4 ms·
Stasi is relevant because methods Stasi used are relevant. Stasi considered arrests and torture to be ineffective and crude methods when controlling people. Th
by nabla9 12y ago
Stasi is relevant because methods Stasi used are relevant.
Stasi considered arrests and torture to be ineffective and crude methods when controlling people. They wanted something that was harder to detect even for the victims. The oppression and surveillance Stasi directed towards typical citizen or dissident was not brutal as in "you have to fear for your life", especially in the last decades of DDR.
Stasi perfected the technique called Zersetzung. It was form of psychological harassment and character assassination that maintained plausibe deniability. They falsified information and caused mental stress. For high value targets it could include breaking into their house and altering furniture. For most people it was the threat of being inconvenienced, life being derailed and social relationships disrupted. Not getting into school, not getting the job or apartment you wanted. False rumors about you. Social relationships being broken. No-fly list for your life.
There is potential for the same thing happening in the west as a result of more efficient surveillance. Some black box algorithm determines that this guy acts in a way that is above some threshold and your life will be somewhat more shitty from that day onward. You just don't know why.
- brightsize 12y agoFor anyone who's interested in this bit of history, the Stasi museum in Berlin is well worth a visit. I recommend taking the tour, the guides do a great job in helping to make sense of all the artifacts on display. http://www.stasi-museum.de/en/enindex.htm http://www.stasi-museum.de/en/enindex.htm
- Ecio78 12y agoOn the same topic, I would recommended visiting Terror Haza[0] (House of Terror) in Budapest, Hungary. As far as I remember, it was the old office of the Nazi local secret police and then the Communist local secret police. It is now a museum dedicated to what has been done by both regimes, and it has a really nice "visual" approach. Just as an example, the "role switch" of the secret police from Nazi to Communist (made most of the time by the same people), was well represented by a room full of lockers, with two dummies with the two corresponding different uniforms set on a rotating base and with memorabilia of the time including contract that was signed by Nazi secret police officer to vow that they have changed their mind and that now believed in the new regime. [0] http://www.terrorhaza.hu/ http://www.terrorhaza.hu/
- saryant 12y agoI recently read The File by Timothy Garton Ash, a British journalist who spent a fair amount of time in East Germany in the last decade of the DDR. After reunification he was able to obtain his Stasi file. He learned how the Stasi perceived him as a risk and began contacting those who snitched on him. The stories of how some of the informants became informants are fascinating. One cooperated with the Stasi in order to obtain exit visas for official travel. Some were Ash's friends seeking to boost their careers, some were just pleased to do their part in furthering the cause of socialism. Ash was never imprisoned or tortured and could leave whenever he pleased (though he was eventually barred from entering the DDR). He didn't really suffer at the hands of the Stasi but the book is a terrific look at the Stasi's surveillance and intimidation through the eyes of a single individual. http://www.amazon.com/The-File-A-Personal-History/dp/0679777857 http://www.amazon.com/The-File-A-Personal-History/dp/0679777...
- weinzierl 12y ago"he was able to obtain his Stasi file" sounds a bit like this was something special (I'm sorry if this is wrong, English is not my first language). Just to clarify: "Everyone has the right to inspect those documents that created the STASI about themselves. More than a half million people have made use of this option since 1992."[1] [1] http://www.bstu.bund.de/DE/Akteneinsicht/Privatpersonen/Privatpersonen_node.html http://www.bstu.bund.de/DE/Akteneinsicht/Privatpersonen/Priv... (loose translation)
- saryant 12y agoThat might just be poor wording on my part. Ash doesn't try to make it out as something exclusive, he devotes a significant portion of the book to Germany's efforts to bring the Stasi's work to light and the effects of that effort on German reunification.
- rmetzler 12y agoMy dad's Stasi files stated that he read a certain church related newspaper in public. There also were photographs of me at a very young age in the files. I guess they found them when they were routinely opened up personal letters. I'm pretty sure NSA can access the same information about what I read and how my child looks like and I'm really worried about that. And when I post something NSA related on Twitter and the next moment my web browser crashes, I really feel the mental stress you're talking about. Stasi was different though, because their IMs would be your best friends and neighbors. Our weakness is the technology we use to talk to each other.