5 ms·
$1 Trillion dollars to build a plane to give the US (and it's allies) a greater edge over it's "opponents" militaries (in theory). I try to avoid been an armch
by noir_lord 12y ago
$1 Trillion dollars to build a plane to give the US (and it's allies) a greater edge over it's "opponents" militaries (in theory).
I try to avoid been an armchair general but you have to wonder what you could have done by giving NASA $400 billion (equivalent to 15 years of their current budget) and spending the other $600 billion evenly between education, infrastructure and investing in new businesses/re-training.
Sometimes I suffer species embarrassment.
- bokonist 12y ago"spending the other $600 billion evenly between education, infrastructure and investing in new businesses/re-training." I have recently started to believe that most people get the casualty wrong between education/training and industrial advancement. If you want more engineers, spend money in a way that creates more engineering jobs, do not simply educate engineers for jobs that do not exist. If you create the jobs, people will change college majors or teach themselves. Industries will create apprenticeship programs to compensate for the undersupply, etc. I think the U.S. already spends more than enough money to provide enough book learning to meet the demands of industry. Spending more without creating the jobs would be a waste of money. (Note I am not arguing that spending the money on the F-35 was the best use of the money, just that spending money on more education is also not a good use of money).
- rayiner 12y agoI was an aerospace undergrad in Georgia Tech, which has a pretty close relationship with Lockheed-Martin by virtue of geography. My observation was that projects like the F-35 create lots of technology and create the monetary incentive for training lots of engineers. It's maybe not the most efficient way to do those things, but it's not like all that money is just thrown in a hole.
- isomorphic 12y agos/F-35/Mars Lander/
- ihsw 12y agoMost people don't move beyond where they live, so "creating jobs" is a highly localized event that requires targeted and planned injection of resources. And even so, these resources can and do disappear. Personally I think reducing friction to moving elsewhere -- be it across state boundaries or across oceans -- should be prioritized. This would involve supporting/subsidizing public transportation infrastructure on a massive scale, which has benefits that are unrelated to increased personal mobility. Supporting the the "creation of jobs" is ephemeral by nature -- the need for those jobs is not permanent, however the supporting transportation infrastructure has a far greater sense of permanence.
- daeken 12y ago> If you create the jobs, people will change college majors or teach themselves. Industries will create apprenticeship programs to compensate for the undersupply, etc. The dearth of plumbers, electricians, mechanics, welders, and other tradespeople in the US completely disagrees with this. These are very frequently high-paying jobs (even if you judge by the tech industry yardstick) and there simply aren't enough people to fill the jobs. Mike Rowe has been campaigning about this for years now, to try to get people back into the trade, and it's just not happening.
- ixnu 12y agoDo you have data to support this claim? It would certainly depend on location, but BLS average salary data seems to point otherwise: Plumbers $49K: http://www.bls.gov/ooh/construction-and-extraction/plumbers-pipefitters-and-steamfitters.htm http://www.bls.gov/ooh/construction-and-extraction/plumbers-... Electricians $49K: http://www.bls.gov/ooh/construction-and-extraction/electricians.htm http://www.bls.gov/ooh/construction-and-extraction/electrici... Mechanics $36K: http://www.bls.gov/ooh/installation-maintenance-and-repair/automotive-service-technicians-and-mechanics.htm http://www.bls.gov/ooh/installation-maintenance-and-repair/a... Welders $36K: http://www.bls.gov/ooh/production/welders-cutters-solderers-and-brazers.htm http://www.bls.gov/ooh/production/welders-cutters-solderers-... -VS- Software Developer $93K: http://www.bls.gov/ooh/computer-and-information-technology/software-developers.htm http://www.bls.gov/ooh/computer-and-information-technology/s... Computer Programer $74K: http://www.bls.gov/ooh/computer-and-information-technology/computer-programmers.htm http://www.bls.gov/ooh/computer-and-information-technology/c...
- rayiner 12y agoIn the state of nature, the smartest play is not to try and be Mark Zuckerberg. It's to beat up Mark Zuckerberg and take all his stuff. Nations live in a state of nature as to each other, and thus a strong defense is a necessity in order to avoid colonization.[1] In any case, the trillion dollar price tag is amortized over 55 years. Over that time, at current levels of spending, we'll spend almost $8 trillion on education just at the federal level, almost a trillion on NASA, $44 trillion on social security, $42 trillion on Medicare, etc. The F35 has been a bungled project, but it's not any basis for feeling "species embarrassment." [1] Europeans didn't manage to colonize or otherwise subjugate India, Asia, the Americas, etc, because they were so much wealthier or more educated, but because they had vastly superior military technology.
- ibisum 12y ago>In the state of nature, the smartest play is not to try and be Mark Zuckerberg. It's to beat up Mark Zuckerberg and take all his stuff. False. The smartest play is to not be relevant either to Mark Zuckerberg, or the criminals who steal his stuff. You are justifying violence, aggression, and theft. This is not really a position I am surprised to see being upvoted, but I am rather disappointed that you haven't had any worthy challengers, either. The fact of the matter is that the state of nature is utterly arbitrary, now. If we decide not to kill each other, we do not kill each other. We do not randomly kill anyone without actually deciding to do it; failing to acknowledge the culpability of killers, and those who prepare to do killing above all else, is why we have killers. In an ideal, natural state, equilibrium will be attained, for that is the nature of the universe at large. It takes an obtuse intrusion of life to impede upon the natural entropy of the universe; decide to kill, and then kill, and you'll be doing something that does not happen anywhere else, provably, yet in the wider known universe. It is a unique and utterly self-perpetuating circumstance, murder. It cannot occur without life making the effort to proceed with the act. And the fact of the matter is, trillions of dollars worth of decisions have been made, by a tragically small elite, in the name of the whole - to kill. This is the responsibility of everyone who allows those dollars to persist as currency in global communication; the fallacy of irresponsibility nevertheless allows for continued acts of overt destruction on the human species. Decide not to kill, and you need not kill. For every $billion bomber, there could have been 1,000 solutions to the distrust and hatred between those who do not understand each other, sufficiently well enough, to acknowledge the commonality of life, shared. Put the bomber pilot in the middle of the village, and soon enough he'll be grateful for the company of those humans with whom he must drink tea, or perish. The only reason that the American people have allowed their nation to be subjugated by murders, criminals, the provably insane, is that they (the American people) simply cannot take responsibility - for themselves, nor for others. The idea that American military power is a projection of the willingness to 'do good for others' is an utterly banal fallacy; American military might can only be projected when those who can stop it are driven into an apathy derived from near-total irresponsibility for the results: for the death, for the murder, for the total lack of justice, for the dire export of utter prejudice, and ultimately - hatred. The budget was allocated on death. It was not spent on life. There are far more potent ways to deliver continued life by those, the living, here and now, than to predict future conflict 'is necessary and natural'. If you are alive today, you can solve this: learn the language of those you pretend not to hate.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]