18 ms·
Homemade Speakers
- kiram9 12y agoIf anyone is thinking to build their own cabinets - I would suggest checking out https://www.parts-express.com/cat/speaker-components/4 https://www.parts-express.com/cat/speaker-components/4 I have built a few speakers from scratch, including line arrays using them as my source. They are kind of like the mono price of speaker parts.
- keehun 12y agoDoes anyone know if this is a graduate level course? Seems like working with JBL engineers and getting mentored by TH is something that would draw a big crowd.
- msandford 12y agoIf you want to go really nuts, take a look at the Elsinore by Joe Rasmussen: http://www.customanalogue.com/elsinore/elsinore_index.htm http://www.customanalogue.com/elsinore/elsinore_index.htm He does a great job of designing a crossover and phase-inverting the tweeter to get an excellent step response. beat mentions that this is something most speaker manufacturers fail to account for. It's about as good as you're going to get for a DIY design and a whole associated design guide.
- gcb0 12y agoanyone who pays more than 200 on Chinese speakers at bestbuy are the bane of my existence. they drive everything up. and then publish tons of unscientific reviews and technobabble to justify their silly spending.
- beat 12y agoComplex crossover networks are The Devil. As you observed, the human ear is largely insensitive to moderate variations in volume/frequency... but it's incredibly sensitive to phase. Phase is how we discern directionality (stereo), among other things. So introducing complex phase shifts in the crossover in order to achieve flatness is a bad tradeoff, imho. To my ears, the best and most musical sounding speakers I've heard have time-aligned drivers and very simple crossovers. Tannoy, Spica, Vandersteen, and other such designs are clearer and less fatiguing. I'm a musician and have recorded numerous albums, and those speakers are the ones that match what I'm used to hearing the best. The fundamental problem is that we work on what we can measure. It's very easy to measure frequency response. It's very hard to measure phase alignment. So we fix what we can measure. If you want to see serious map-over-territory thinking, look at THD specs for amplifiers. It's super-easy to measure THD - just isolate harmonics of a sine wave a 1khz. Unfortunately, this has approximately zero to do with music, unless your idea of "music" is static sine waves. Recorded music has a 20-30db dynamic range (less in the case of modern pop) and covers ten octaves. Dynamic recovery behavior, intermodulation distortion, stuff like this is what gives amps their distinctive sounds - but it's nearly impossible to measure! So they sell what looks good on paper... THD. Sigh.
- chillingeffect 12y ago> incredibly sensitive to phase Under contrived situations such as square waves and headphones. However, in general, the ear is not particularly sensitive to phase. [0] [1] which both discuss, in particular, [2] and [3] as well as many others listed in their bibliographies. The stated conclusions are, emphasis mine, "Given the data provided by the above cited references we can conclude that phase distortion is indeed audible, though generally speaking, only very subtly so and only under certain specific test conditions and perception circumstances." [1] Reads may also be interested in an additional conclusion which reads thusly: "Room acoustics further masks whatever cues that the hearing process may depend upon to detect the presence of phase distortion." [1] [0] http://www.silcom.com/~aludwig/Phase_audibility.htm http://www.silcom.com/~aludwig/Phase_audibility.htm [1] http://www.audioholics.com/room-acoustics/human-hearing-phase-distortion-audibility-part-2 http://www.audioholics.com/room-acoustics/human-hearing-phas... [2] Lipshitz, Stanly P., Pocock, Mark, and Vanderkooy, John, "On the Audibility of Midrange Phase Distortion in Audio Systems,' J. Audio Eng. Soc., Vol. 30, No, 9, Sept. 1982, pp 580-595. [3] Toole, Floyd E., "The Acoustics and Psychoacoustics of Loudspeakers and Rooms - The Stereo Past and the Multichannel Future," 109th AES Conv., Los Angeles, Sept 2000.
