3 ms·
Isn't music available through DRM-free sources most of the time anyway? Just don't use Spotify if you are against DRM. It will also be a vote with your wallet a
by shmerl 12y ago
Isn't music available through DRM-free sources most of the time anyway? Just don't use Spotify if you are against DRM. It will also be a vote with your wallet against it. By using it you implicitly support DRM proliferation.
- jdong 12y agoVoting with your wallet is much less effective than publicly complaining, unless of course your wallet is worth a lot.
- shmerl 12y agoMy comment wasn't really to the authors of this tool. Their tool is a form of the public protest and is appropriate. It was more directed to those who actually use Spotify. For them, complaining while actually using these kind of services (and helping them to spread more DRM in the process) is strange.
- jdong 12y agoWhat if they like the product but would rather have it without the DRM?
- shmerl 12y agoI'd say they should stop using it until the product drops the DRM. Otherwise their complaints don't sound sincere. Or at least not convincing. It's like as if smokers would complain that cigarets industry ruins public health.
- MichaelGG 12y agoSmokers complain, and now we have e-cigarettes which may be less harmful while still allowing the enjoyment of nicotine and the fun of smoking. I'm not sure why it's insincere. I keep buying ThinkPads, but I hate the new designs with a passion. (And they hate me; they literally cause me RSI where the earlier ones didn't.) It doesn't make my arguments against the new ThinkPads any weaker.
- shmerl 12y ago> and now we have e-cigarettes which may be less harmful while still allowing the enjoyment of nicotine and the fun of smoking. So, we can have digital goods sold without DRM, so we could enjoy them without police state methods attached. > I'm not sure why it's insincere. Because by buying from those who push DRM on them, users support and prolong the usage of the said DRM. Complaints won't persuade DRM Lysenkoists. Loss of profits can.
- alttab 12y agoExcept with Spotify you are not buying music. You are paying a subscription to their streaming services. DRM is the only way they can protect the artists. On top of that, if you are paying 10 dollars a month and ripping the DRM off their streams you are stealing, and completely missing the value proposition of streaming music. confusing Spotify with amazon or apple DRM would only display lack of understanding on part of the consumer. The truth is for streaming services you are NOT buying music!!!
- shmerl 12y ago> Except with Spotify you are not buying music. You are paying a subscription to their streaming services. DRM is the only way they can protect the artists. 1. Renting does not make sense for digital goods (I already explained in the past why). 2. DRM doesn't protect anything. I.e. it can't enforce the renting paradigm. This very article demonstrates that DRM is broken and it can't stop piracy. Therefore there is no need to use it ever even if we assume that it's an ethical practice (it is not). All DRM does is punishing paying customers by crippling the usability of the product (limiting supported devices / platforms / players / formats and so on), while having zero effect on pirates who pirate the same stuff DRM free.
- test_account_1 12y agoI totally agree, but a lot of people do.
- lucb1e 12y agoSomething with 'many wallets'. You know, just like the many eyes principle.
- davexunit 12y agoYes, please do not use Spotify. Not only do they use DRM, the client and server software is proprietary.
- thefreeman 12y agoDid you even read the article? It is a lesson on how to use panda to examine the memory of running processes. The spotify / music DRM is just an example to demonstrate the power.
- shmerl 12y agoSee my other comments. I don't criticize the article or the work which was done to break the DRM.
- glomph 12y agoPretty sure that is the only reason that this hasn't been fleshed out into a fuller anti drm system. It is easier to get it drm free from other sources and they get it sooner.