I actually agree, but I think it's a debate worth having. Clearly, this system works for Hacker School. Kudos. This system is also being advertised for wider

I actually agree, but I think it's a debate worth having. Clearly, this system works for Hacker School. Kudos. This system is also being advertised for wider implementation, possibly into communities and companies that all of us are a part of, and any broad social reform deserves a good deal of scrutiny before implementation. A key part of these rules, in particular, is the potential for abuse and the sorts of implications they have on the culture that implements them.