5 ms·
Such a system is unworkable. Where are the profits "made" exactly? You can have sales tax, but governments already do that and they aren't satisfied. The reaso
by mike_hearn 12y ago
Such a system is unworkable. Where are the profits "made" exactly? You can have sales tax, but governments already do that and they aren't satisfied.
The reason taxing a person's income is (relatively) easy is because you can't split a person up. Just count the number of days they spend in a country, if it goes over a certain level then they are resident for tax purposes and away you go. America ignores this of course with citizen based taxation a.k.a. modern slavery but in all the other civilised countries that's how it works.
Now consider Google. A German user goes to YouTube and sees an advert. Is this money made in Germany? Or was it made in America, where the software was developed? Or in America and Switzerland because there's a YouTube team in Switzerland too? Or was it made in Finland where the request was actually processed? Or was it made in Canada because that's where the advertiser is? Or was it made in Ireland because the advertisers contract was with Google Ireland Ltd?
Pretty quickly you realise this is a fools errand. There's no way to say where the money was made in such an international operation. Any definition you come up with will be fought over by governments endlessly because they all want to buy votes by taxing foreign companies which smells to them a lot like free money (and thus free voters).
So we end up with the simplest definition possible - the money is made where the company is headquartered. The headquarters can be anywhere. This solution was arrived at in both America and Europe. It sorta worked for a while because most companies were already established and new companies were small and poor so nobody cared about them much. Now we have the phenomenon of new companies that are extremely profitable, do all their business on the internet and therefore could pick a country to headquarter in purely for tax reasons. Cue moaning and wailing from stupid politicians who ran up enormous debts and now want a bigger slice of the pie.
But attempting to change this simple definition will just reopen pandora's box.
The best solution would be to just finish off the race to the bottom entirely and push corporate tax rates to zero everywhere. This would yield an approximately 25% hole in for example the UK budget. However the money can be made up elsewhere, such as by increasing VAT or personal income taxes. Of course that is politically difficult - people like corporation taxes because they don't like corporations, and taxing them feels like free money too.
- justincormack 12y agoThats not going to happen. We are going to tax these companies. Sales in the EU can and are regulated and taxed, the problem is some issues like varying tax rates (Luxembourg) and various issues like the double Irish Dutch sandwich (that Apple invented) which was based on differences between tax definitions between countries. These can and will be fixed. Just because you, personally, hate government spending, does not mean we are going to remove corporation tax. Putting all taxes directly on a few prices, like increasing VAT (retail sales) or income tax (cost of hiring labour) is far more distortionary than spreading taxes between more prices (like returns on capital, as roughly corporation taxes are).
- mike_hearn 12y agoI don't hate government spending, what makes you think that? What I hate (perhaps hate is a strong word) is arbitrary and vague systems of laws. Corporation tax is riddled with these and it just undermines confidence in all government. You say yourself these "loopholes" are nothing more than disagreements between governments about how tax works. Thus the "solution", if you want to call it that, is that countries have to stop competing on tax rates. If Greece wants to charge corporation tax of 80% then everyone else has to as well otherwise they're enabling avoidance? That makes no sense and is fundamentally against national sovereignty. Low corporation taxes are quite popular amongst the Irish because they correctly perceive that it leads to lots of jobs. Who are we to say that they got it wrong? We can see how arbitrary this all is with the fact that these companies, which have done business this way for years in full view of national governments, are only now getting investigated once government spending cuts start making politicians unpopular. If these arrangements actually were illegal under clearly defined law they would have been investigated and tried a long time ago. IIRC the OECD thinks corporation tax has much higher deadweight costs than other forms of tax. I read this in an interesting article on the subject here: http://www.theregister.co.uk/2012/11/25/tax_and_tech_biz/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2012/11/25/tax_and_tech_biz/ .. however the original link was dead last time I looked.
- justincormack 12y agoThe problem abot making a precise tax system is that then getting round it is easy. Simplicity is clearly a key point, but somehow our political processes are not very good at that alas. Corporation tax also has huge subsidies, eg allowing interest on debt as an expense should go, which would allow the rate to be cut. No deductions should be allowed on any tax...
- ulfw 12y agoIn Google's case (as in your example) it's incredibly easy: money is generated where a human being (a user) clicks on an add and thus generates ad dollars. If a German user clicks on it, money is generated in Germany. It's the same with physical sales. If a customer buys something (from say a Chinese company) in France, then money is generated in France.