6 ms·
I think that's a cool idea, but in practice it doesn't seem to lead to very fun gameplay. It means a large swath of monsters: jellies, giant insects, wolves, be
by munificent 12y ago
I think that's a cool idea, but in practice it doesn't seem to lead to very fun gameplay. It means a large swath of monsters: jellies, giant insects, wolves, bears, spiders, serpents, etc. wouldn't drop anything. You'd end up basically just trying to kill "monsters" that are humans. To me, that's not very fun.
> You can combine this with a trinket generator to give each one a little more flavor.
I do have that. They are "powers" and work similar to items in Diablo where they can be a prefix or suffix on the name of the item and modify its stats. So you can get a "Glimmering Stick of Wounding".
> This also means that, by definition, a mob can never drop an inappropriate item.
I did try this, but my experience was that it made killing mobs predictable and boring. "Oh, look, the wizard dropped yet another robe." I deliberately sacrificed realism (which is of limited value in my book anyway) to get a more exciting, surprising game.
> Some loot traditionally comes from the body of the monster itself, like a rat's tail or a wolf's fur which you can bring to the next merchant or quest-giver for reward. A more natural method of doing it would be solely through the skill/crafting system, instead of dropping pre-defined animal parts just because they happen to be important to some quest.
I do have that too. There is a "crucible" in the "town" where you can combine items to make new ones (again similar to Diablo). It's a fun mechanic, but I don't want to lean to heavily on it. I find games where you go into the dungeon, amass a pile of rat's tails, sell them, repeat, to be super boring.
- ars 12y ago> It means a large swath of monsters: jellies, giant insects, wolves, bears, spiders, serpents, etc. wouldn't drop anything Sure they would - a jelly drops a potion made from its body, the other animals have stingers, teeth and claws that are excellent weapons, and skin or plates that make armor. A petrified dead snake makes a great wand. A web from a spider can be used as a trap item (throw it at someone and "stun" them for a time). Make it reusable by pulling back the cord attached to it. A bear arm makes a sword-like slashing weapon.
- Gravityloss 12y agoIf going for realism, it could be argued that rare ferocious beasts, or their unique body parts could have very high trophy value (as opposed to humans). Just witness the extinction of many real life species that are killed for perceived magical qualities of a small body part. For added realism, it makes it easy to just leave the body to rot and sell the small rhino horn to shady criminals. For added effect, if they are rare enough, they become more valuable the more you kill them...
- xerophtye 12y ago>I did try this, but my experience was that it made killing mobs predictable and boring. "Oh, look, the wizard dropped yet another robe." I deliberately sacrificed realism (which is of limited value in my book anyway) to get a more exciting, surprising game. My opinion is somewhere between the two. While yes, repetitive loot is boring, seeing an enemy shoot fireballs at me and knowing its because of an item he has (an item i can loot), has its own thrill. "ooo! i want that!". It makes battles more fun, knowing that you are gonna get something cool.
- moomin 12y agoDCSS works exactly like this: plenty of monsters don't drop anything useful. The other mobs rarely drop anything that useful (except for ammo). Actually, it turns out to be a great game.
- kibwen 12y agoI agree that DCSS is a great game, but I think that its loot system leaves much to be desired. Don't get me wrong, the user interface for item and inventory management is smooth as buttered silk (if you know your history, this is in fact the reason for DCSS's ascendance in the first place), but it merely serves to make tolerable the practice of sifting through mountains of worthless garbage to get at the goodies. In fact, I'd go so far as to say that monster drops in DCSS are universally useless, with the following exceptions: corpses, artifacts dropped by unique monsters, and a few god abilities that are powered by dungeon trash (with Jiyva's being the only one that's actually interesting). Other than that, all interesting items in the player's possession will have generated either randomly or via vault loot.
- moomin 12y agoYeah, ammo (especially early game) is useful, but rarely vital. Blowguns are pretty important. But nearly everything is absolute trash. On the other hand, I'm pretty sure it's a deliberate design decision to keep the item supply under tight control.
- pdpi 12y agoThe Elder Scrolls series is pretty close to implementing exactly this in practice, and they solved this conundrum in an interesting way: To enchant gear, you need souls. Normally, you can't humanoid souls for this purpose (unless you use black soul gems, which are scarce and not seen in a good light), so you basically get gear from humanoids, and alchemy/enchanting bits from monsters.
- ebrenes 12y agoIn contrast this was one of the things I most liked about Everquest (in its early releases). First, most loot had a reason to be there and some logic to it. You need bone chips? You'd go whack a skeleton. You needed some beetle eyes? Go whack a beetle. Bear meat or skin? Go hunt for bears. It gave the world a cohesiveness and logic that you didn't even have to think about. Also in the early days you could give mobs items and they would equip them. If you traded a sword and shield with a skeleton and it would drop those back to you when you killed it. This was also pretty cool, because you could tell what damage to expect from the mobs based on what the mob looked like. If it was a skeleton wielding a staff you knew you'd found a catch because those would sell for a pretty penny. Later on, in subsequent zones that all started to break down a bit more. But overall, I think it kinda retained this in essence. Had the game had a stronger crafting mechanic behind it (instead of being broken from the get go), it would have been quite interesting. I agree whole heartedly on the just blindly gathering 100's of rat tails or wolf pelts being boring beyond redemption. But there's some charm to being able to hunt for what you need.
- Udo 12y ago> It means a large swath of monsters: jellies, giant insects, wolves, bears, spiders, serpents, etc. wouldn't drop anything. I guess at a fundamental level it depends on what kind of game you want to make/play. To me the allure of RPG-style games is that they can be story vehicles. Run-of-the-mill animals dropping weapons and gems has the opposite effect on me: I think it disrupts the world's integrity and as a player I always think it's a design weakness. In any case, they do drop something - their bodies. > You'd end up basically just trying to kill "monsters" that are humans. Nope, at least not if we're talking standard fantasy RPGs. You could argue that all the tool-using monsters are human-like, but to me that's not very accurate. If there's a moral in-game argument in there, well, you generally don't kill Goblins because they're not human, you kill them because they're evil or they attack you first. There are generally tons of tool-using monsters in fantasy settings that aren't even humanoid. But yeah, I think it's OK to have human bad guys as well. To me, basing the distinction whether to kill some creature on whether they're human or not feels weird and questionable. > I think that's a cool idea, but in practice it doesn't seem to lead to very fun gameplay. Obviously, I disagree. Not every mob needs to drop riches, especially if the loot doesn't make sense within the story. Providing predictable and nonsensical short-term rewards is not a player retention strategy I'm overly fond of, I might as well just install ProgressQuest and watch that for half an hour. On the other hand, there are many games that do just that, so your view is clearly commercially viable. > "Oh, look, the wizard dropped yet another robe." That's only a problem if the expectation is that every lootable item is indeed loot-worthy. > I deliberately sacrificed realism (which is of limited value in my book anyway) to get a more exciting, surprising game. I see you're not kidding about not caring for realism. That's of course totally fine, do your thing. I'm not trying to convince you of anything. My point is that I personally think the choice between fun and realism implies a false dichotomy. Yes, dropping "realistic" loot is a bit predictable - but it's a good kind of predictability that makes the in-game world more convincing. And with just a little bit of good will and creativity you can still make them drop unique and surprising things without breaking their character. Maybe I'm mistaken but you sound a bit defensive, which was not my intention. Once again, this is not a critique of your game. It's a very personal opinion about loot and the style of games I like to play. At the end of the day, you're the guy building something amazing and I'm just a random dude on the internet who except for the occasional abysmal LD entry never even made a real game. So: rock on :)