3 ms·
correct. Demand-siders have insisted that we all need to start spending more money to kick the economy into gear. Broadly, the only tool to do this is to "pri
by dnautics 12y ago
correct. Demand-siders have insisted that we all need to start spending more money to kick the economy into gear. Broadly, the only tool to do this is to "print money"; read: lower interest rates, twiddle with the reserve ratio requirement, directly pay off banks for certain types of activities.
Supposedly this will make people want to buy things now (instead of later). There is this odd effect though, that increasing prices also can make people insecure, as in: Worldwide, more money is piling into savings than businesses believe they can use to make productive investments. In other words, the people WANT deflation.
The net effect though is we will be transferring wealth from the poor to the rich; and then the bubble will pop, the rich will cash out of their assets early, and people with slower investment classes (401ks, pension funds, etc.) will get screwed. And some of these other people will even get fired, putting them into even greater risk.
I'm not going to defend "supply-side" economics, either, because that's got it's own brand of stupid going on.
There is a modest distinction between bubbles and inflation. While inflation guns bubbles and aggregates small, local bubbles into bigger, systemic bubbles, there can be bubbles during deflationary periods, and systemic inflation doesn't necessarily end in a bubble. Bubbles are characterized by a specific set of price dynamics that are guided by human psychology; the most characteristic, but hardest to notice, is when the asset price collapses, typically around twice the speed that it rose.
- Ma8ee 12y agoIt's nothing wrong with demand side economics in this situation. The problem is that the current policy only make capital available to those who already have more than they know what to do with, such as banks and big investors. The middle class who usually drives demand are still struggling to pay of the mortgage of the house they bought during the bubble.
- praxulus 12y ago>Demand-siders have insisted that we all need to start spending more money to kick the economy into gear. Pretty much. >Broadly, the only tool to do this is to "print money"; read: lower interest rates, twiddle with the reserve ratio requirement, directly pay off banks for certain types of activities. Well, those are the only tools central banks have available to them, but there are much better options. Unfortunately those tools are only available to legislatures, who have decided not to use them.
- bildung 12y agoDemand-siders have insisted that we all need to start spending more money to kick the economy into gear. Broadly, the only tool to do this is to "print money"; read: lower interest rates, twiddle with the reserve ratio requirement, directly pay off banks for certain types of activities. As I have understood demand-side economics, one additional difference to supply-side views is the source of the demand: demand-siders do not only see business investments as the source of demand, but also private consumption. To support that, wages have to rise (as is happening in China). I think that partly explains the currently active basic income discourse in Europe and the US and the introduction of minimum wage in Germany (done by a coalition of center and right parties!). Both instruments would directly benefit the poorer half of the population, who has a low to non-existant savings ratio (in Germany the "poorer" 60% of the population hold only 3% of the privately-held wealth). Increasing wages for these classes would immediately result in more demand.
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoYou've almost completely misunderstood the distinction between "supply-side" economics - which focuses its concept of stimulus on monetary policy - and "demand-side" economics - which focuses its concept of stimulus on fiscal policy. The former kind of stimulus indeed gets you asset bubbles, like the one we're in right now. The latter gets you a healthier economy, but requires legislative approval by entire institutions currently controlled by the financial sector.