3 ms·
Excerpt from the post that apparently attracted the "social justice warriors": > I'm currently dating two lovely women, Svetlana and Elise. Unfortunately conti
by danso 12y ago
Excerpt from the post that apparently attracted the "social justice warriors":
> I'm currently dating two lovely women, Svetlana and Elise. Unfortunately continuing to date both of them is unsustainable so I must choose one. In order to make such a choice, I wish to construct a ranking function - a function which takes as input the characteristics of a woman and returns as output a single number. This ranking function is meant to approximate my utility function - a higher number means that by making this choice I will be happier. If the ranking closely approximates utility, then I can use the ranking function as an effective decisionmaking tool. In concrete terms, I want to build a function f:Women→ℝ which approximately predicts my happiness. If f(Svetlana)>f(Elise) I will choose Svetlana, and vice versa if the reverse inequality holds.
Yeah I don't think readers who disliked your choice of "models" necessarily count as "social justice warriors." I figured the post itself was just meant to troll people in an attempt to show how superior your powers of logic and math were.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoPeople complaining about nonexistent sexism on the interwebs are, almost by definition, social justice warriors. If you read the post, you'll find it answers a strange math puzzle. That's it's purpose. The example is given simply so that a reader can more easily understand what's going on.
- danso 12y agoYeah, see...no one questions that it purports to be about mathematics. The problem that some seem to have is, what does math have to do with lingerie models? I can't speak for the other machine-learning amateurs, but I found your "real world" example to be unhelpful in explaining the math...maybe because I couldn't get past my preconception that choosing between just two prospective dating partners is in many ways, not a problem that calls for machine learning. And maybe your retort would be, "Well duh, the checklist theory outlined here could be applied to a large group of prospective suitors to efficiently filter them"...well, then why was that not the example to begin with? Because even a sample of, say 10, would seemingly render the example checklist to be non-decisive...which then leads to the question of how to efficiently pick binary features that are relevant to the decision-making process...because it seems kind of a no-brainer to argue that you shouldn't apply a ML-algorithm to a sample size of 2. Now, if you had consistently referred to the setup of dating lingerie models as you explained the math, then maybe you could more believably argue that, "Hey, lingerie models make this math easier to understand"...but you didn't. You discard the scenario quite early on, which makes some people think that the scenario was a bit gratuitous, as if the author's intent is to subtly say, "Hey, I'm not only a math genius, but I can appreciate a hot woman!" Which, sure, isn't the kind of sexism that 19th-century-era women faced, but it also doesn't seem to add to any kind of mathematical understanding.
- yummyfajitas 12y agomaybe because I couldn't get past my preconception that choosing between just two prospective dating partners is in many ways, not a problem that calls for machine learning. Actually, the difficulty was that you couldn't get past your preconception that the post was about machine learning. I didn't claim anywhere that I was writing about ML. The section entitled Why not use machine learning (TM)? may reduce your confusion. In any case, only one of the complaints about the post was even remotely as articulate as yours (which is quite orthogonal to the "sexism" and "racism" claims). Which, sure, isn't the kind of sexism that 19th-century-era women faced, but it also doesn't seem to add to any kind of mathematical understanding. The clause about sexism in this sentence confuses me. It implies, without actually stating, that the post does contain sexism but of a different sort. Could you clarify?