7 ms·
This sounds like a good idea, but won't really change anything since everyone will have to pay the new fees, and it's just an arms race. It does not fix this p
by ars 12y ago
This sounds like a good idea, but won't really change anything since everyone will have to pay the new fees, and it's just an arms race.
It does not fix this problem:
"and if there are more transactions than will fit they take the highest-fee transactions first."
So what he's saying is that the bitcoin network can not handle the typical volume of transactions? So you have to prioritize things?
If it can't do it now, today, when it's small, there is simply no way bitcoin is going to grow, which is troubling for the future of bitcoin.
The requirement that every transaction is recorded forever is already causing problem (the block chain is HUGE). And the fees are just a method to try to reduce the side of the data.
Instead a completely different method should be used: A cleanup cycle where old blocks are consolidated and discarded. (The miners agree that the new block is valid, then the old block is no longer needed.)
(Also as a side note bitcoin will never survive past the last mined block. Miners will not continue to mine just for fees, but the amount of entrenched hashing power in place by then means that destroying the network will be trivial for people.)
- voxic11 12y agothere is no last block...
- jMyles 12y agoLast mined block. I assume she (he?) was talking about the last block for which a block discovery fee is paid.
- haakon 12y agoI'm pretty sure you're right about what she was talking about, but to be clear about terminology, all blocks are "mined". To quote the Bitcoin wiki, "Mining is the process of adding transaction records to Bitcoin's public ledger of past transactions."
- xorcist 12y agoThe transaction fees are part of what you call the block discovery fee. As long as there is someone left running the software, blocks will be mined.
- wmf 12y agoSo what he's saying is that the bitcoin network can not handle the typical volume of transactions? So you have to prioritize things? If it can't do it now, today, when it's small, there is simply no way bitcoin is going to grow, which is troubling for the future of bitcoin. Right now miners aren't creating full 1MB blocks because each transaction has a pretty high orphan cost, but this can be fixed (as mentioned in the post). The requirement that every transaction is recorded forever is already causing problem ... Instead a completely different method should be used: A cleanup cycle where old blocks are consolidated and discarded. This is more or less being worked on under the name "ultimate blockchain compression". Miners will not continue to mine just for fees It's not obvious that this is the case, but there could be a problem if the 1MB block size limit is still in place at the next reward halving.
- pmorici 12y agoHave you actually looked at these issues in any detail because I'm fairly certain there are solutions to most of the objections you are raising. You don't need to store the whole block chain there are methods to prune it so to speak so that it takes up significantly less space. The Bitcoin client Multibit already does this. As the transaction volume of the Bitcoin network picks up they can increase the block size so more transactions can be included per block. More transactions means more fees per block. The right combination of transaction volume, block size, and Bitcoin value could certainly make mining for only transaction fees profitable.
- DavidSJ 12y agoIncreasing the maximum block size would cause a hard blockchain fork. That sort of thing has been done before on a couple of occasions but it's by no means a small deal.
- nwh 12y agoYou make them sound casual, bitcoin has has really only had one hard forking change to enable pay-to-script transactions.
- maaku 12y ago> bitcoin has has really only had one hard forking change to enable pay-to-script transactions. ... which wasn't a hard fork. The only hard fork so far was the move from BDB to LevelDB for chain state data.
- makomk 12y agoActually, if I recall correctly the only hardfork so far was accidental. It's far from clear that a deliberate hardfork would ever get community support, particularly given that some of the core developers are strongly opposed to increasing the block size and think that everyone should move to online wallet services and off-chain transactions for small payments instead.
- 12y ago
- weavejester 12y agoSo what he's saying is that the bitcoin network can not handle the typical volume of transactions? The limit is an artificial one, and if the number of transactions starts regularly exceeding the limit, it can be easily raised. the block chain is HUGE 20GB, which I wouldn't class as particularly large. Also as a side note bitcoin will never survive past the last mined block. Given that's around 120 years away, that seems like a pretty long term problem.
- mrb 12y ago"A cleanup cycle where old blocks are consolidated and discarded" Already implemented by multiple clients, and already envisioned by Satoshi in 2008. See Simplified Payment Verification (SPV): https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Thin_Client_Security#Header-Only_Clients https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Thin_Client_Security#Header-Only_... (wiki page out-of-date - this is an incomplete list of clients.) The storage requirements of an SPV client only grow by 4MB/year regardless of how many transactions the global network processes. See section 7 of https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf "Miners will not continue to mine just for fees" Yes they will. Most of the observed mining power continued mining through the first reward halving of Nov 2012. This is because miners have different operating costs. So the few that stopped mining actually caused a small difficulty drop (~10% IIRC), which made it a bit more profitable for those who continued mining, so the network stabilized at a slightly lower hashrate (before it continued increasing again in Jan-Feb 2013.) This demonstrates that mining is an economically self-adjusting activity that can survive 50% drops in mining income. And the disappearance of the fixed reward in year ~2140 will NOT be an event where more than 50% of your mining income disappear overnight [2] so Bitcoin mining is economically viable forever, theoretically. [1] https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Controlled_supply https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Controlled_supply [2] Fees currently average ~0.05 BTC/block. The fixed reward is 25 BTC/block today and decreases smoothly by halving every ~4 years, therefore it should reach 0.04882812 BTC by year ~2048 [1]. This means even assuming fees never grow beyond 0.05 BTC/block (eg. Bitcoin's adoption stagnates), fees will already represent most of a miner's income by year 2048. Subsequent reward halvings (0.04882812 BTC to 0.02441406 BTC in year ~2052, etc) will be insignificant compared to the income from fees. And the disappearance of fixed rewards in year 2140 will be an even less significant event. Fees will have already represented the majority of mining income for the previous ~100 years.
