3 ms·
"Shaming rituals, however light in touch they are, rarely improve things. They're just another small-p political tool to be used by politically minded people to
by mcguire 12y ago
"Shaming rituals, however light in touch they are, rarely improve things. They're just another small-p political tool to be used by politically minded people to exert social control."
This is absolutely true. The only thing that will improve someone's manners is their mother slapping them when they got out of hand while growing up. Once they're an adult, their concepts of social roles and the appropriate ways of interacting with others are fixed. The only path of improvement is for them to die off.
- HarrietJones 12y agoThanks for the sarcasm. We're not talking about egregious examples of bad behaviour. These subtle-isms are vague; they're hard to identify and explain; they crop up unconsciously. It's not bad manners if you don't know you've upset someone, or you're unaware that you're enforcing damaging social norms. We should change & we should question our moral compasses. For me, this is an absolute. But the proposed solution only works in situations where all actors are acting in good faith. It's too easily subverted. I have no beef with Hacker School for trying this, but time and again, groups that work within these frameworks devolve into politicking and rules lawyering.