longer than 30 days renting: for this the place has to be a for-rent place, registered somewhere else. The government is just asking AirBnb to follow the law, advertising only legal places that have their stuff in-place. Not only that, but it's hard to know if AirBnb hosts are declaring their taxes properly (AirBnb could enforce this, though.) As a Spaniard, I like seeing some disruption in areas that need it, and promoting leasing/rentings definitely needs it. But as a freelancer who pays quite a lot in taxes, it boils my blood that so many people (including most government officials, granted) try to game the system. As for the quote, I can't find it anywhere in local sources, neither did I hear it yesterday when the officials appeared on news. So, it's probably a writer error, meant to be and.
- hyperbovine 12y agoGoogle is helping anybody who Googles how to do something illegal break the law. Should we fine them as well? There are dozens if not hundreds of other web sites that let you advertise vacation rentals in Europe. Are they also receiving such ultimata? My qualms with the regulatory efforts underway in Europe re: Google, Amazon, AirBnb, Uber, etc. are that they do not seem to be driven by any sort of guiding principle other than protectionist aversion to American companies succeeding in the European marketplace. Protectionism isn't inherently bad but let's call a spade a spade.
- RBerenguel 12y agoThey are also fining European companies doing similar things (see Blablacar.)
- vidarh 12y ago> Are they also receiving such ultimata? Does a substantial percentage of their advertisers break the law by not having the appropriate licenses required in their countries? If no, then they shouldn't be receiving any ultimatums. (the answer to that question, by the way, is "no" for most of these sites, as most of them are simply affiliates / marketing partners for a handful of companies that have, decades of history of dealing with the regulations properly when representing the property owners; I'm sure there are exceptions here and there, especially for smaller/newer operators) You may not see this as "driven by any sort of guiding principle other than protectionist aversion", but a lot of others see this as driven by the respective organs duty to uphold various consumer protection laws.
- esbranson 12y agoI would absolutely love to get my hands on a bulk, machine-readable version of Catalunya's laws. To see what other sort of crazy laws they have to deal with. The law is the one dataset that seems to have frequent relevance everywhere but no one seems to ever have it..
- prof_hobart 12y agoAm I taking it from this comment that you think this particular law is crazy? I don't know the details of it, but at a basic level, only being allowed to rent places that have had some kind of safety inspection doesn't seem that ludicrous to me.
- kordless 12y agoOr it's an opportunity.
- weddpros 12y ago"You can live in your house, raise kids in your house, but maybe it's too dangerous to let you rent it to tourists". Seriously? It looks like the kind of nonsense governments use when they want to bar you from some freedom isn't it? They put a discouraging administrative burden on you.
- josephlord 12y agoIf you own it you probably had it inspected before you bought it and you can make changes to ensure it is safe. You can ensure changes are done safely and get them checked if you want to. You have personal liberty. When you rent it there are minimum standards, renters are often in a weak position to get things fixed and for short term rents the renter is arriving blind with possibly no opportunity to change plans if they recognise there are safety issues even if they have the skills to identify them.
- icebraining 12y agoAs a renter, I don't mind. For those who do, there's a simple solution: the State can have it inspected at request and grant a certification, so that renters can be assured before committing. Of course, that's if the law was actually intended to protect the renters.
- nashequilibrium 12y agoIt's amazing how society will always have it's shadow over you. I work my butt off to buy a home, my own piece of land but I have to ask the government permission for who to let stay on my land for a certain period of time.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- switch007 12y agoMost people own land on a fee simple basis (in England, the Crown holds the allodial title), but that's another discussion. I've used airbnb in many European cities where the rentals are invariably converted apartments in dense buildings (i.e. 30-200 apartments) in a residential neighbourhood. It's completely different to letting out a farm house on an estate in the middle of no where. Respect for your neighbours (tenant and owner alike) in such communities is paramount.
- qq66 12y agoLand "ownership" has no basis in natural law since it's a formalization of violence (all private land was either taken from someone else, or declared to be owned by threatening newcomers with violence). You can't own land the way you can own the fruit of your labor, so all land ownership is contingent on the consent of the community.
- icebraining 12y agoThat doesn't mean that the community shouldn't simply decide to actually grant full property rights to whoever is deemed to have the title. You don't need to rely on nonsense like "natural rights" to oppose the government-granted licensing system. (You should also not assume I support full property rights)
- vidarh 12y agoThe community could, but the community won't in most cases for the simple reason that most communities find it incredibly damaging to neighbours to let people do whatever they want on "their" property. If I were to, for example, start a 24/7 brothel in my terraced suburban house, complete with front garden strip show set to loud music and light show, it would have tremendous negative effects on my neighbours.
