3 ms·
> Investment in certain skills I think you get it wrong. You are not being paid for the years of studies you did. If you learn about petrol extraction in a cou
by ekianjo 12y ago
> Investment in certain skills
I think you get it wrong. You are not being paid for the years of studies you did. If you learn about petrol extraction in a country that has no oil and if you are not willing to move, your market value is exactly zero. The market defines your value, not your education. That's precisely what tons of students don't understand and get severely pissed off when they don't get the job and the salary they expected.
- coldtea 12y ago>I think you get it wrong. You are not being paid for the years of studies you did. Not only you do, but in a lot of countries it is mandatory too. People with university degrees earn X more than people without, by law. This for example happens with civil servants in lots of countries (different, published pay scales if you have a university degree). In some places it's also encoded in the minimum wage a profession commands. (I worked at the salary department of a major ministry in my country, and I know of similar laws elsewhere too).
- ekianjo 12y ago> Not only you do, but in a lot of countries it is mandatory too. Great, you just defined one of the root causes of unemployment. Artificially fixed value. The same thing occurs when you artificially define minimum wages: home owners stop renting their properties because it does not make sense for them anymore.
- coldtea 12y agoI don't believe in some magic "market equillibrium mechanism" that always reaches some optimum and doesn't need intervention. If people and especially employees, can screw other people, they will. Laws against slave and child labor, and women inequality in pay, are also some ways in which we introduced protections against those abubses. For some people those protections were "artificially defined" too (e.g "why take the children out of the labour pool and artificially inflate the value of adult labor"). >The same thing occurs when you artificially define minimum wages: home owners stop renting their properties because it does not make sense for them anymore. The correlation doesn't make much sense. As long as there are people willing to rent their properties, they'd rent them. If anything, with people getting some guaranteed minimum wage, instead of being paid less, there even be more people that can afford to rent. Or is the idea here that people would not be employed because of the strict miminum wage? In actual life I haven't seen that. It's more like employees are paying people less just because they can, than paying them less because they cannot afford to pay them more. Minimum wage at least puts a cap to that.
- ekianjo 12y ago> The correlation doesn't make much sense. As long as there are people willing to rent their properties, they'd rent them. If anything, with people getting some guaranteed minimum wage, instead of being paid less, there even be more people that can afford to rent. Wrong word used up there, it was not "wages" I was refering to, it was "rent prices".