- mbell 12y agoThis comment covers much of what is wrong with common interpretations of acoustics. > the human ear is largely insensitive to moderate variations in volume/frequency... but it's incredibly sensitive to phase. No, it's not. The human auditory system is sensitive to time variation. Phase shift may contribute a time shift but only at frequencies low enough that their wavelength has reasonably relation to the spacing of the ears. For example at 10Khz the wavelength is far too short for 'phase' to impact arrival time. Ultimately what actually matters in this regard with the human auditory response is group delay, not phase. > Phase is how we discern directionality (stereo), among other things. As mentioned above, what matters in the context of what your saying is group delay, but that is far from the only thing that matters for directionality. The human psycoscoutic system is very complex, part of directionality is group delay, part of it is frequency attenuation caused by sound wrapping around the ear from the ear, part of it is a half dozen other things. 'Phase' doesn't come even close to being a catch all cause. > To my ears, the best and most musical sounding speakers And thus we've devolved from science, as this usually goes. What on earth does 'musical sounding speakers' even mean? > It's very easy to measure frequency response. It's very hard to measure phase alignment. I have no idea where you came up with this statement but it is very easy to measure the response of a loudspeaker, both in amplitude and phase. > If you want to see serious map-over-territory thinking, look at THD specs for amplifiers. It's super-easy to measure THD - just isolate harmonics of a sine wave a 1khz. THD can be measured at only 1Khz, but it isn't something intrinsic to what 'THD' means. Measuring at only 1Khz is generally indicative of a crappy amplifier manufacturer looking to inflate their power numbers. Proper specs will provide a 20-20kHz THD rating. > Dynamic recovery behavior, intermodulation distortion, stuff like this is what gives amps their distinctive sounds - but it's nearly impossible to measure! If an amp has a distinctive sound, it has failed to achieve it's core design goal. I'm not sure what you think is impossible to measure, but I assure you it is not.
- matthew-wegner 12y agoAh, DIY speakers! The general rule here is that DIY speakers will sound as good as commercial speakers that cost 4-5x as much. You can buy kits with pre-cut parts, so all you need to do is glue/clamp and build the crossovers. Easy-to-build bookshelf speakers, the Overnight Sensations--$136 with free shipping: http://www.parts-express.com/overnight-sensations-mt-speaker-kit-pair--300-706 http://www.parts-express.com/overnight-sensations-mt-speaker... And the Amiga towers are great for a living room, more towards $300 for the pair: http://www.diysoundgroup.com/speaker-kits/amiga-kit.html http://www.diysoundgroup.com/speaker-kits/amiga-kit.html More Amiga info: https://sites.google.com/site/undefinition/diy/amiga https://sites.google.com/site/undefinition/diy/amiga I have built both, they're both really great at what they do. If I ever have the free time and money, I'd love to build some Statements: http://speakerdesignworks.com/Statements.html http://speakerdesignworks.com/Statements.html
- kingnight 12y agoIs that general rule pretty accurate? I've been contemplating buying an home speaker upgrade and pretty price adverse because I don't _need_ to upgrade. I am currently using Harman Kardon Soundsticks II w/ sub for my home audio and have no complaints -- kept this for 8 years really, so maybe I don't know what I'm missing. Are those 300 really ~ to $1200. If so, that sounds like a solid project!
- matthew-wegner 12y agoI'd say so! Most of my information comes from a super-long 3000-post speaker thread on a private music site. I have auditioned a few high-end speakers in stores and would say that DIY holds its own very well. Personally, I replaced an ~$800 pair of speakers with the Amigas, and they're vastly better in terms of clarity/resolution. I have a decent tube amplifier already. Past that point I'm pretty sure room setup/room treatment starts to matter much more than hardware...
- andy_ppp 12y agoWhich tube amp do you have (or should I buy?). I'm in the market for one :-)
- beloch 12y agoI once had a prof who designed his own speakers and built them out of concrete. They were massive, full-range beasts that were flat down to 20 Hz. (in the right room). As it turns out, concrete is surprisingly good speaker material, aside from the near total lack or portability. Some crazy (and crazy rich) audiophile bought them for $50K. Selling slabs of concrete for $50K a pop sounds like a great business model, but there is a severely limited number of people willing to pay that much for speakers, and the speakers apparently took hundreds of hours of tweaking to work "properly" anyways.
- thrownaway2424 12y ago"In the right room" is important. Anyone who spent $50k on loudspeakers ought already to have spent an equal amount on room geometry and materials. In fact above a fairly modest amount (a few thousand bucks, maybe) most people will get superior results from changing the room, rather than spending more on the equipment.
