5 ms·
"Subjective" means "based on or influenced by personal feelings, tastes, or opinions." Whether or not the choice of theories is subjective on this definition d
by lisper 12y ago
"Subjective" means "based on or influenced by personal feelings, tastes, or opinions." Whether or not the choice of theories is subjective on this definition depends on whether or not you care about the truth. Consider:
Proposition P: Anthropogenic climate change is a myth.
Suppose I subjectively choose a Bayesian prior for proposition P to be very close to 1. I can turn the crank on that and come up with models that are consistent with all the available data. Of course, this will lead me to conclusions that some would consider bizarre ("conspiracy theory" is the pejorative term) but because my feelings, tastes and opinions are just as valid as anyone else's (qua opinions) there is no subjective basis for preferring or rejecting my conclusions. But, of course, there is an objective basis for rejecting my theory because it has more explanatory loose ends than a theory that doesn't have to invoke conspiracies.
Perhaps you want to use subjectivity to choose among theories which are objectively "equivalent" in some sense, i.e. similar explanatory power, agreement with the data, etc. There's nothing preventing you from doing that, but what would be the point? The best you can say objectively is that there is no basis for preferring one theory over another and there's more work left to be done (c.f. string theory). You could pick one theory over another because you think it's "prettier" but so what? If there was anything actually to be gained then (again, by definition) you could have made the selection objectively, not subjectively.