3 ms·
> Just because I don't believe what you claim, doesn't mean I believe the opposite. Do you still not believe most email is formatted at 78 characters? Really?
by nailer 12y ago
> Just because I don't believe what you claim, doesn't mean I believe the opposite.
Do you still not believe most email is formatted at 78 characters? Really? I've stated my reasoning, you haven't refuted that or explained any alternative.
> it might just be that 78 character plain text mails are actually inherently superior to all the alternatives
No, we've already discussed why they're worse and you haven't even attempted to rebut it.
> Maybe you want to read the LKML's actual FAQ?
Yes, I have, and I'm aware that Linux kernel developers have other ideas about email workflows, eg, not 'top posting', again, they not representative of common email use cases, for the same reasons I have mentioned earlier, which you have not refuted in any way.
> Email clients have more qualities than their ability to parse emails with lines longer than 78 chars
They do, but displaying email is a critical part of email clients.
> Other than that, your thinking seems to be pretty one-dimensional.
Another part of email list etiquette: read the rules or go somewhere else: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 12y ago> Do you still not believe most email is formatted at 78 characters? Really? I've stated my reasoning, you haven't refuted that or explained any alternative. You've essentially stated that you don't know either (you haven't really read your users' emails, have you?), and I have explained why it doesn't matter anyhow, so I don't see any need to refute anything. > No, we've already discussed why they're worse and you haven't even attempted to rebut it. No, we haven't. > they not representative of common email use cases (a) Yes, they are - are you maybe confusing use cases (what it's for) with workflows (how it's applied to that use case)? (b) How exactly is that even relevant? Because linux kernel developers are not representative of email users, it's fine to break email in a way that doesn't work for linux kernel developers? I mean, kinda my whole initial point was that exactly that is terrible engineering. > for the same reasons I have mentioned earlier Actually, you haven't. > which you have not refuted in any way. As such, there is little to refute. > They do, but displaying email is a critical part of email clients. so? > Another part of email list etiquette: Part of that is that you sincerely try to understand the other side's position, don't quote out of context, don't misrepresent, don't just repeat talking points without actually considering and addressing the other side's arguments, question your own implicit assumptions, ... - that avoids the frustration that you are seeing there.