6 ms·
Economic theory. A rich person earns more money per hour than a poor person (by definition). Money is a representation of value (by definition). In Economics, v
by marcus_holmes 12y ago
Economic theory. A rich person earns more money per hour than a poor person (by definition). Money is a representation of value (by definition). In Economics, value earned is at least proportional (if not equal) to value created. So a rich person creates more value in the same amount of time than a poor person. Their time is literally more valuable.
In theory there's no difference between theory and practice. In practice, there is.
- 001sky 12y agoNaive theory is the worst kind. The behavioural assumptions of NC econ are naive in this dimension. Infinite rationality is easily affordable in theory. In reality, both the approximation of it is expensive, and the hack/exploitation of its failure to materialize are profound.
- kourt 12y agoA rich person earns more money per hour than a poor person (by definition). No, that's a person with "high hourly earned income". Making wealth is not the only way to get rich. For most of human history it has not even been the most common. Until a few centuries ago, the main sources of wealth were mines, slaves and serfs, land, and cattle, and the only ways to acquire these rapidly were by inheritance, marriage, conquest, or confiscation. Naturally wealth had a bad reputation. - Paul Graham
- smsm42 12y agoWe're not living "a few centuries ago", however. And there is also an important qualifying word "rapidly". One doesn't have to become rich overnight to be rich now. As for the "bad reputation", given that most things that were written and otherwise arrived to us were composed by people of some means at least (excluding monks, etc. which are harder to classify by modern standards) - really poor folks had high illiteracy rates, little spare time to create records that we could read, and not many people that cared for their opinions enough to create permanent record of them. So, given that, how exactly Paul Graham knows what reputation the wealth had amongst folks who weren't wealthy?
- wpietri 12y agoOne study says that only a third of the Forbes 400 started from a middle-class background or lower. [1] A third of them had purely inherited wealth. [2] And when I look around at the rich people I'm familiar with, they aren't enormously more productive than their peers. Often it was a right-place, right-time thing. If Bill Gates had been born 50 years earlier, for example, it's hard to imagine him becoming a zillionaire. So I think it's an enormous error to confuse wealth with creating lots of value per hour. Wealthy just means you control a lot of capital. [1] http://www.cnbc.com/id/49167533# http://www.cnbc.com/id/49167533# [2] http://www.forbes.com/sites/erincarlyle/2013/09/18/how-self-made-forbes-400-billionaires-earned-their-money/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/erincarlyle/2013/09/18/how-self-...
- smsm42 12y agoThe third is not a majority. The first link says 57% were not born wealthy. >>> And when I look around at the rich people I'm familiar with Anecdote is not data. I don't know where you live, but depending on it and your social circle, the minuscule number (compared to the whole nation) of people you can observe personally would be very different. >>> Often it was a right-place, right-time thing. It was. So what? Nobody claims billionaires are superhuman. The claim is only they deliver (or delivered) value. Did they come into position of being able to deliver the value by luck? Maybe. So what? If you per chance found a deposit of gold or discovered very valuable technology - they fact chance played role in it does not change the price of gold or the usability of technology. >>> If Bill Gates had been born 50 years earlier, for example, it's hard to imagine him becoming a zillionaire. Sure, so that guy everybody mentions would be called "John Walles" instead, it's no different.
- wpietri 12y ago>> It was. So what? So maybe you should read all the way to the the last line of my post, which explains my exact point: someone currently being a billionaire doesn't mean that they will make the world much better if they spend an hour on one thing versus another. Ergo, kourt's point stands: somebody being wealthy is not any sort of proof that they can create more value per hour. Which is the (wrong) notion that NhanN was promoting. If you're going to jump into a conversation in the middle, please try to pay attention to what's going on. It's frustrating to have to connect the dots for you.
- bildung 12y agoEconomic theory. A rich person earns more money per hour than a poor person (by definition). Money is a representation of value (by definition). In Economics, value earned is at least proportional (if not equal) to value created. So a rich person creates more value in the same amount of time than a poor person. Their time is literally more valuable. The assumption of a rich person being rich because of the value created may sound plausible, but is empirically falsified for at least the USA and Germany. Statistically, a rich person is rich because she inherited.
