2 ms·
In any quality legal system there's no such thing as "stretching the boundaries of legality". It's either allowed, or it's not. Once you get into the realm of r
by mike_hearn 12y ago
In any quality legal system there's no such thing as "stretching the boundaries of legality". It's either allowed, or it's not. Once you get into the realm of random bureaucrats issuing opinions that define law you enter a whole world of pain (see: EU right to be forgotten, FTC child protection regulations, US SDN list).
Tax law, being very old and quite well worked out, is pretty specific. Starbucks is not breaking tax law by doing this unless governments give into temptation and try to retroactively change the rules.
The core problem is that attempting to slice up the profits of a fundamentally international business is a losing proposition that can ONLY end in bitter arguments. It's not surprising there are a billion loopholes; it can never be any different. Who is to say what Starbucks beans are worth? If you go in and say, well that's obviously "tax avoidance", you'll immediately hit lots of other much less clear cut cases. But once you abandoned the rules there won't be any way to decide on those less clear cut cases and it'll just turn into chaos.
- DanBC 12y ago> In any quality legal system there's no such thing as "stretching the boundaries of legality". Of course there is. Law is what's on the statute books and also how the courts interpret that. Some tax schemes seem to follow the letter of the law, but not the system, and the courts may well rule against them. > Who is to say what Starbucks beans are worth? There are a bunch of methods. You could use naive measures such as cost of beans + cost of roasting + transport and labour costs + X%; or you could compare market costs of other roasted beans; but it's probably a good idea to have a look at the effect of the expense of those beans on the company that they are sold to. And the beans are so expensive that the company make no profit, and thus avoids tax.
- mike_hearn 12y agoSo I set X% to be whatever I need to minimise profit at my subsidiaries. Who are you to say X% is wrong? Did you build a successful coffee company? Law is interpreted by the courts according to what it says, not according to what would be convenient at the time. This is why you hear about people getting off on a technicality. At least that's how it's supposed to work. If you look at the right to be forgotten, the problem there is that the underlying law is so vague that basically anything can be read into it. So then judges end up legislating from the bench, which they aren't meant to do, that's why we have separation of powers.
- mverwijs 12y agoHow fondly I remember these types of discussions at the HFT company I worked for. "We're not doing anything illegal.", they'd say. "The law allows for this." I've learned that as soon as a company says something like that, they're doing something ethically shady. Like applying for government funding when replacing whole datacenters full of slow, old, energy-slurping HP servers. How old? 6 months old. "But these new machines are much more eco-friendly than the ones we're currently running. So we're entitled to government funding for replacing all those bad bad units with more eco-friendly units!" After replacing those machines with more energy-efficient (and faster!) machines, we'd make more money in a day than most of us will make in a lifetime. The 6 month old machines got scrap-heaped. With money that the Government was supposed to have spend on ecologically sound business cases. We weren't doing anything illegal. But it sure felt like it.
- justincormack 12y agoThe law does say that manipulating transfer pricing is illegal. However it is hard to prosecute where the thing being transferred is non tradeable (eg IP is sold to local subsidiaries in many od these cases not just coffee).