4 ms·
Youtube.com couldn't show my logged-in state from a google.com server then?
by sp332 12y ago
Youtube.com couldn't show my logged-in state from a google.com server then?
- jacquesm 12y agoWhy should it? It's a different domain, therefore a different entity as far as the web is concerned.
- x1798DE 12y agoWith third-party cookies turned off, youtube.com definitely shouldn't be able to show your logged-in state from a google.com server. They generally play some fancy footwork with redirects to deliberately break third-party cookie origin parties so that they can achieve "single sign-in". I, personally, would prefer it if this were not possible, but it seems unlikely that Google would find this a desirable outcome. Personally, I isolate my logged-in Google services in their own separate browser. I was hoping to find (or write) a browser plugin which opens URLs in different browsers based on regex of some sort (i.e. *.google.com, gmail.com, youtube.com links open in Chrome, everything else in Firefox), but I believe this is difficult to achieve because of the way browser sandboxing works (at least in Chrome).
- michaelt 12y agoYoutube could use OAuth, just like other sites that let you sign in with Google or Facebook. The only difference is when you click to log in, your browser is briefly forwarded to a google.com server that then forwards you back. That, and it's much better for security.