3 ms·
I don't think all middlemen are parasitic. The guy at my corner store, for example, creates value by stocking a carefully chosen set of products very near to my
by wpietri 12y ago
I don't think all middlemen are parasitic. The guy at my corner store, for example, creates value by stocking a carefully chosen set of products very near to my house and having them available at all hours. He's basically an L1 cache. And in being that, he's not making the problem of goods-getting worse for other people.
I think you're wrong about Google. They create enormous value through the services they provide. They then monetize that mainly through advertising. They could monetize it other ways; if advertising were illegal, Google would still be raking in cash.
But their search-related advertising, unlike traditional display advertising, actually creates value for both advertiser and viewer because it's relevant to what people are searching for. In user tests, a former colleague was having people do Google searches related to shopping. One guy, unprompted, said, "Hey, you want to know the secret for Google? ignore the stuff in the middle. The really good links are over here on the right." That is, he found the ads more valuable than the normal web content.
Turning back to the companies mentioned, I think they are serving their customers well. The problem is that they are all creating negative externalities by forcing other parties to become unwitting free suppliers of goods they are selling. For the parking apps, it's the cities providing the public parking. For the reservation app, it's the restaurants.
- grey-area 12y agoThanks for the clarification. Perhaps the operative distinction here is between parasitic and symbiotic corporations. Ideally they are symbiotic with other players in the eocsystem, rather than parasitic, but I think all corporations have a temptation and a tendency to end up as parasitic monopolies. Re Google, I wasn't saying they don't create value, far from it, I was saying they don't create value for readers with advertising. I concede this is a debatable point though for the reasons you mentioned, and it is really a subjective. Personally I don't find their advertising useful, and if anything think it targets me mostly with sites I've already engaged with and wastes the money of advertisers. There is a tension in their services because they depend on advertising, and the temptation (which thy have increasingly given in to on their search service recently) is to favour advertisers (the real customers) over end users - a classic problem in a two-sided market. To be clear though, I was not saying google are evil, but that just shifting the value around is what businesses do and what Google does - creating value is a very slippery and subjective concept and I'd argue their services which create value (mail etc) are funded by those that don't (advertising). So I would not use that particular behaviour as a criticism of the companies mentioned in the article - they might be objectionable, immoral or even illegal (I'd say probably all three) but they are not easy to distinguish from normal businesses in terms of how they shift value around.
- wpietri 12y agoThanks for the thoughtful reply. I believe that value is subjective, in that it's value to humans, but it's not particularly slippery. I also believe that for almost all businesses value creation is separate from cash extraction. My ISP's internet connection, for example, delivers a lot of value to me, but getting a bill from them doesn't. Google Search delivers a lot of value to me, but having ads on the page often doesn't. However, Google Search ads do deliver value to advertisers, and sometimes they deliver value to users when they discover novel products that are helpful to them. I think the value analysis for Sweetch and Monkey Parking is pretty clear. People want to park quickly and easily near wherever they're going. Monkey Parking makes that easier for some people, which appears to create value on the per-customer level. But it only does that by making parking harder for other people, so the app delivers no net gain in value. Indeed, by in effect paying people hang out in parking spaces until somebody pays them to leave, they are probably making the parking problem worse, resulting in a net destruction of value. I think the analysis for the restaurant reservation thing is similar. For each person they get in, they are excluding somebody else who would have had a table. Net value gain: zero. Or possibly negative given that squatting on reservations means that some will go unfilled. So in both cases, they seem to be parasites on the actual creators of value. This can be easier to see if you contrast them with the parking startups that do make parking easier: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7986950 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7986950