- stcredzero 12y agoYay! Audio knowledge! I've met so-called "geeks" who will look at you funny if you start talking about "frequency response" -- but they'll talk your ear off if you remind them about the frequency domain and Fourier Transforms. Back in the late 20th century, just about everyone who was tech savvy seemed to know some basics about sound. Nowadays, I wonder if the whole Monster Cable/coathanger thing has made some people filter out everything sounding like audio knowledge as "woo." Not all of it is. A lot of it is physics. Back in the 80's, designing and building your own speakers was a suitable project for high school students. Still is.
- minimax 12y agoMaybe for CS "geeks" but for those of us who came up through the EE ranks linear systems is our bread and butter.
- snowwindwaves 12y agohere is another interesting tale of home-made speakers, this fellow made some very large boxes and had very specific drivers he wanted but they were still inexpensive. He used active (powered as opposed to passive RLC network) crossovers. Also he built his own off-grid house with mini-hydro plant. the OP will probably find it interesting. I ended up reading every page on this fellows 90's style website. http://ludens.cl/Electron/Speakers/speakers.html http://ludens.cl/Electron/Speakers/speakers.html
- ljf 12y agoThat guy is a hero of mine, when I first found his site I lost about 4 days to exporting it and taking it all the interesting personal projects he has worked on.
- ljf 12y agoExploring, not exporting!
- Theodores 12y ago> "While commercial musical equipment is usually of quite usable quality, commercial speakers unfortunately are not, unless you go to exotic and extremely expensive brands. The reason is simple: Good speakers, by law of physics, need to be large. There is no way around this basic fact." Is this as true as it was in the 1990's? A lot of people have high-end small speaker systems with branding such as 'Bose' on the front. Maybe they have got old and their ears have changed, but even if they once had big-box speakers due to the physics reasons, they have moved to the small speaker 5.1 things and it is now okay to do that. The sub-woofer doesn't have to be stereo either. I don't know, but has new thinking fundamentally changed how hi-fi is done from the twin speaker stacks of old with lots of tweeters/woofers/crossovers to these new-fangled mini-5.1 things?
- VLM 12y agoLow frequency response needs size. If you're willing to cutoff at 200 Hz then little stuff will work. In my high school years I built a stereotypical mono subwoofer of the 2x4 sheet of plywood for front and back variety. Sounded pretty good, but could have been better. A mantra thats repeated continuously, mostly by people selling mono subwoofers or uninterested in audio reproduction, is low freqs are non-directional. Yet I go outside and listen to thunderstorms and passing unmuffled motorcycles and firearms and much bigger .mil weaponry and it sounds highly directional. I can point at the rumble of distant artillery as well as any other sound. Surely if you build a directional subwoofer system and can only perceive a field, that'll work OK even if its an economic financial fail. But the other way around is an epic fail. So save money at the risk of sounding bad. Well, if the point is spending money to sound good, having an extra 3 dB of signal is never a loss... Another puzzle is I know from experience that L-R and L+R sound different from FM subcarrier detection. Supposedly mono subwoofer people claim that magically only applies to higher freqs. I would think a single mono channel subwoofer would sound "better" fed off only L or R channel than some peculiar mix of unknown phase. The problem is which channel to connect to? Phase relationships are a pretty big puzzle in audio once you get past simple response problems and simple distortion problems.
- chrissnell 12y agoSo how did he design them? What tools does one use to do this? I have a form factor in mind for some speakers that I'd like to build for my off-road truck [1]. I have a certain look and mounting style in mind and I haven't seen anything like it. I just don't know where to start with the design, though. [1] https://flic.kr/p/o1xmJ8 https://flic.kr/p/o1xmJ8
- jzwinck 12y agoI made some speakers when I was in high school. The tools I used were a table saw, a whole bunch of long clamps, a screwdriver, and a hand drill. But most important, this book: http://www.amazon.com/Building-Speaker-Systems-2nd-Edition/dp/B000THVC3S http://www.amazon.com/Building-Speaker-Systems-2nd-Edition/d... . If you buy it used now you will find it hilarious how they describe using computer software to analyze speaker systems, but no matter: you can stand on the shoulders of giants and design your own boxes without any software at all. The "D'Appolito array" is covered in that book--a design employed in many store-bought speakers where two mid-woofers flank a tweeter at a specific distance to avoid some of the time alignment concerns raised here. This is a good candidate if you want to build smallish, narrow speakers for home. In the car it usually comes down to "where is there enough room for the drivers I want?" I think the book also discusses various dual-driver arrangements for subwoofers, which is another interesting area where you can use twin drivers to eliminate undesirable effects. If you put that together with the D'Appolito design in a single cabinet, you will have something like what Infinity used to sell for $1000 each...but doing it well won't save you much money because good drivers are expensive.
