3 ms·
"I really like the idea of being able to encode a consumable transaction that both authorizes the transfer and encodes the transfer amount." This occurs in EMV
by Nursie 12y ago
"I really like the idea of being able to encode a consumable transaction that both authorizes the transfer and encodes the transfer amount."
This occurs in EMV transactions. It's not exactly as you describe but there are a lot of similarities. Effectively, in your scenario, your credit card becomes your signing token.
--edit--
Just to give you a bit more detail, there is mutual auth (terminal to card, card to terminal, card to payment process and payment processor to card), and the card creates a cryptogram from various pieces of transaction data (date/time, amount, customer verification method used etc etc).
- objclxt 12y agoEMV is all very well and good (to be clear, without a cryptogram the payment can't be charged), but it falls down because of the requirement for backwards compatibility. For physical, retail transactions the easy way out of this is a liability shift (make the retailer liable for any fraudulent transactions that aren't run using EMV), but it's much harder for card-not-present (online) transactions, where people just type in card numbers and go.
- jon-wood 12y agoFor cardholder not present transactions there's 3D Secure[1], which sits in the middle of online transactions. Customers fill in their details on the merchant's site, then redirect to a service run by their card provider which asks for some form of authentication that only the provider knows about, and then a token is passed back to the merchant which can be used to authenticated the transaction. Much as in store transactions which aren't conducted with Chip & PIN transfer liability to the merchant, online transactions without 3D Secure will also transfer liability, giving merchants a potentially hefty incentive to verify the customer's identity. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/3-D_Secure http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/3-D_Secure
- josephlord 12y agoI hate this model. Try to buy something get redirected to a 4th party (not the retailer, buyer or the bank / card issuer) and get asked to enter private secret information. It teaches all the wrong things about security.
- vertis 12y agoIn the Australian Commonwealth Bank's implementation, this is a code that they SMS to my phone. No personal details, just MFA. Works pretty well. Edit: Also, it isn't a 4th party, the bank runs the service themselves.
- josephlord 12y agoI'd be happy with that but it doesn't match the experience I have with the my credit card (or my debit card but I barely use that at all).
- Nursie 12y agoWell yes, for physical transactions there is the back compat issue, but hopefully as more countries take up the scheme (hint hint USA) we'll have less and less need of fallback. I agree that a system for verifying/authorising specific amounts for online transactions would be a good thing, and I agree that the "here's my card info, charge what you like" model is a bad one.