6 ms·
> Last month, Google announced its plan to spend $50 million over the next three years encouraging young women to give coding a try. The website for the project
by tzs 12y ago
> Last month, Google announced its plan to spend $50 million over the next three years encouraging young women to give coding a try. The website for the project features articles about inspiring women, like Erica Kochi, who leads UNICEF's Innovation Unit. The first item on a page of coding projects for girls to try is a 3-D-printed bracelet.
> "It's insulting, not only because it's highly gendered, but also because it perpetuates this idea of women as consumeristic and narcissistic," said Losh. "It's kind of like a trifecta of badness."
Professor Losh needs to do some field research. A few hours hanging out in a mall or other place popular with young people will show that a large fraction of young women do in fact do seem to have quite an interest in jewelry.
Including a 3D bracelet project sends the message to young women who have not considered coding that it can be a part of their current world. It's something they can apply to their lives, not something they have to change their lives in order to use.
What's insulting is Losh's implicit assumption that women who wear bracelets must be doing it because they are narcissistic and consumeristic. Why can't they wear them for aesthetic reasons? Or sentimental reasons?
- detcader 12y agoWhere do you think female interest in jewelry comes from? Are you implying that interest in jewelry is inborn in women? You are begging the question. The professor is concerned with general culture's image of women, which is perpetuated when female programmers are shown to be printing pink jewelry and perpetually enraptured by childish flowery borders. The existence of individual women who enjoy jewelry for the aesthetics are of no consequence to what the professor is concerned with. You are responding to an assumption that isn't there, but rather one you've imagined as a substitute for an understanding of the her social analysis. >"It says that the only way you can be interested in technology is if it is girly," said Wheat. "I'm very girly. My room is purple. I have floral bedding. I think I'll probably be a very feminine engineer. I just don't like the idea of being pigeonholed."
- guard-of-terra 12y ago"Are you implying that interest in jewelry is inborn in women?" This is an extremelly important question with regards to history of our species, so if you by some chance have an answer be sure to share it with us along with rationale.
- detcader 12y agoIt's not. Such a thing would be impossible. Look up "gender socialization" and read about girlhood: http://www.metafilter.com/121190/teenage-girls-they-havent-been-living-theyve-been-performing http://www.metafilter.com/121190/teenage-girls-they-havent-b... http://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/womens-blog/2014/jan/10/little-girls-deserve-better-toys-sexism http://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/womens-blog/2014/jan... http://sodisarmingdarling.tumblr.com/post/34106027759/what-its-like-being-a-teen-girl http://sodisarmingdarling.tumblr.com/post/34106027759/what-i... http://rebeccahains.wordpress.com/2014/01/20/is-my-son-smart-is-my-daughter-skinny/ http://rebeccahains.wordpress.com/2014/01/20/is-my-son-smart...
- guard-of-terra 12y agoThe articles you quote, while flamebait, don't try to answer the forementioned question. As for "impossible" - why?
- detcader 12y agoThat women talking about being girls is "flamebait" says more about you than the articles.
- spindritf 12y agoWhy would a tendency to adorn oneself not be innate? Seems pretty universal to me. Why should nurture be the default assumption? I'm sorry but your answer is terrible, akin to "look up sexual selection and read about genetics."
- detcader 12y ago"a tendency to adorn" is not the same as "a tendency to adorn oneself with jewelry", which is what I've been talking about -- are you talking to me? Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. Why should the non-existence of God be the default assumption?
- andrewflnr 12y agoIt doesn't really matter why women like jewelry. It seems to me (as a man (with a sister)) that if it's not biological, it's sufficiently deeply ingrained as to make little difference in the short term. That's where they are today, so it at least makes sense to try to talk to them there. But I think you and I agree it should not be the central point. We've got to figure out how to teach math properly.
- detcader 12y agoPop-up ads make sense too, don't they?
- andrewflnr 12y agoIn a sense, but that's a bad analogy. If you want to make unflattering comparisons to advertising, the general concept of targetted advertising is closer.
- jorgis 12y agoPassing out mirrors and nail files at a social event for women interested in programming is like passing out hammers and dimensional lumber at a social event for men interested in fashion design.
- jiggy2011 12y agoProbably more like passing out deodorant or shaving kits.
- tzs 12y ago> Where do you think female interest in jewelry comes from? Are you implying that interest in jewelry is inborn in women? You are begging the question I don't care where it comes from. Do you think that if a woman likes jewelry, she needs to justify it as some inborn attraction before it is acceptable?
- detcader 12y agoYour comments that "women at the mall seem to like jewelry" eminates the implicit assumption that this is a natural trend that will persist deterministically (as in, women who don't like jewelry are natural outliers). I am merely inquiring what that assumption is actually based on.
- taeric 12y agoYou are assuming the natural part. The original comment was simply about dominant view. Could it be that it is strictly societal based? Yeah, why not? Does that change things? Remember, the desire is to get women into technology. Not to change societal norms on anything else.
- mercer 12y agoI find that an important question to ask when it comes to these discussions is whether the goal is to be pragmatic toward reaching a specific goal or to be 'correct'. Another important question is asking yourself to what extent one can achieve both, as that would be preferable. I haven't spent a lot of time thinking about this, so I could be very wrong. However, I'm inclined to think that if the goal is to get more (young) women to work in tech, making things more 'girly' might not be a bad idea. Ideally this would not be necessary, and I don't consider the approach 'correct', but as one of the possible approaches it might be the most pragmatic. And there could be plenty of initiatives in parallel that take a more correct or ideological approach. This reminds me a bit of a workshop I heard about from a friend. It was a whiskey and wool event where participants would do whiskey tasting (with a Scottish-looking man guiding them), but also learn how to knit. The goal was specifically to get guys to try knitting, and it was very effective. These kinds of things can be fine, in my opinion, as long as they're not the only options. Then again, I'm not a woman, so I don't know if perhaps it's more offensive than it seems to me.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- informatimago 12y agoThe whole discussion of women+tech is insulting! Guys weren't baby fed tech! They just grab it and have fun with it. Girls can grab it all the same: it's just knowledge. Computers and books are as available to girls as to boys. I don't say in the 70's when computer access was limited, perhaps boys could jostle to gain access to the computer console better than girls; but the reality is that at that time, girls would just shun and mock boys interested in computers: geeks and nerds never have been "popular". I'm not sure it has much changed for a long time, until they realized that big money could be made by some in computers. And even now, it only goes as far as how much money is made in computing. If you look at: http://www.statisticbrain.com/startup-failure-by-industry/ http://www.statisticbrain.com/startup-failure-by-industry/ You see that computing startups are the ones that are less likely to be still operating after 4 years (at 37%). Therefore I'm not surprised that girls are not interested in computing! If you want more girls in computing, then make it more profitable and more reliable. Eliminate the risk!