- Anechoic 12y agoIn addition to what jzwinck recommended, I'd also recommend the Loudspeaker Design Cookbook [0] and the Master Handbook of Acoustics [1] If you're an engineer that's comfortable with differential calculus, I'd recommend the grandaddy of them all: Acoustics by Beranek [2] (I'm actually linking to Acoustics: Sound Fields and Transducers which is an updated version of Beranek's original Acoustics cowritten with Tim Mellow) [0] http://www.amazon.com/Loudspeaker-Design-Cookbook-Vance-Dickason/dp/1882580478/ http://www.amazon.com/Loudspeaker-Design-Cookbook-Vance-Dick... [1] http://www.amazon.com/Master-Handbook-Acoustics-Alton-Everest/dp/0071603328/ http://www.amazon.com/Master-Handbook-Acoustics-Alton-Everes... [2] http://www.amazon.com/Acoustics-Transducers-Leo-L-Beranek/dp/0123914213/ http://www.amazon.com/Acoustics-Transducers-Leo-L-Beranek/dp...
- ljlukkar 12y agoI have degree in computer science but I owe a large part of what I understand about physics and electronics to my speaker building hobby. I highly recommend getting into the physics of sound. It’s actually pretty simple and will teach you how waves behave in general. http://www.cs.helsinki.fi/u/ljlukkar/labsub/ http://www.cs.helsinki.fi/u/ljlukkar/labsub/ I’m currently working on a Arduino based pre amp that hosts a rest api for remote controlling: http://tinypic.com/r/15yvj2g/8 http://tinypic.com/r/15yvj2g/8 http://tinypic.com/r/11vmhld/8 http://tinypic.com/r/11vmhld/8 http://tinypic.com/r/jrzfk5/8 http://tinypic.com/r/jrzfk5/8
- mikevm 12y agoSo how do you get into the physics of sound? I don't think I'll be building speakers anytime soon though, but I'm still very much interested in the details of psychoacoustics and sound reproduction.
- jacquesm 12y agoStart by reading this: http://www.amazon.com/Acoustical-Foundations-Music-Second-Edition/dp/0393090965 http://www.amazon.com/Acoustical-Foundations-Music-Second-Ed...
- remmelt 12y agoI'm very interested in the Arduino based pre amp. Do you have a page with your design that I can study? I was thinking about maybe integrating a Lightspeed Attenuator. Most of all, I'd like the pre amp to automatically turn on the power amp (currently a Gainclone) when a signal starts coming in from the connected Airport Express. http://diyaudioprojects.com/Solid/DIY-Lightspeed-Passive-Attenuator/ http://diyaudioprojects.com/Solid/DIY-Lightspeed-Passive-Att...
- swimfar 12y agohttp://www.amb.org/audio/alpha10/ http://www.amb.org/audio/alpha10/ Here's another arduino-based pre-amp. This one includes relay-based stepped attenuators and input selectors. The pcbs are all available as well as the schematics in case you just want to use it as a base for your own project.
- justatdotin 12y agoconsider digital crossover from minidsp. I've made a pair of powered 2-ways with a minidsp/miniamp combo in each.
- scoot 12y agoThose aren't homemade speakers, they're homemade enclosures. Disappointed as I was expecting something more substantial than "I made a box".
