12 ms·
What's the advice if you have a business requirement to support both formal, informal and full names? For example, the order confirmation e-mail might say "Goo
by michaelt 12y ago
What's the advice if you have a business requirement to support both formal, informal and full names?
For example, the order confirmation e-mail might say "Good news Joe, your order is on its way" while the apology e-mail might say "Dear Mr Biden, we're sorry but your order isn't on its way" and the parcel might say "Joe Biden, White House, Washington DC"
Should you ask the customer to fill out three different fields?
- jpatokal 12y agoYou rethink that business requirement, because it's virtually impossible to get that right against the full spectrum of names.
- rtb 12y agoYes. There is no other way to get all three cases correct. (If this is a burden on your users, you should consider ways to drop this requirement.)
- alkonaut 12y agoIf you want to be international, you don't even try that. You let the communication say "Dear $Name" and you are done. Even if it means none of the emails say what you want it to say. And yes, even for a US system I don't think it's a good idea to ask for first/initial/last or to ask for formal/informal. Chinese users in the US will be happy to just see a "Name" field. Just ask for a name! I'd stay away from gender/greeting too. Mr/Ms/Mrs/Dr etc. are way too culturally narrow even for the US.
- legulere 12y agoThis might break if the language the name is in has a vocative case http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vocative_case http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vocative_case
- alkonaut 12y agointeresting. If the message is in English, would such rules still apply? We are talking about formatting a message with a foreign name (origin unknown) in a known language, e.g English.
- frenchy 12y agoNot normally. Typically you'd pick the 'least marked' version of the name and just use that.
- userbinator 12y agoIn such a case I would try to change the requirement. This is probably a somewhat unpopular opinion, but if I am giving a name to a system I'm going to put in my full name and that is what I would expect it to always use to refer to me by. Having had some pretty irritating experiences with systems that would only retain or use a piece of the names I gave them (either a family name or given name), resulting in a collision, whenever I feel that is what might happen I give them a concatenation of my names in different orders for the different fields, so if I was John Doe I might enter "Doejohn Johndoe". Apparently I'm not the only one doing this.
- bryanlarsen 12y agoIs it a business requirement to offend people? In some cultures "Good news Joe" is offensive. In others "Dear Mr Biden" is offensive.
- Torgo 12y ago>Is it a business requirement to offend people? Yes, it often is. Years ago in college I worked in an international retail establishment. We were required by policy to address customers by their first names. It was a rural community with many older people, and many people were visibly unhappy being called their first name by a 19 year old kid they didn't know. And as an adult, I find myself in agreement to this day. If I don't know you, why are you calling me by my first name?
- embolalia 12y ago> "Joe Biden, White House, Washington DC" Speaking of web forms and DC, I hate when they have "Washington, DC" listed as the state. Never mind that it isn't a state; at least the territories have to put up with that, so we're not alone. But DC should be in the Ds, not the Ws. Washington is a city, not a state(-like thing), even if it isn't distinct from the district anymore. Well, Washington is a state, but… you know what I mean.