2 ms·
> When I talk to anyone who's livelihood doesn't rely on advertising or marketing, there is near unanimous agreement that advertising is fundamentally manipulat
by EdwardDiego 12y ago
> When I talk to anyone who's livelihood doesn't rely on advertising or marketing, there is near unanimous agreement that advertising is fundamentally manipulative and dishonest.
Besides the social cost of Advertising, there many other costs.
Such as? Keen to hear. :)
Also, what would you propose in lieu of the current advertising supported model that is dominant today?
- eevilspock 12y agoPlease read the linked comment for an explanation of other costs. It's not exhaustive. I didn't write about other costs, such as the stifling of competition (advertising favors the establishment, the rich get richer) and negative sum arms races[1]. I'm implicitly proposing that people pay directly for the products they use. Be the customer, not the product. Reward businesses that put the user first, with no advertiser conflict of interest. We need to evolve a way to do this efficiently, since people aren't going to pull out their credit card for every different site they use, especially not the one-offs. The best minds of my generation are thinking about how to make people click ads. That sucks. – Jeff Hammerbacher, fmr. Manager of Facebook Data Team, founder of Cloudera If we can redirect just a fraction of those best minds at coming up with a micropayment system for the web, it won't take long to solve. Some people make themselves feel better about advertising by saying it helps the poor (who can't, presumably, afford to pay for Gmail or Facebook or whatever online journalism they read). These same people conveniently forget that the poor spend a greater share of their income on goods, thus a greater share goes to advertising costs, which could mean that the ad-supported web model we have today is regressive (as in regressive tax). - [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7927862 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7927862
- wpietri 12y agoFor me the biggest problem with it is the enormous waste of talent. If we banned all advertising tomorrow, nothing particularly bad would happen. People would still learn about products; companies would still gain and lose customers. Indeed, that whole process might be more effective. But suddenly the US would have $500 billion or so worth of labor and goods to devote to some purpose that is actually productive. Actual smart humans waste their entire lives doing something that adds zero net value the system. When I think of my friends in advertising, it always makes me a little sad. What good things could they have done with their lives?