- pibefision 12y agoWell, if you have a property elegible for renting in AirBnB, you are not the kind of people who is suffering unemployment, so I'm not sure if your segmentation applies here to support AirBnB growth in Spain. Spain is the 2rd receptive tourist destination for the world (1st is US) (uwto.org)
- omegant 12y agoThe real reason behind this fine is the heavy lobbying from the big Hotel companies in Spain, they are specially making this pressure at a local government level, as they are going to be the regulators (The new renting law differentiates between short and long term, and gives the regulation powers to the Comunidades Autonomas). Neighbors horror stories like the ones we´ve been seeing in NY, don´t seem to be as big a factor in this. Still it happens, mainly in the big cities like Barcelona and Madrid, were some flat owners are having problems with the guests of their neighbors. But I´m not aware that the neighbors are too vocal (I´ll gladly be corrected about this). The Hotel lobby is seeing how a big chunk of their business is going to the share economy and they are afraid. In Mallorca where I live, most AirBnB offerings are mostly for summer apartments and homes (not at the city), so there is little problem with neighbors (who mostly want to do the same). People of course see AirBnB as a way to keep low the costs of owning a summer apartment (renting the weeks they are not going to use it). This is specially interesting to those who are trapped on high Mortgages from the bubble, as it´s providing them another income source. People who inherited or bought before 2004 are seeing mostly profits, and if you are lucky (and dedicated) you are able to make money of it. So far the legal status in Mallorca is good, as you can register your apartment for season renting only paying a yearly fare per bed to be rented. But they are certainly receiving heat by the lobbys and this could change any moment. I guess that the best move by AirBnB is to start selling this local governments the advantages of AirBnB: -to improve the usage of the empty apartment stock (that eventually increases the plummeted property prices) -Putting money on the hands of the people who more needs it. -Not a killing competitor to hotels, while certain % of clients will move to AirBnB, not all people wants to go to apartments (even less if they are privately owned), for they vacations. It´s a similar concept to the low cost companies, they increase the total traffic, and the total business for the area, it´s not only the same passengers traveling cheaper. Don´t need to be all local government, just 2 or 3 of the most touristic ones like Baleares, Canarias, Valencia, Cataluña. Once one starts making AirBnB friendly regulations (and selling them as an advantage for the government itself), most of the rest will follow.
- taneliv 12y agoI wonder how this is different from other similar services, for example milanuncios has heaps of private homes available for letting (or subletting) also in Catalonia. In my experience both work the same, airbnb feels more trustworthy and is easier to use, milanuncios has wider selection. Anyone know the law in question? In hotels the accommodation tax was, I think, 50 cents per adult guest, something that could probably easily be factored in airbnb's service.
- RBerenguel 12y agoAs I commented below, the law says that a private place (like my home) can't be repeatedly rented without being registered as a home (full home) for rent. Also, separate bedrooms can't be legally rented (unless the full home is rented): it's either full house or nothing (personally I find it rather stupid a bedroom can't be rented legally, but anyway.) Likewise for stays longer than 30 days. It's not a matter of acomodation tax, is that homes (except those registered as tourist apartments, which implies the full house) are outside the laws.
- jpkeisala 12y agoMakes sense. If people are using Airbnb as business to rent property it is fair to ask they follow the law by having proper permit.
- flexie 12y agoAbsolutely. I would hate if my neighbor started renting out his apartment to tourist on Craigslist or AirBnB.
- snitko 12y agoIt's funny how your first thought is not to go to your neighbor, ask around and see whether this is going to be any trouble for you at all and if it is, try to work out a solution you both would agree on. Your first thought: permit, government, regulation. He's your neighbor for gods sake. It's not like you can't go talk to him. Why do you, by default, treat him like a piece of scum with which only government can deal? Needing some kind of permit to do whatever I please with my property, if it doesn't create problems to anybody else, is insane.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mahouse 12y agoIt's not about screwing your neighbour, it's about security, it's about having ensurance, it's about collecting taxes, it's about not being unfair to the rest of hotels that just follow the law. If you don't like the law that gives you no permission to walk around it.
- RBerenguel 12y agoI wonder why you are being downvoted by stating obvious facts related to the problem. As time passes I'm more tempted to install that Chrome plugin that turns every mention of "disrupt" into "bullshit."
- 12y ago
- snitko 12y agoTalking about private property. People can't even rent it without government permission and then you hear voices saying "you wouldn't have private property if not for the government". Well, guess what, it's not yours if you need a permission to do stuff with it.
- gaius 12y agoAnd if you freely sign a piece of paper with the landlord that says you will not sublet....? This is a very common clause.
- snitko 12y agoThen it's a whole different story. It's a contract between the landlord and me that I voluntarily signed. Neither me, nor anybody else never signed any contract with government saying I cannot sublet.
- avz 12y agoThese laws and regulations were clearly created before the onset of sharing economy. And then they were useful since they provided important safety guarantees to the customers. However, this problem has now been solved by technical means (peer reviews, various forms of karma or reputation scoring etc). Many people say they feel safer, have more trust in and receive better user experience in new sharing economy services like uber and airbnb compared to traditional services like taxi and b&b. This suggests that the new technical solution has potential to be better than the old legalistic one. Perhaps it's again the time to adjust the laws and regulations to the new situation created by emerging technology. Specifically, licensing and limits on duration or portion of property that can be subleased should be scrapped. When it comes to registration, then assuming the government really needs to know about each property being subleased, services like airbnb could be required to export their own registry for use by the gov't. Compliance with such a law would be trivial from technical perspective (database dump with appropriate projection in some standard format). When it comes to taxes, then of course people renting out using airbnb should pay their dues like anyone who makes a profit or receives an income. If they don't, the standard measures against tax evasion apply.
- RBerenguel 12y agoDo you really think peer reviews and karma scoring are really a solution as soon as there is any money involved?
- avz 12y agoI think they work especially well when money is involved. If you make some money from time to time by subletting your property or sharing a ride you have even more incentive to maintain good reputation. This is how I imagine small early human communities worked: based on reputation. The thing is that our brains don't scale and they can't maintain reputation model for all people whom we exchange with in a large city. Services like airbnb and uber externalize the reputation model to a large scalable distributed system. As far as spammers and other abusers are concerned tech community has a long and largely successful history of dealing with them (blocklisting, statistical techniques like bayesian spam filtering, machine learning algorithms etc). Gmail is a very good example of effectiveness of spam-fighting techniques.
- capisce 12y ago> "after numerous complaints over rowdy visitors" Tragedy of the commons... This is why we can't have nice things.