4 ms·
Were every network to start doing what the BBC is, their unfounded opinions would cease to be heard, Bill Nye wouldn’t have to keep debating them, and maybe, ju
by Karunamon 12y ago
Were every network to start doing what the BBC is, their unfounded opinions would cease to be heard, Bill Nye wouldn’t have to keep debating them, and maybe, just maybe, they’d all just go away.
Not bloody likely. Now you've just put them in the same group as the other conspiracy theorists, and given them the additional (legitimate) ammo that "the establishment is censoring them".
Confirmation bias is a hell of a drug.
- tieTYT 12y agoDevil's advocate: When's the last time a fringe* conspiracy theorist's agenda has been able to effect legislature? EDIT: Added the word "fringe". As in, a conspiracy theory that doesn't get media coverage.
- fahadkhan 12y agoI offer Second Iraq War as a lower bound.
- tptacek 12y agoHPV vaccination jumps to mind.
- Karunamon 12y agoThe "vaccines cause autism" crowd have been successful in carving out "personal exemptions" from otherwise evenly-enforced rules.
- tieTYT 12y agoSorry, I meant "fringe" conspiracy theories. Otherwise my point was kind of off topic to bring up. Imagine if that "vaccines cause autism" crowd didn't get air time. Perhaps they wouldn't get personal exemptions.
- Crito 12y agohttp://fluoridealert.org/content/communities/ http://fluoridealert.org/content/communities/ "Communities Which Have Rejected Fluoridation Since 1990" "Satanic Ritual Abuse" aka Satanic Panic also had a field-day in the courts, if not the legislature.
- alexeisadeski3 12y agoSarBox? FATCA?
- sampo 12y agoThe totally over-restrictive GMO regulation in the European Union is based on very efficient, but scientifically unfounded, propaganda by some NGO's.
- jonnathanson 12y agoIn fairness, and quite unfortunately, I don't think we can call climate change deniers a "fringe." A substantial proportion of the American public denies climate change in one way or another, be it denial of anthropogenic climate change, denial of climate change altogether, or dismissal of the significance of climate change. I don't have the latest figures in front of me, but in the not-too-distant past, deniers polled as a slim majority. The tide seems to be turning, but until quite recently, it was an article of faith (literally, on occasion) among many conservatives that climate change was a liberal-media bogeyman. This was true even among the more respectable conservative publications and commentators, and not just the wackos.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> In fairness, and quite unfortunately, I don't think we can call climate change deniers a "fringe." In terms of science we can. In terms of politics or society we can not, but we can distinguish political reporting from science reporting, even on a scientific issue which has political implications.
- jonnathanson 12y agoSure, but I was responding specifically to the idea that the denial camp (amongst laypeople / GenPop) is a "fringe." In some ways it's dangerous to think of it as such. It's a significant movement with some significant capital behind it, from energy companies and other lobbies. By no means am I suggesting it's a legitimate movement or a non-fringe movement amongst scientists, or that it deserves equal airtime. The viewpoint is largely bunk. Its adherents, however, are legion.
- dragonwriter 12y agoAs "fringe" was defined in the context used upthread in the phrase "fringe conspiracy theorists", it means specifically "ones that don't get [presumably, mainstream] media attention". So, the discussion here is largely about making climate change denial into a fringe by that definition. There certainly are other senses of the word "fringe", some of which they fit, others of which they don't.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- div 12y agoPutting them in the same group as other conspiracy theorists is putting them where they belong.
- jarrett 12y agoFor any given fringe view that the media properly marginalizes, some people will go on believing it. But that doesn't mean the number of believers (or undecided people) will stay the same. It's quite possible, and in my view probable, that reducing airtime from fringe views will substantially reduce the number of people who hold or lean towards those views.
- 7952 12y agoClimate change scepticism is not a fringe view, but moderately widely held. It is hard to believe that those people will suddenly support environmentally literate policy. They will just switch to a different set of trite anecdotes to prove why nothing should change.
- tonfa 12y ago> Climate change scepticism is not a fringe view, but moderately widely held. Is it true for the US? That's definitely not my impression for Europe, it always looked to me that was a belief from a tiny minority.
- jarrett 12y ago> Climate change scepticism is not a fringe view, but moderately widely held Amongst 1) the general public, 2) scientists in general, or 3) climate scientists specifically?
- Karunamon 12y agoYou're at least partly right, but I would argue the conspiracy types are already well acquainted with "alternative" news sources (infowars, Coast to Coast, random bloggers...). Additionally, (and this is just a personal feeling), but something about top-down "reducing airtime from fringe views" feels very wrong. Who decides what a "fringe view" is? By that rubric, Creationism is perfectly legitimate since it's widely held. I think we'd all be better served, morally as well as practically, by letting the loons be loons and let people make their own decisions rather then trying to explicitly control who gets airtime. Bring on the denier and let them get annihilated in a debate against someone who knows what they're talking about. This has the benefit of not invoking censorship boogeymen (which may or may not actually exist) and doesn't hand over the "we're being oppressed" card to them.