6 ms·
Abnormal Brain Structure In Youth Who Commit Homicide
- DasCorCor 12y agoI could have acheived better accuracy (87%) by simply calling everyone a non-murderer.
- the_cat_kittles 12y agotwo people have the opportunity to invest in 20 startups. the first person says no to all of them, and the second person invests in all 20 of them. all but one go bankrupt. the first person proudly proclaims "i can avoid bad investments with 95% probability!"... and the second is a millionaire.
- reinhardt 12y agoNobody became millionaire by calling everyone a murderer.
- the_cat_kittles 12y agojust pointing out that the "success" of your model depends heavily on how you choose your evaluation criteria. to me, 87% correctly classified seems irrelevant because you can just change the distribution of murderers and non murders and your model would fail. it seems more interesting to me to focus on, say, the rate the model successfully classifies murders.
- slavik81 12y agoThe risk structure is different. When you make an investment in a company that turns out not to be successful, you wasted your money. If you persecute someone who would never have murdered anyone, you may have done great and irreversible harm an innocent man. The rate at which it correctly classifies non-murderers is more important for this measure to be useful.
- PeterisP 12y agoThat's why naive "error rate" is not useful and not used measurement for any classification that's not like 50/50 but more like a "needle in haystack". A more useful measure is F-score (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/F1_score https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/F1_score) according to which calling everyone a non-murderer would give 0%, but the method described in article ("81.29% overall accuracy, 80.00% specificity, and 81.48% sensitivity") would give 81%.
- math0ne 12y agoWatch out the future police are coming for you!
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- putlake 12y agoIn recent years research has found more and more evidence of genetic determinism. i.e. certain types of brains are more prone to violent behavior. Psychopaths also have a certain brain "signature" [1] I wonder if the legal system recognizes genetic determinism as a mitigating factor in violent crimes. If I were a defense attorney in a no-win scenario, I'd probably try this defense. Ah..will probably spend the rest of the night researching [2] 1. http://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/the-neuroscientist-who-discovered-he-was-a-psychopath-180947814/ http://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/the-neuroscient... 2. https://www.google.com/webhp?sourceid=chrome-instant&ion=1&espv=2&ie=UTF-8#q=brain+neurology+as+a+defense+in+violent+crimes https://www.google.com/webhp?sourceid=chrome-instant&ion=1&e...
- canjobear 12y agoBrain structure differences do not necessarily imply genetic determinism.
- kghose 12y agoDon't forget XYY (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XYY_syndrome#1960s http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XYY_syndrome#1960s) A cautionary tale about drawing conclusions from small sample sizes.
- gatehouse 12y agopredisposition to murder doesn't seem like a good reason to let someone go free
- sliverstorm 12y agoIt's not his fault, he can't resist murdering! How could we imprison a man like that!
- waterlesscloud 12y agoYou want to think very, very, VERY carefully about the implications of "genetic determinism" before you go down that road.
- 12y ago
- anigbrowl 12y agoThis doesn't surprise me, sadly... incarcerated homicide offenders had reduced gray matter volumes in the medial and lateral temporal lobes, including the hippocampus and posterior insula ...and indeed I've wondered why we don't test for conditions in the incarcerated population that have known potential for altering behavior, eg Toxoplasma gondii see http://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/9/11/03-0143_article http://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/9/11/03-0143_article for example. Assuming for the sake of argument that we could soon reliably identify symptoms of a homocidal disposition, what does this mean for criminal justice and law enforcement? From a purely utilitarian point of view it makes sense to monitor or even confine such people, but from a libertarian (philosophical) point of view, we could not subject them to penal confinement as people can hardly be held criminally liable for deficiencies in their own brain structure, which might be the result of genetics, malnutrition, or childhood trauma. Some sort of medical incarceration is the obvious alternative, but this is legally problematic. A Supreme Court case O'Connor v. Donaldson (1975) (among others, but this is the big one) made it very difficult to commit someone for confinement in a mental institution without clear evidence that they present a danger to society. Arguably, the US went putting people in mental institutions too casually and without regards for their rights, to a position of not providing sufficient mental health services for all but the most unhinged patients. While this technological advance might one day provide a reliable gauge of a person's homicidal capability, that's a long way from identifying how or when such behavior might manifest. At a less extreme case than confining someone, should we allow someone with a measurable homicidal tendency to purchase guns? If we forbid them doing so, how do we avoid a tiered approach to citizenship, in which the rights of some are abrogated pre-emptively through no fault of their own actions, but a 'fault in their stars'? From a different angle, this is also an interesting result for attorneys involved in death penalty defensive work - if MRI scans, which the courts and public are highly familiar with, can reliably predict homicidal characteristics, then the question of criminal responsibility becomes much more difficult to answer, since people have no control over the structures of their own brains.
- XorNot 12y agoWell, and this is just a crazy idea here, you could just decide as a society that citizen gun ownership is kind of pointlessly dangerous, with a close to statistically insignificant rate of self-defense usage, and instead move back to a model of an actual well-regulated militia.
- brandonb 12y agoI love this type of research, but this particular study requires a two-ton grain of salt. First, these results are based on only 20 total homicide offenders. So when they claim they can classify 75% of murderers correctly, that really just means 15 out of 20. Second, the final classifier has access to more than 14 variables, including factors like the number of previous convictions, not just brain structure. [1] If you're fitting 14 variables to 20 data points, it's very likely you're over-fitting. I personally would wait for a much larger study before drawing conclusions. [1] "The identified variables were age, PCL:YV Factor 1, PCL:YV Factor 2, years of regular substance use, total number of convictions, ICU, SES, brain volume, left and right lateral orbital frontal cortex, medial orbital frontal cortex, anterior and posterior cingulate, right temporal pole, and right and left parahippocampal cortex." http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4055901/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4055901/
- anigbrowl 12y ago20 total homicide offenders, 135 non-homicide offenders, and two control groups comprising another 41 subjects between them. I agree it's a highly preliminary result, but successfully IDing 75% of homicide perpetrators and 82% of non-homicide subjects is a good start. Why are you leaving out the rest of the test population? PS I don't think it's perfect by any means, when you look at the population it's pretty particular to New Mexico. Per my other comment, I think the significance of this is that we should be doing a lot more research in our depressingly large incarcerated population to develop a better understanding what makes some criminals dangerous vs others who are just selfish or opportunistic.
