5 ms·
How would you motivate people to learn on their own as an alternative to going to university?
Assignments and exams in university do provide great incentives to force people to learn things.
But can you provide incentives like that without a university where people do the learning on their own?
- deleted 19y ago[deleted]
- bhewes25 19y agoOverly simple answer money. Though even if you pay them how do you know how much they have learned? Certifications such as MCSE, CCNP, RHCE or any other of the acronym certifications. Or in the case of the Finance industry the CAIA, CFA, FRM, PRM, what the hell ever tests. Work well for industry specific general information. Another way I have found useful is give people a project a real market driven(IE come up with such and such of a product) or some safe lab project. Give basic guide lines and an incentive to finish and let them go at it. You will be amazed people come up with and what they learned to finish the project. Also always be there to help if the get stuck to give new ideas, but never do it for them. Yet another way keep track of what above average knowledge of a topic each member of the organization, I assume we are talking about a company, has. Make the list relevant to work so people do not think you are invading their privacy and set each person up with another person who wants to learn such and such skill or knowledge base.
- aswanson 19y agoAsk little kids. They do it naturally.
- curi 19y agoForced learning is unreasonable. If you can't demonstrate the merits of something, so that a student judges it would be a good idea to learn it (now), then in what position are you to say it really should be learned? If motivation to learn something requires external incentives, then why bother learning it? We should learn things that are intrinsically worthwhile.
- slashcom 19y agoI disagree. "Education and religion are two things not regulated by supply and demand. The less of either the people have, the less they want." -- Charlotte Observer, 1897 There is very much a reason that it is the law that children must go to school until 16: we want to enforce a certain amount of education on them, otherwise they'll think they never need it. The difference between me and my sister is a nice anecdote. I love to learn; I read books out the wazoo, etc. My sister, on the other hand, hates it. For the longest time, my parents had to watch her do her homework, or she wouldn't do it. The thing that eventually got my sister to do her homework by herself? Getting it through her teenage head that if she reliably does her homework, my parents won't be on her case every 5 seconds. She's now learning, not because of intrinsic love of it, but because of extrinsic reward: independence from my parents.
- curi 19y agoSchool is unpleasant. This turns people off learning. Then schools say: see? kids don't like learning. we have to force them. That isn't a valid argument. If pleasant, voluntary, interest-based learning was offered, you don't know how children would react. The same thing with your sister. the offer usually made is something like: obey me, and do your schoolwork. it won't be fun, but when you grow up you'll thank me later. if you don't obey, i'll hurt you. That provides no information about how your sister, or any other child, would have behaved if offered some better options.
- jey 19y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Montessori_method http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Montessori_method
- curi 19y agoOne of the premises of the Montessori method from the article is: That children learn in a distinctly different way from adults. That isn't reasonable, and isn't backed up by any serious theories of learning. There is only one known method for creating knowledge/complexity (evolution).
- jey 19y agoCall me a cynic, but I think people just don't care enough to do it. I think a lot of people go to college because they're supposed to, or to get a good job, etc. That's not wrong or bad, but it's just not going to be conducive to self-study. Once/if you do care, you can set goals and keep working on it until you figure out what works for you.
- jey 19y agoI also think that parents can encourage a curious attitude in their children, but it has to happen early. It won't work on every child, but can't hurt to try.
- cstejerean 19y agoThis is rather unfortunate. A lot of the folks that simply attend college is because they believe they NEED it in order to get a job, be successful, etc. While they're right to some extent (you're going to have a hard time being lawyer with no formal education), people generally miss the point that there are ways to make a living outside of working a boring job. Some people are simply not meant for college and instead of being forced through by parents, etc, they would be much better off simply dedicating four years of their life to practicing something they enjoy. I've met several people with no formal education background that now own a couple of small business (nothing fancy, cellphone stores, gas stations, etc) and make more money (and have more fun) than most folks with a college degree at their age. It doesn't take much college to do something entrepreneurial just the motivation to learn and the willingness to fail. The problem is a lot of folks don't realize that is a feasible option. For the most part everyone is force fed the same routine: "get good grades in high-school to go to a good college and then get good grades in college to get a good job otherwise you're screwed".
- jkush 19y agoFind out what kinds of things they'd like to do but feel they aren't capable of doing. Then, demonstrate which things they can learn now which will get them closer to doing the very things they can't do. If you can convey that each thing they learn can be used as a building block to learning things that are currently way out of their league you might have some success.
- DanielBMarkham 19y agoPeople are motivated by one of two things: pleasure or fear. I enjoy learning random stuff, but I plow through difficult computer-related stuff for one reason: it's a fast-paced, cutthroat competitive world out there. I need every little bit of advantage I can scrape up. I like it like that, but I imagine most folks would find that belief to be very uncomfortable. So I guess the enemy of self-directed learning is contentment?
- amichail 19y agoHow about paying people sort of like TopCoder with its prizes? Unlike TopCoder, you could reward most competitors. This could turn this into something like a part-time job for high school students. One can imagine that computer companies would be happy to donate money for these prizes to increase interest in CS. Unlike TopCoder, you would have many targeted competitions (e.g., compiler design, AI, graphics, etc.). So unlike university where you pay to learn, here you get paid to learn.
