5 ms·
Academically Adrift: Limited Learning on College Campuses (2011)
- JBiserkov 12y agoQ: Why is there so much knowledge in universities? A: The freshman bring some in, if little; the graduates take away practically nothing; so it naturally accumulates there.
- gshubert17 12y ago[2011] -- but still interesting.
- lmartel 12y agoI think the most important data point here is the average of 12-14 hours spent studying per week, including "academic" socializing. Of course you're not going to accomplish much in that time; most employers would fire someone putting in twice that much time for slacking off. The rhetoric for as long as I've been alive (I'm college-aged) has been "get a degree, get a degree" and as it turns out getting a degree isn't very hard. We need to either make it harder or somehow change the rhetoric to "learn something."
- Swizec 12y agoThat's usually 12-14 hours of studying on top of 30-40 hours of classes. At least that's what's expected. What usually ended up happening for me was blowing off 30-40 hours of classes a week, doing some 10-20 hours of studying (including homework and such), and having a near full-time job. Then followed by some 15 hours of studying per day during exams. But I never graduated. So that probably wasn't the best strategy. Although I did get a bunch of solid work experience in my field.
- lmkg 12y ago> That's usually 12-14 hours of studying on top of 30-40 hours of classes. That sounds like an extremely unusual balance of classes vs studying. An 'average' class-load is something like 12-18 credit-hours. That's supposed to mean 12-18 hours of in-class instruction per week. I'm quite curious how you ended up taking 30-40 hours of in-class instruction, and if that was normal compared to your peers. I was told in orientation (in 2003) to expect 2-3 hours of outside work per classroom hour, and my experience matched that. If these students are facing the same expectations that I faced, then they're getting a 1:1 ratio of classroom:outside hours, which is underworking by a significant factor.
- Swizec 12y agoI don't remember what I was told in orientation, but most classes ended up having 2-3 hours of lectures and 2-3 hours of tutorials per week. You were expected to take 5 classes per semester. This gives you a minimum of 5(2+2) = 20 and a maximum of 5(3+3) = 30 hours of classes per week. Which means my original estimate was wrong, but coupled with holes in schedules, potentially taking extra classes in a semester (I think the max I ever did was 7) you easily ended up spending 30-40 hours a week at school if you were going to all your classes. That's how it was at my run-of-the-mill European public University. But I did always get the impression studying in the US was much easier.
- girvo 12y agoInteresting. For the first couple of years, thats exactly what my (double, granted) degree was here in Australia.
- VLM 12y agoI wonder if that is counting lab time. In the hard sciences those can be a killer. "Quantitative Chemical Analysis", that lab seemed to go on forever. Electronics labs were the roughest because they were open and if you "got it" you were done in an hour, or if not, well, that might be a very long day for you. I distinctly remember a microcontroller class where I had 9 years of in family experience (Motorola 8 bit) and I'd be outta there in a half hour but there would be classmates putting in 8 hours because they didn't really understand imperative programming or whatever. In the olden days computer science programming was done in labs because few people had the precise combination of machine / OS / compiler / IDE to match the class requirements, things are a little better now...
- onetimeusename 12y agoI am partial to trying to get people to "learn something". My belief is that when something is known as being hard, a teacher can get away with being mediocre or inept because bad ratings and students failing or low averages can be hand waived away as them not trying hard enough in the "hard" course. I also think the attitude that degree = more $ is at least partially to blame for less rigor. If people think this way then naturally just showing up to class and receiving the diploma are most important and if we are honest that might explain the existence of majors that are not rigorous at all like the ones mentioned.
- watwut 12y ago14 hours a week is 2.8 hours a day (ignoring weekends) on top of classes you spend in school. We had at least 4 hours a day of lectures during first year. That amounts to 6.8 hours a day not counting countless hours during exams time. It is not that little given that most people are unable to focus fully without breaks, so they have to happen too. In addition, you do count unproductive time in work (pointless meeting, small talk with colleague) as a work time. Most people can learn only so much withing a day and can focus only for so long. I would guess that 6.8 hours can be quite close to the point where your focus run out and you are bound to waste the additional time by staring on book (as opposed to learn from it).
- Spooky23 12y agoI guess I've become an old man. I can't think of a class where reading less than 40 pages of material and 20 pages of writing a semester or equivalent ever happened. Even "Intro to East Asian Cinema" required a grueling schedule of 2-3 movies a week plus multiple papers. And I attended a mid-tier public university in the 90s!
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- bcaine 12y agoI'd be curious how the study measured 40 pages of reading each week. My guess is that most, if not all of my classes (Computer Engineering student) have > 40 pages of reading associated with the topics taught each week, but for many of them the reading is never assigned, nor is it ever performed. In my experience, reading only really is necessary when you are really confused on a topic from lecture, miss class, or have a terrible professor. I'd assume its similar across a lot of STEM disciplines (with respect to not actually reading textbooks much).