- mewse 12y ago75% of homicide perpetrators identified correctly (15/20) + 82% of non-homicide perpetrators identified correctly (111/135) is a total classification accuracy of 81% (126/155) for the procedure. But if we just assume that everyone is in the non-homicide group (which is what "innocent until proven guilty" has us do anyway), then that gives us a total classification accuracy of (135/155) 85% for the same sample set. That is, "innocent until proven guilty" is notably more accurate than the system which is being proposed here, and infinitely less likely to deliver a false positive result.
- BadassFractal 12y agoIn his book "Free Will" (http://www.samharris.org/free-will http://www.samharris.org/free-will), Sam Harris discusses the dilemma of what we would do if we suddenly discovered that horrible acts of violence were actually pre-determined by one's genetics and physical traits, rather than by one's (supposedly) controllable will and thought processes. How do you punish someone who unwillingly commits atrocities, someone who cannot control it and didn't ask to be born that way? What do you do with that individual? IIRC the example was someone committing a murder and then the jury discovering that the person actually had a brain tumor that was making him/her act differently from normal. Do you hate that person? Who do you blame? In an ideal futuristic society we would be able to alter our genetics in such a way that we do not present an unnecessary threat to others, if we do indeed discover that we're naturally predisposed towards horrible acts of violence.
- ohashi 12y agoStart working on a way to fix them.
- rolleiflex 12y agoTo extend, how do you 'punish' those who have those genetics and physical traits, but haven't committed a crime yet? How do you treat a perfectly innocent someone who cannot control it and didn't ask to be born that way? What do you do with that individual?
- spain 12y agoI would argue that not all those with the required traits for committing crimes do not actually go on to committing those crimes, so it would be wrong to preemptively punish them. Instead we should offer something like therapy to help them better control their instincts.
- the_cat_kittles 12y agoin a video that i discovered reading the comments on hn, marshall rosenberg argues that the concept and practice of punishment should be abandoned all together. this is a long (3 hour) video, but its actually an amazing point of view: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YwXH4hNfgPg&list=FLtlBbsoKI-JBFCXMeb48TfA&index=2 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YwXH4hNfgPg&list=FLtlBbsoKI-...
- hackuser 12y agoFrom the report: "Here we use neuroimaging and voxel-based morphometry to examine brain gray matter in incarcerated male adolescents who committed homicide (n = 20) compared with incarcerated offenders who did not commit homicide (n = 135). Two additional control groups were used to understand further the nature of gray matter differences: incarcerated offenders who did not commit homicide matched on important demographic and psychometric variables (n = 20) and healthy participants from the community (n = 21)." Perhaps someone with expertise can comment on a couple of points: 1) Am I correct that this research is preliminary, given the number of subjects involved? It seems too preliminary to even report on HN (to answer my own question), but maybe I don't understand it well enough. 2) Is there reason to believe that the brain differences caused the homicide, rather than believe that committing homicide and getting incarcerated, two very traumatic events, caused changes to their brains? Or that something very traumatic caused them both the crime and the brain changes?
- yoz-y 12y agoGiven a sufficiently high number of input parameters (huge in this study) and a sufficiently small test group (tiny, in comparison to number of parameters in this study), any classifier black-box approach will find some correlation in any arbitrary condition. http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/neuroskeptic/2009/09/16/fmri-gets-slap-in-the-face-with-a-dead-fish/#.U7zcthYucuJ http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/neuroskeptic/2009/09/16/fm...
- robg 12y ago1 - All of science is a progress report, subject to change with more evidence. This is one compelling study that will drive more research. 2 - An excellent point easily missed and hard to account for without true longitudinal studies. Early childhood stress is a known agent of brain damage.
- downandout 12y agoWhile 75% of homicide defendants may have this defect, the opposite is almost certainly not true (that 75% of people with this defect will commit homicide). This type of research is fascinating, but since we have no way to treat such a condition, its only purpose would be to attempt to identify potential murderers. And that is a very slippery slope (see Minority Report).
- VladimirGolovin 12y agoOne of the authors of the paper is Dr. Kent Kiehl, who is famous for using a mobile fMRI to scan thousands of inmates in multiple prisons, including many psychopathic offenders. His book on his research of psychopathy in prisons, "The Psychopath Whisperer", is excellent (despite a terrible name). Easily one of the best books on the topic. I want a sequel.
- bakhy 12y agoI hate the way the word "abnormal" is thrown around just like that. I would bet that any group of people with a strong common characteristic could be found to have common "abnormalities" in their brain. <Morgan Freeman>Does this average, normal brain, actually exist? Do the heads of more than 50% of people on Earth contain close to identical brains? Or are we all abnormal in our own way?</Morgan Freeman> And their tendentious conclusion about predicting homicide is simply creepy.
- carlob 12y agoHow do they know the different brain structure is not an effect of having committed an homicide rather than the converse? Can someone with access to the full text see if they address this question?
- jeromeparadis 12y agoI was wondering the same thing. Also, isn't it possible that how they lived and in which environment before committing a murder affected their brain?