- DaniFong 19y agoIt's funny, on TopCoder, prizes count for close to nothing to most of the top competitors. More than anything, respect is what people strive for -- from others and from themselves. People are extraordinarily excited about the prospect of being 'red' or getting a rating above 2200, and seems to motivate people far more than prizes.
- ivankirigin 19y agoPeople that need to learn to be motivated won't be motivated enough to learn on their own. Low standards in school and a lack of clear guidance as to the point of it all makes people uninterested in learning. So start young, before they've become disinterested. Focus on the ability of learning/creating to make people truly happy and on the propensity to make people rich.
- shawndrost 19y agoI think there is a good question at the root of this. Universities were once the best source of information, but now they're not. However, they provide many things that make it easier to learn (expert evaluators, like-minded peers, social expectations) that aren't easy to find elsewhere. How can you duplicate those benefits? "Money" sounds like a horrible answer. "Forced learning" discussions are missing the point (or at least discussing a different question than I am). The answer I would expect to hear here, "join a startup", is not very user-friendly.
- vitaminj 19y agoSelf-learning has its own problems, some that have caught me out on more occasions than I care to admit. I graduated with an EE degree six years ago, but over the years found myself more and more interested in economics. I read textbooks, papers and articles, and over time I thought I knew something about it. It was only when I went back to uni this year to formally study for an economics degree that I realised I knew jack. All the fundamentals and boring little details that I used to gloss over had more signficance than I'd ever thought. I also had access to the university resources, good instruction and a fairly rigorous course structure. Granted I was motivated and keen to learn (sadly unlike the bulk of the 19 year old kids there), but I gained a much more solid basis for understanding econs than I would have had I not gone back to uni. I'm certainly no apologist for universities and schools, but wanted to point out that there are some issues with self-learning, namely 1) focussing only on the interesting topics and neglecting the fundamentals, 2) unstructured learning can be ill-directed and 3) good instruction is more efficient than finding your own way.
- arvid 19y agoTrue, but one needs to be very self-critical when self-learning and interact with others (not necessarily in the formal situation). To me, formal education is to provide the tools and knowledge necessary to learn on one's own, outside of a formal setting. Think about it. In elementary school, 90% of learning occurs inside the classroom. In high school, maybe 60-70%. In college, maybe 20-40%. Grad school 10-20%. Ironically, what increases during this development is the need to interact with others: colleagues, mentors and acting as a mentor to others.
- asdflkj 19y agoAssignments and exams are much less important than being around your intellectual peers every day. If instead of going to a university, you moved into a big house with 50 other smart, ambitious guys and a big room full of textbooks on every topic, after 4 years you'd know at least as much as if you had gone to a university, and probably more. You might be a little sexually frustrated, though (edit: and socially retarded, as well).
- indrax 19y agoVery low cost exams or other verifications that results in a certificate with publicly known high standards. Any high schooler should be able to afford the test, but people should be immensely impressed if they pass it. Once they are known and respected, they become resume fodder and that leads to money.
- staunch 19y agoProvide role models and mentors. Let them find a subject on their own that they can love and be the best at amongst their social circle.
- davidw 19y agoI left for Italy after enough university level Italian to learn more on my own, and fended for myself for a year. That was probably the biggest single "learning experience" of my life, and a lot of fun to boot.
- imgabe 19y agoThe bottom line is you can't force somebody to learn something. Assignments and exams compel people to temporarily memorize a list of facts or a pattern of calculation, but they have no impact on whether someone understands the underlying principles behind it. Without that kind of understanding they often can't apply what they've learned in unfamiliar or superficially irrelevant situations, or extend the knowledge on that topic when it falls short. For example, lots of electrical engineers learn about signal processing, but only the ones who really understood it would be able to see how it can be a useful metaphor computer programming (as in SICP.) In my life, I have found the things I've remembered most are the topics that I've used to accomplish some task I wanted to accomplish. I remember how to program because there are programs that I want to write and knowing things like algorithms and data structures helps me do that. I hardly remember a thing from chemistry or biology because there's nothing I want to accomplish with that knowledge. In the future, the greater availability of information is going to make a traditional "well rounded education" less and less useful. Every year or so, another newspaper article comes out decrying our education system because students can't find (obscure country) on a map. Yes, it's great to know things, but when was the last time you were trying to do something and you ran into a roadblock because you didn't know which continent Mt. Everest was on or what the longest river in the world was? What's the point of memorizing things like that when you can look them up in 30 seconds? The model for education should be: 1. Find something you want to do 2. Learn what you need to know to do it 3. Do it, maybe learning additional techniques or facts along the way. Add them to the body of knowledge on the topic. 4. Repeat. I guess my answer to your question is: no, you can't provide incentives like exams and assignments without a university. The real world provides far more effective incentives already.
- ruggy 19y agoJust keep raising tuition and cutting financial aid.