3 ms·
I'm not so sure. The high-energy physics community created an ethically (but not legally) binding agreement on the date of theorist postdoc offers to prevent a
by jessriedel 12y ago
I'm not so sure. The high-energy physics community created an ethically (but not legally) binding agreement on the date of theorist postdoc offers to prevent a useless race for ever earlier commit dates.
>In recent years, we have seen a growing number of early offers with short deadlines for high energy theory postdoctoral positions...We are worried that this practice is preventing young researchers from making a free and fair choice among their job opportunities. And, while there may be some short term advantage for the institutions which do this, we believe it will have serious negative effects in the long run....Thus, we commit to make no postdoctoral offer for the fall of a given year, whose deadline for acceptance is earlier than January 7th of that year.
http://insti.physics.sunysb.edu/itp/postdoc-agreement.html http://insti.physics.sunysb.edu/itp/postdoc-agreement.html
I think all the postdoc applicants generally like this, so it does seem to be in their best interests.
It's very plausible that various private companies have a harder time than HEP professors coordinating on a pledge like this given legal restrictions and the fact that they do not have the common framework of academia. So I think this really could be a prisoner's dilemma.
- rayiner 12y agoThere was a similar agreement among federal judges for the hiring of term clerks. There was much gnashing of teeth when the plan broke down, and judges started hiring two years in advance. But I don't think there is any real prisoner's dilemma. What do the candidates lose? It's great to have a job lined up that far in advance. It lets you plan, especially if you have a family. Its obviously more burdensome for judges that way, but if they didn't think it was worth it to break the plan, they wouldn't have!
- jessriedel 12y agoIf it was beneficial to have the date earlier, then everyone could have just agreed to an earlier date. The problem is that everyone wants a certain date, but defecting employers can benefit by making early job offers with acceptance windows that close before their competitors have made any offers; students are risk adverse and so will accept the earlier offer rather than gamble that they will get a later offer from a better employer. Contrary to your intuition, most people do not want the inflexibility of needing to decide on their next job 2 years ahead. For example, if you're a young law student, you're still learning what kind of law you actually want to work in, and it's very inconvenient to have to choose years ahead of time what court you work in, at which point your academic (or love) interests may have changed.