5 ms·
Sounds like someone needs to re-read Piaget. Piaget identified a number of intellectual stages that children go through at fairly predictable ages. Children t
by btilly 17y ago
Sounds like someone needs to re-read Piaget.
Piaget identified a number of intellectual stages that children go through at fairly predictable ages. Children transition between them during growth spurts. There is variance in when the growth spurts happen, and therefore when those mental leaps happen.
Most children transition from the "intuitive" to the "concrete operation" stages around age 7. Concrete operations include tasks like ordering objects in a logical sequence. This is EXACTLY what the "5 minute IQ test" is testing. The longer test is almost certainly testing a variety of different mental skills that are also enabled by the same transition. Hence the strong correlation.
Furthermore someone who is "gifted" at age 6 on a test like this almost certainly is gifted because he or she hit that growth spurt early. A year and a half later more kids have gone through the same transition, and having acquired those mental skills early hasn't necessarily translated into acquiring them better. That would explain why so many once-gifted kids aren't gifted 18 months later. (Of course the additional time with those skills does help, explaining the fact that many still are gifted relative to their peers.)
In short the results should be unsurprising to anyone who has studied child development.
- tokenadult 17y agoPiaget didn't prove that no child can be genuinely gifted over the course of childhood compared to some "average" child--he didn't have a data set adequate to prove such a proposition at all. It's not clear yet that his proposed stages of development are as invariant as some readers of his books, think, either. MIT professor Seymour Papert actually studied with Piaget when Piaget was still alive, and this is what Papert says about how little Piaget's developmental hypothesis constrains profound giftedness: "The case [of Jean Piaget] has a mild irony in that this man, so often quoted as the authority on what children cannot do because they are not at appropriate stages of development, published his first scientific article at age eleven!" -- Seymour Papert, The Children's Machine: Rethinking School in the Age of the Computer (1993).
- btilly 17y agoI'm not saying that this research is rendered obvious by Piaget's work. Nor did I say that the age at which children make certain transitions is fixed in stone. Nor would I try to imply that Piaget discovered everything about the subject. Nor did I try to indicate that there are not gifted children. However I stand by my claim that Piaget's work provides a framework to understand why a young child's ability at one task (sorting lines by length and objects by weight) is indicative of a much broader range of cognitive skills. Furthermore the fact that cognitive abilities go through periods of rapid advance over a broad range of areas makes it less surprising to me that you see fairly large shifts in where children stand relative to each other in ability.