- Swizec 12y agoI don't know anyone who doesn't read the textbooks or at least the "condensed" slides version with some 500+ slides per class. Not in STEM not anywhere else. It is simply impossible to retain that much information just from going to class, you have to re-read it all before exams. Which is when the reading happens, nobody actually does the reading every week. That's just silly. Man, I wish I went to uni in the US. Every time I hear anything about the US college experience it just sounds like a piece of cake.
- jmspring 12y agoFunny, for the classes I took (and I was often taking 50%+ more than the "average load"), taking notes and listening usually managed to allow me to retain 70+% of the material (across math, physics, chemistry, computer sci/eng classes). The only exception was O-Chem which really did require a lot of extra time outside of the class room. Languages, lit, and polisci were less about retaining specifics and more about interpretation and discourse. But, hell, grad level Dickens class was a lot of reading.
- tuke 12y agoBefore your accept this review at face value, read the book for yourself. This review, like many, fails to note that the data in question regards first- and second-year students (i.e., the second sample is in the third semester -- only 1 1/2 years after starting college). Many of us will recall that we made our big leaps in our junior and senior years, after declaring a major. In a later study, the authors claim that similar observations can be made regarding older students. Still, I would read this book with some skepticism. For a more subtle review, try this one from the New Yorker: http://www.newyorker.com/arts/critics/atlarge/2011/06/06/110606crat_atlarge_menand?currentPage=all http://www.newyorker.com/arts/critics/atlarge/2011/06/06/110...
- crisnoble 12y agoThe link in the story to the book was broken, but this one works: http://press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/A/bo10327226.html http://press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/A/bo1032722...
- nmrm 12y agoComparing my experience in higher education to the constant litany of negative literature on education sends up red flags. I typically write off books/articles in this genre as fear mongering. I've not read this particular book, but a lot like it. The typical pattern is that engineering majors don't see order-of-magnitude in writing and "critical thinking", and humanities students don't see order-to-magnitude improvements in science and math. But then the author averages everything together and concludes no body's learning much. Go figure. Getting a lot of value out of college isn't hard. Attend a state school or reputable private college (read: typically for-profits and online programs are a waste of money; mileage may vary). Once there, major in math, a science, or a core humanity (the latter typically doubled with education or another "practical" major). Meet people and have a good time, but make sure you're spending 30-40 hrs/wk on course work.
- nmrm 12y agoStandardized assessments are an inadequate way to measure outcomes at the higher ed level; the methodology discussed in the article is terminally flawed. I propose that you fundamentally cannot measure what a given person learned or didn't learn in college from a major-agnostic test. Learning at this level is far too specialized. College is NOT and never should be about getting really good at basic skills. These tests treat college as an iteration on elementary and secondary education. For example, I majored in math and now I'm in grad school in a related field. I'm sure I would score about the same -- if not worse -- on a standardized mathematics test now as I did in high school. The tests are generally a combination of calculation/arithmetic and Euclidean geometry. Real mathematics has very little to do with calculation, and I was definitely better at churning out Euclidean-style deductions in high school than I am now (I could trivially recover a lot of the useful clever identities I had internalized in high school, but I haven't looked at that material in years). To conclude that this means I didn't improve tremendously in mathematics during college is just sloppy. In fact, I would be highly unsurprised to see a negative correlation between actual outcomes (number of top tier grad school admissions, desirability in the market place, professional success 5, 10, 15 years after graduation) and institutions which score very highly on these standardized assessments. Iterating on high school is an absurd waste of the college years. edit: computation -> calculation.
- edtechdev 12y agoI'd read up on the Collegiate Learning Assessment (CLA). It addresses the concerns you raised, and it's not aiming to measure some of the things you assert it is measuring. It's not the same thing as the SAT or the GRE. Formative (as opposed to summative) assessments like the CLA are helpful in reforming and improving education. When a high percentage of students are still making the same basic grammatical and writing errors they were as freshmen, that's useful to know. The same thing with mathematical and other skills. It helps convince folks at universities that teaching needs to be reformed, improved to go beyond the standard lecture, homework, and test formula which is ineffective for learning: http://news.sciencemag.org/education/2014/05/lectures-arent-just-boring-theyre-ineffective-too-study-finds http://news.sciencemag.org/education/2014/05/lectures-arent-... See also concept inventories which are tests which are similarly helping measure and assess student conceptual understanding (and misconceptions) in various disciplines (including computer science and mathematics). There are also surveys of student attitudes and engagement and beliefs which are helping improve student learning and retention (like NSSE - the National Survey of Student Engagemen). Then there are non-standard assessments which are helpful for assessing and improving and demonstrating student learning, such as e-portfolios. Learning can be measured. It can be assessed. (As can motivation, beliefs, etc.) And there are some skills we try to help students learn that are indeed major-agnostic. The ability to write and communicate effectively. The ability to critically think about and evaluate information. The ability to work with others. The ability to properly use and apply mathematical and computational tools. Even digital humanities folks are using computational tools to assist their work. Employers are complaining about some college graduates having poor communication skills, having poor programming skills or conceptual understanding of fundamentals (fizz buzz test), etc. There are things that can and should be improved at the college level - at all levels.