3 ms·
Sounds great. Where is this "vastly superior" military technology you speak of? The only thing superior about the F-35 is the price tag. We already have the
by CamperBob2 12y ago
Sounds great. Where is this "vastly superior" military technology you speak of? The only thing superior about the F-35 is the price tag.
We already have the hardware needed to repel every nation on Earth from our borders several times over. At some point it makes sense to look more closely at how we allocate our tax dollars.
- rayiner 12y ago> We already have the hardware needed to repel every nation on Earth from our borders several times over. At some point it makes sense to look more closely at how we allocate our tax dollars. First, the mission of the U.S. military is not just to repel attackers from our own borders. We have, though NATO, made it our mission to do the same for the whole of Western Europe. Second, I don't know where this idea comes from that we "have the hardware needed to repel every nation on Earth from our borders." Spending $200 billion per year does not mean you can effectively repel two countries that each spend $100 billion per year. There are diminishing returns. We push far along that curve because we're tremendously averse to loss of American life. We don't want to just be able to repel attackers, but do it with minimal U.S. casualties both to military and civilian personnel. The goal isn't just to win a war against China or Russia. It's to win a war without losing a million Americans in the process. Or: ideally, have such an overwhelming advantage that people the world over start to think of war between major powers as a relic of the distant past, instead of the central aspect of international politics that it has always been.
- CamperBob2 12y agoSorry, but there's no credible reason to think we will need this particular trillion-dollar aircraft to go to war against a hypothetical future version of China or Russia that spends the equivalent of $100 billion per year to attack us. A single ballistic-missile submarine is enough to deter that. Perhaps it's time to give the "Department of Defense" a new name. It used to be called the "War Department," didn't it?
- rayiner 12y ago'noir_lord wasn't suggesting we spend the $1 trillion on a more effective project. He was questioning spending that money on the military versus education or NASA. These sorts of criticisms of U.S. military expenditures are based on an a-historical view of the world that ignores events before 1950. For hundreds of years before that, the European powers were constantly at war, culminating in WWII that left 60 million people dead. That sort of warfare is the rule. The peace of the last 60-odd years is the exception, and the exception has to a great extent been bankrolled by the American military. Is the F-35 the best use of defense dollars? Probably not. But we spend under 4% of GDP on the military. Given the potential consequences of the loss of American military supremacy, that's not an unreasonable amount.
- CamperBob2 12y agoThese sorts of criticisms of U.S. military expenditures are based on an a-historical view of the world that ignores events before 1950. Correct; specifically, before November 1, 1952. Every dime we've spent on defense since then has gone towards fighting a kind of war that's not ever going to happen again. Either that, or fighting an asymmetrical skirmish somewhere in hopes of changing someone's culture through the application of violence. Again, there simply is no problem facing the US that projects like this are cost-effective at solving. (And that doesn't even get into the absurdity of a combat aircraft with a human pilot in 2014, much less the 2050+ amortization timeline of the F-35 project.) Build your Maginot Line on your own dime, kthxbye.
- rayiner 12y ago> Correct; specifically, before November 1, 1952. Every dime we've spent on defense since then has gone towards fighting a kind of war that's not ever going to happen again. The hydrogen bomb does not render obsolete conventional warfare. See, e.g., all the wars nuclear powers have been involved in since 1952. War between nations is a dispute resolution mechanism of last-resort. A weapon that just leaves everyone on both sides dead is inapplicable to that end. Take, for example, a hypothetical war over some limited resource (take your pick, they're all running out). Is anyone going to use nuclear weapons in such a war? No, but they're not going to handle everything through diplomacy either. > And that doesn't even get into the absurdity of a combat aircraft with a human pilot in 2014, much less the 2050+ amortization timeline of the F-35 project.) We have quite a few advances to make in communications technology and AI before human pilots are obsolete. As long as we need human operators, the wireless communications infrastructure is too fragile (susceptible to jamming, etc) to use in combat, and we're nowhere near fully autonomous combat aircraft.