- smsm42 12y agoI don't know about Germany, but for USA it is does not appear to be true. Which data your based your claim on? Here: http://www.forbes.com/sites/moneybuilder/2012/04/20/most-wealthy-individuals-earned-not-inherited-their-wealth-2/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/moneybuilder/2012/04/20/most-wea... it says only 6% of wealthy people are wealthy by inheritance. Here: http://blogs.wsj.com/wealth/2008/01/14/the-decline-of-inherited-money/ http://blogs.wsj.com/wealth/2008/01/14/the-decline-of-inheri... they arrive at the same conclusion (minority got wealthy by inheritance).
- bildung 12y agoSorry for the late reply, I didn't recognize your answer earlier. Is there some comment notification option on hn that I missed? The forbes article you quoted is a bit problematic because the data given are voluntary answers. In studies like these there always is the problem of a potentially skewed return rate: Given a return rate of 30%, what is the wealth inheritance quota of the other 70%? My speculation would be that someone who is proud of the fruit of his own hard work (the quoted local business owner) is more likely to answer such a survey. On the other hand some rich person who found a clever way to unofficially inherit parts of the own wealth while avoiding the correlating taxes won't answer such a survey. At least the second of the blogs.wsj.com studies is self-selected, too. I couldn't find the papers for the two other quotes because the sources were too vague. It's better to use data sources like tax income of states. IMHO even better is the concept of social mobility (the wikipedia article is quite good: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_mobility http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_mobility), as it also encompasses factors like the parents' social contacts and educational chances. The studies cited there all use official, non-self-selected data and sometimes even proper longitudinal studies. In the results presented there the USA has the the lowest intergenerational vertical social mobility of all researched OECD countries (i.v.s.m. means the probability of a child to get into a higher (or lower) class than its parents live in). An example for Germany: The probability of a child of workers to get a degree from a university is 17 times lower than that of a child with academic parents (source: http://www.deutschlandfunk.de/geschlossene-gesellschaft-uber-die-verteilung-von.media.09812bea2e59b93a7e5a15894f44b32d.pdf http://www.deutschlandfunk.de/geschlossene-gesellschaft-uber...). Yes, social mobility is not the same as inherited wealth, because it's a result of a combination of inheritance and other factors. On the plus side, the empirical data it's based on is of comparibly high quality. The problem is that monetary (as opposed to social etc.) wealth is pretty hard to measure even given government data. In Germany for example the data for people having income is more or less 100% available. But the richer you are, the less probable it is for you to have income: The money then comes from capital gains, rent etc. These are way harder to measure, e.g. the capital gains could get collected by a corporation and not an individual. The corporations money only gets tapped on demand (=saved inside the corporation hull until retirement). And the child of the owner has a counsulting contract with that company. Legally, thats not inheritance at all, but practically it pretty much is.
- venomsnake 12y agoA rich person usually inherits more money. Abolish inheritance and almost all of the capitalistic problems disappear.
- el_zorro 12y agoI'm really curious how you think this will solve anything. Children of wealthy parents don't have to inherit anything to have advantages that most poor children could only dream of. That is, unless you somehow abolish parents using their wealth to give their kids access to better healthcare, higher-quality and healthier foods, better educations, opportunities for travel, exposure to culture, and on and on. And if you say that yes, that is what you mean and all those things are to be taken care of by the state, then you've moved beyond even the socialized policies of the Nordic countries. Not that that's a bad thing, but it would be a little disingenuous to call it capitalism.
- wpietri 12y agoIf you abolished inheritance (that is, taxed it at 100%) you would certainly reduce a number of capitalism's structural problems. That's why even many wealthy people are in favor of large inheritance taxes. [1] That would also provide you a lot of tax revenue for improving education and social services. Or you could just pay it out as a negative income tax or a basic income. That wouldn't solve every problem of capitalism, but so what? No improvement makes everything perfect, but that's not a reason to argue against improvements. [1] e.g.: http://www.forbes.com/sites/ashleaebeling/2012/12/11/buffet-carter-gates-sr-and-friends-call-for-estate-tax-with-45-teaser-rate-amid-fiscal-cliff-negotiations/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/ashleaebeling/2012/12/11/buffet-...
- walshemj 12y agoalong with vast swathes of the middle class
- wpietri 12y agoUnlikely. Most people are solidly in adulthood before their parents die; at that point, their economic destiny is generally fixed. A high inheritance tax won't harm the kids' middle-class status.