- imaginenore 12y ago> So what he's saying is that the bitcoin network can not handle the typical volume of transactions? So you have to prioritize things? No, it has to do with fighting spam and DoS attacks. If there's no lower bound for the fee, and there's no prioritization, there's nothing stopping anybody from sending trillions of transactions to trillions of addresses non-stop. > the block chain is HUGE No, it's not. It's 20GB. Many modern games are larger than that. A 4TB hard drive can be bought for $120. 20GB of that represents the total cost of $0.60. Oh noes!
- DSMan195276 12y ago20GB still isn't something to scoff at if it wants wide-spread adoption. It's huge when you consider that anybody who wants to attempt to run Bitcoin has to download all 20GB just to get things installed. I have approximately a 1.5MB download speed. The space on my HD I can live without, but I gave-up trying to get the bitcoin-qt program to sync after about a week (I ran it mostly non-stop - I obviously wasn't getting anywhere near 1.5MB down, syncing the block-chain is slow) and just bought the little bitcoin I wanted straight into an exchange and then bought the other coins I was planning to buy anyway so I didn't have to mess with bitcoin myself. The fact is, in it's current state the huge block-chain makes bitcoin anything but user-friendly.
- lockes5hadow 12y agoYou don't have to download the whole block-chain to use bitcoin.
- simcop2387 12y agoWhile true, I don't believe many clients make it easy to do that still.
- dustcoin 12y agoNearly every mobile client does not download the blockchain and instead uses SPV (Simple Payment Verification / headers only mode) or relies on a trusted server for block information.
- sanswork 12y agoBitcoin can currently handle about 7 transactions per second. Currently it averages around 0.8 transactions per second so its a ways to go before it hits that(by comparison Visa does ~2000/per second average).
- ikawe 12y agoInteresting - where did these figures come from?
- sanswork 12y ago7tps is done by figuring out the max block size divided by the average size of transactions. For the other numbers: https://blockchain.info/charts/n-transactions-per-block https://blockchain.info/charts/n-transactions-per-block each block is about 10 minutes so that gives us around 0.7tps The Visa number from https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Scalability https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Scalability though it looks like Visa redid their site since the source was added so you'd have to search to find the actual source though http://usa.visa.com/merchants/industry-solutions/retail-visa-acceptance.jsp http://usa.visa.com/merchants/industry-solutions/retail-visa... says they can burst to 24K TPS.
- ghshephard 12y ago"(Also as a side note bitcoin will never survive past the last mined block" Okay, I'll bite. What will the $USD value be of all aggregate fees be at that point versus the average cost of hashing that block? If, in fact the cost is greater, then doesn't that suggest fewer people will be interested in mining, which means that the cost will drop? Seems to me there is a nice feedback loop there.
- dustcoin 12y agoIt is true that if mining revenues fall, less profitable miners will drop off, lowering the difficulty, eventually reaching an equilibrium where some population of miners continue to mine. The big question is: Will the amount of hashpower willing to mine for only transaction fees be enough to secure the network against 51% attacks?
- ghshephard 12y agoOne target for transactions is about 4,000 transactions/second. If they reduce the confirm time to 60 seconds like DogeCoin, then we are looking at about 240,000 transaction fees per block. Figure $0.10/transaction, that's about $24,000 per block. Right now it's 25 * $600, or $15,000 block - so, I can see there being a future on transaction fees on Bitcoin Alone. But - there are a lot of other really interesting applications that can be run on the block chain, and I can see people willing to pay much greater transaction fees than $0.10 to get their transaction recorded on the block chain - so plenty of interesting opportunities.
- tlrobinson 12y ago"This sounds like a good idea, but won't really change anything since everyone will have to pay the new fees, and it's just an arms race." I don't think Gavin or anyone else claimed it did. This change is just one of several needed to solve these problems. "Instead a completely different method should be used: A cleanup cycle where old blocks are consolidated and discarded. (The miners agree that the new block is valid, then the old block is no longer needed.)" Satoshi described "pruning" in the original whitepaper, and it doesn't require a protocol change. "Also as a side note bitcoin will never survive past the last mined block." Fortunately that's at least 100 years away. I think that should be enough time to transition to a different incentive structure.