5 ms·
Scalpers do create value. After a complete scalping transaction: - the original ticket purchaser is happier with the cash received than with the ticket they h
by rahimnathwani 12y ago
Scalpers do create value. After a complete scalping transaction:
- the original ticket purchaser is happier with the cash received than with the ticket they had before
- the final ticket purchaser is happier with the ticket than with the cash they paid
- the scalper is happy with his/her profit
- the promoter's/venue's revenue is unaffected
So, three people are better off. Value has been created.
- neumann 12y agoI do not understand this logic. What original ticket purchaser? Scalpers aren't like eBay. They have bought up the tickets from the venue at certain amount, depriving others of a limited resource at that same value, and now offering it a higher value to people who didn't have the means to buy it as fast as the scalper. The disruption the scalper is introducing into an existing system benefits nobody but themselves.
- rahimnathwani 12y agoI'm not willing to pay more than face value for tickets so, if scalpers didn't exist, I would be better off. I'd have an x% chance (where x<100) of getting tickets at face value. There are rich people who are willing to pay up to 4x face value. They are very happy to pay 2x face value and get to go to every show they want. Without scalpers, they would pay less per show, but would totally miss out on some shows. The scalper benefits those guys, at the expense of guys like me. It's not true that the scalper benefits nobody but themselves.
- neumann 12y agoThat's a good point I had (subconcisouly refused) to consider as value. Value is added to the rich. Further offending my socialist dream. ;)
- lmm 12y agoYesterday I bought a ticket at >2x face value for a concert on Monday. That's value for me - I'd like to be able to go to things without having to plan my life months in advance, and I'm willing to pay for the privilege. Supply isn't set in stone. If scalpers buy up tickets early on then they take on the risk that a show won't sell out, and that allows the promoters to move to a bigger venue (as happened in this case), add more nights, or even raise prices. So the promoter benefits too. It's no different from any other middleman: find someone who's selling at price x, find someone who's buying at y > x, connect them together and take your cut. Which is what makes capitalism works.
- wpietri 12y agoYou're missing the negative externality: the person who couldn't get in because you're paying some scalping dick. And let's not forget the performers, who are interested in performing for their best fans, and who try to set ticket prices accordingly.
- jblow 12y agoNo, because the final ticket purchaser would have been even happier with the ticket plus the extra cash he would have had if he had not needed to buy from the scalper, and/or the venue or promoter would have been happier with the extra money that is instead taken by the scalper. Come on, this is obvious.
- rahimnathwani 12y agoNo, because the final ticket purchaser would have been even happier with the ticket plus the extra cash he would have had if he had not needed to buy from the scalper But in my example, he wouldn't have gotten the ticket at all. The ticket would have been had by someone like me, who was barely willing to pay the face value, but was lucky enough to get one of the limited supply of tickets when they were released for sale. and/or the venue or promoter would have been happier with the extra money that is instead taken by the scalper But in my example the venue or promoter has already set the price lower than the market-clearing price. If s/he hadn't done that, then the scalper would not have popped into existence, as the market would already have cleared.
- gizmo686 12y agoYour analysis is slightly off. In a world without scalpers, the original ticket purchaser would not exist, because he bought the ticket for the purpose of selling it. However, your general thought is good. In a world without scalpers, person A and B both have a 50% of buying the ticket at price $X. However, the ticket is worth more to B than it is to A (in terms of real utility, not monetary value). There is real value created by increasing the chances of B getting the ticket. The most effective mechanism we have found to maximize the chances that B gets the ticket in this situation is market pricing, which is what scalpers enable.
- rahimnathwani 12y agoI see your point. However, many times people buy tickets to a show because they intend to go, but then something comes up, or their financial situation changes, or demand outstrips supply to the extent that the open market price exceeds the value to them. That's the situation I was imagining when I wrote my post. My original post has as many comments as downvotes, which I take to mean it wasn't a useless post, but that people disagree that scalpers add value. The funny thing is, I would prefer a world without scalpers, and in which I had an equal chance to buy underpriced tickets. If I were rich, I would probably prefer the current situation, or one in which tickets were priced dynamically, like plane tickets are now.
- wpietri 12y agoWhat's your evidence that a market mechanism is most useful here? When I think of the best concerts I've seen, the ones I really loved, they were mostly when I was young and broke. Now that I'm older and have money I can afford to go more concerts, but I generally care less. I could well be pushing out very passionate fans. I suspect a better mechanism in this case is making people pay in a currency in which we are all more or less equal: time. If the venue just started selling tickets in one spot at a particular time, the people in line first would be the very passionate fans, the ones who dropped everything to get in line early.
- icebraining 12y agoBy shifting the demographics of the audience, it can reduce the value of the show. Quoting Kid Rock, who has been trying to eliminate scalpers: Kid Rock and his team are reserving the first two rows for die-hard fans only. No matter how much money you've got, you can't buy your way into them. "They are not for sale, " Kid Rock says. "I'm tired of seeing the old rich guy in the front row with the hot girlfriend. And the hot girlfriend, you know, with her boobs hanging out,with her beer in the air, just screaming the whole time. The old rich guy is standing there like he could[n't] care less. It's a very common theme at Kid Rock concerts." http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2013/06/27/196277836/kid-rock-takes-on-the-scalpers http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2013/06/27/196277836/kid-rock...