- unholiness 12y agoAgreed. I think there's a lot to be learned from building a driver, if only for the powerful experience of realizing that there's nothing magical about it. Just a magnet and a coil of wire. It's the equivalent a CS guy designing a rudimentary processor: it won't be necessary be good enough to beat out commercial stuff, but it sure does convince you that the thing you take for granted really can be done with just transistors/magnets and wire. I for one would have loved to do this kind of activity as a kid: it's a pretty simple concept that puts a whole lot of power in your hands and exposes interesting questions. It looks like Bose is doing something in this space at kids science camps [0]. If you can acquire/make an amp and a strobe light to replace their "blue box", there's a whole host of kid-friendly activities on the site to do with kids centered around making hand-made, origami paper drivers. [0] http://build.bose.com/ http://build.bose.com/
- mbenjaminsmith 12y agoDIY speakers as a hobby is mostly about enclosures and crossover networks. It's quite rare that people would build their own speakers drivers (some planar speakers being an exception). Where it's rewarding is taking available drivers and building a full speaker around them -- usually optimizing for performance vs cost. It's difficult and expensive to build really high quality loudspeakers. Add markup to that and the retail price of a well engineered speaker will quickly go into 5 digits. The speakers in my living room are DIY (though they don't really look "DIY" as far as that might carry negative connotations) and they're an excellent value. They were also fun to build. In no way was I disappointed afterwards because I had not, say, wound the voice coils myself.
- userbinator 12y agoThe box is a huge factor in making them sound good. For a brief time, I had a pair of speakers on my desk made from old PC case speakers that I salvaged and just put on stands made from blocks of wood with a hole in them. I liked the look, and the sound was alright, but rather weak and tinny. Then one day I decided to build a box around them, and the difference was night and day - much louder sound with significantly more bass.
- timclark 12y agohttp://www.theregister.co.uk/2014/07/02/feature_the_future_loudspeaker_design http://www.theregister.co.uk/2014/07/02/feature_the_future_l... - has an interesting perspective on speaker design and the human auditory system.
- jensC 12y agoA friend of mine created an online app that helps calculating Loudspeaker Enclosures. The app is completely free, no registration necessary. http://micka.de/org/en/index.php http://micka.de/org/en/index.php Hope that someone finds this useful.
- givan 12y agoThis is only a box for speakers, I was expecting something more.
- analog31 12y agoAh, but the box is a big deal. I'm a DIY speaker builder, but for musical instrument rather than hi-fi use. The box is an integral part of the electromechanical system that determines the response (and to some extent power handling) of the speaker at low frequencies. The box may be a plain box whose volume is its main parameter, or may contain other structures such as resonant ports. Most woofers are designed so they have to be in an appropriate box in order to be useful. Without access to the process for designing custom woofers, the DIY'er has at our disposal two main variables for tailoring low frequency response: Woofer choice from off the shelf models, and box design. And there are some tradeoffs to manage, such as low frequency response and box size, so that there's no ideal box design for all uses.
- chillingeffect 12y ago> musical instrument rather than hi-fi use Me, too. Just when speaker design seemed to be a solved problem, with a small set of uniform solutions, up springs the concept of co-designing speakers and musical instruments. What frequency range/instrument are you working with? And what architecture/horns/boxes/tubes/drivers?
- analog31 12y agoSorry, I left town right after posting that. I'm a bassist, so it's 40 Hz up into the midrange, with not that much going on in the tweeter zone. So far my designs are just lightweight "pro audio" drivers in ported boxes. Nothing sophisticated, but I just want to be in control of how my speakers work. Interestingly enough, I think that the electric bass involves a sort of de facto co-design, because the bass acquired its "classic tone" during a time when speakers were relatively low performance, i.e, having -3 dB points far above the lowest fundamental. To this day, speakers with that tone quality tend to be preferred by bassists, which is a fortuitous circumstance because it liberates us from dragging around huge boxes capable of actually reproducing that E fundamental at full strength.
- laurentoget 12y agoi read several claims that you can buy components and blueprints and build yourself speakers which would be much better than what you could buy for the price. this sounds like a business opportunity to me. anybody knows why nobody is selling good speakers for less?
- beat 12y agoBecause hours of effort, marketing, etc aren't accounted for in the price of your DIY. The hi-fi speaker business is a highly competitive market. The invisible hand already drives prices to about where they can go.
- vl 12y agoGenerally speaking, if you thought of something obvious, search the internet, somebody is already doing it. For example - http://www.htd.com/ http://www.htd.com/ - and godzillion other.