4 ms·
I also suspect this is a "defensive" move. A good experienced co-ordinate will give a ML system a run for its money on "gut" plus be able to factor in the effi
by lifeisstillgood 12y ago
I also suspect this is a "defensive" move. A good experienced co-ordinate will give a ML system a run for its money on "gut" plus be able to factor in the efficiency of certain teams, morale and even how hard the "track work" is - but he gets it wrong and it was "gut" and his boss cannot justify it. Put in an ML system and his boss now gets to say "the system decided"
Both ways there is an expected % of sub optimal decisions but only one can the boss blame someone else.
- PeterGriffin 12y agoWell, "gut" is far from obsolete, but not everything requires "gut". The article claims the program performs better when compared to data from manual management. It'll be saving them $800k/year alone. Also since the program will be evolving over time, you can assume there are still people monitoring its performance and feeding that back into the loop. Similar scheduling algorithms are already in use all over the world. If you're a student, chances are your program is made by a computer "boss" too. Scheduling is not the kind of chore humans are best at. We don't have to be cynical and suspect ulterior motives. After all, we created computers to be our assistants, and here we go, they are. And it's good. Every win for computers is a win for people.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoThing is, computers are really better at such tasks when the number of constraints grow too much for human to handle (i.e. beyond a few). It's because in time the human expert is able to articulate the solution he just thought of, the computer will search 100 000 other points in solution space and likely find a better one.
- lifeisstillgood 12y agoBut ... Only if a programmer has coded the other solution into the algorithm OR if the ML is able to distinguish between a correlation and a causation. Before Looking for Black Swans look for Xmas Turkey's.
- TeMPOraL 12y ago> if the ML is able to distinguish between a correlation and a causation Of course it is. You can get the causation structure out of a correlative dataset with some basic Bayesian math. http://lesswrong.com/lw/ev3/causal_diagrams_and_causal_models/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/ev3/causal_diagrams_and_causal_model...