2 ms·
If you read the net neutrality proposals made by the EU and elsewhere, QOS is perfectly allowed and within the normal operation of networks. The Net Neutrality
by belorn 12y ago
If you read the net neutrality proposals made by the EU and elsewhere, QOS is perfectly allowed and within the normal operation of networks. The Net Neutrality discussion has always been about punitive throttling, and if ISP are allowed to intentionally throttle a network service solely based on who and who hasn't paid them.
Thoughtful input in the rulemaking process has thus been done! Combat congestion is good thing, and no one is objecting to prioritizing VOIP traffic over bittorrent. Fastlane and slowlane has nothing to do with QoS.
- rhino369 12y agoSome limited QOS is. But I don't see a reason why it should be limited. I don't think any traffic should be throttled, but in times of peak usage, you should be able to pay for priority.
- danielweber 12y agoThe Net Neutrality discussion has always been about punitive throttling Not on HN. Some here on HN insist that any interference with bits-in-bits-out, including QoS, violates NN. I've mostly given up on NN debates. In addition to debating the merits of the various positions, we also have moving names for each position, and people really insistent (not you that I've yet seen) that their definition is the "right one."