5 ms·
God yes. The whole point of commerce is the creation and exchange of value. The great startups have been great because they create massive amounts of value in t
by wpietri 12y ago
God yes. The whole point of commerce is the creation and exchange of value. The great startups have been great because they create massive amounts of value in the world.
Startups like this don't create value. They just shift the value around. In the case of these startups, they shift the value to rich people while pocketing the cash. They are essentially parasitic.
Not only is that a dick move, it's dumb for a startup. Google can earn $60 billion in revenue per year because they create even more value than that for its users and customers. Startups that don't create much value have very limited opportunities for capturing value. As the parking app show, regulators are perfectly happy to ban things that don't create value, especially when they have obvious negative externalities. That's what happened to the entire telemarketing industry for example.
So please, people: focus on creating value, not just on whatever bullshit will bring a few dollars through the door.
- NhanH 12y agoJust to be clear: I agree with your point on focusing on creating value. And after I read your comment, I agree that none of the startups in the articles are truly creating that much value. However, is it that simple to qualify when you're creating value? If I had read the article before HN's comments, I'd have thought the startup is cool (admittedly trivial and silly, but we have a lot of those nowadays), rather than parasitic. I'd have thought it's just a clever hack in helping more efficient distribution - in the true spirit of capitalism. Yes, while it would shift the value to rich people, it also free up the rich people's time, so they (rich people) can create more value. Assuming that rich people is richer because society decides that their time is more valuable, they can create more value in the same amount of times of some other poorer people. Of course, that might be not morally justifiable. But creating value and being morally correct is orthogonal. I'm not living in SF the SV area, but I've a few friends there. Every time they talked to me about startup ideas, I've always felt off about those ideas. I kept telling myself that trivial value is still value, and potentially if it can help many people, the net gain would still be large. How do I know where to draw the line? Edit: it seems like quite a few people have problem with my post, so let me rephrase the middle paragraph a bit: Ignoring the mentioning of rich/ poor, parking spot is a commodity. And just like other commodity in life, everyone values it differently. What's wrong in letting people paying for what they think it's worth for? The rich will always have advantage in buying commodity, and that's a fundamental issue in our society, but that's an entirely separate problem to fix, and the solution isn't telling people to stop producing commodity, or distributing them. In this specific case of parking lot, it's bad either way because a private company is skimming profit from public space.
- wpietri 12y agoNot sure why you were downvoted; I think it's a great question. I don't think it's that hard if you look at it systemically. If the problem is parking, none of the JerkTech startups are solving the problem, they're just shifting the burden. And they're probably making the problem worse, as now they've created a financial incentive for people to occupy hot parking spaces so they can get paid to leave. On the other hand, if the problem is "rich people don't have enough time", then there are plenty of ways to solve that. Indeed, Uber basically set out to solve the problem of "rich people don't have enough time and/or feel important enough". Thus the fleet of fancy cars. That created value. I think solving small problems across a large number of people is fine. Look at entertainment. There are plenty of video games that created value one quarter at a time. Or today, $0.99 per. It's not like it cures cancer, but as long as people end up having fun and are happier, that seems fine to me. However, in my view that excludes operations like Las Vegas and Zynga, which create very little fun and a lot of compulsion, which they then use to extract cash. I think the hypothesis that rich people generate more value given more time is... unproven. There are plenty of people who are rich because of their cash-extraction skills, not their value-generation skills. Many of them do it in ways that are negative sum. For those people, the best thing you could do for the world is to waste their time.
- metaphorm 12y ago"Assuming that rich people is richer because society decides that their time is more valuable, they can create more value in the same amount of times of some other poorer people." are you fucking kidding me? why would you assume that?
- NhanH 12y agoI believe that's a reasonable assumption for this discussion (that's not my personal opinion, btw). But trying to justify that statement will start a flame war and distract from the topic, so let me try to say that sentence in another way: Parking spot is a commodity. And just like other commodity in life, everyone values it differently. What's wrong in letting people paying for what they think it's worth for? The rich will always have advantage in buying commodity, and that's a fundamental issue in our society, but that's an entirely separate problem to fix, and the solution isn't telling people to stop producing commodity. In this specific case of parking lot, it's bad either way because a private company is skimming profit from public space.
- Mandatum 12y agoThey're just clipping the ticket for bribery. This same thing exists in the underworld, however tech has made this sort of thing a "legitimate" business. I don't see much of a difference between this, and say, high frequency trading. Different areas, but same concept.
- Tominator0 12y agoYou seem to accept the media's sensationalist take on HFT which was provided to them solely by Michael Lewis. While HFT isn't exactly kosher, it's not as bad as you may like to think. Here's a video explaining some advantages of HFT: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e9aYZYSwCLo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e9aYZYSwCLo
- Mandatum 12y agoOops, didn't mean to compare it to crime. Just relative in concept.
- grey-area 12y agoStartups like this don't create value. This is a very old hypothesis, and you are shadowing Marx in decrying parasitic middlemen. Value is such a indeterminate notion that anyone could be said to be creating it, but so many activities we take for granted (and which render us service) are parasitic in some sense - taking rent, opening a store of any kind, transporting goods, paying interest, manufacturing goods are all based on taking advantage of a gap between buyer/seller or taking advantage of an inherent advantage of scale/capital (ownership of the means of production if you like). I think it's ok not to add any value other than getting a service/product to someone who wants it and doesn't want to spend energy looking for it. That's not what makes these companies regrettable. Google can earn $60 billion in revenue per year because they create even more value than that for its users and customers. Google is, strictly speaking, a middleman just like the companies above, it doesn't create significant value for end users with advertising (its primary source of revenue), that might even be a negative for customers. Google lives in the interstices between customers/customer data and advertisers and the value they create is mostly incidental to their main revenue stream (it is in services like gmail, gmaps, android etc), and designed carefully to ring-fence customers or guide them toward being the end product of advertising streams. Again, I don't think that's bad, but it's important to recognise that and its similarity to the activities of these other companies or others like Amazon or Apple which provide useful services at the same time as making money as middlemen. They could easily earn $60 billion a year by being evil, and we might not even notice if they were at first because we're too busy enjoying the nice free presents. The problem with the companies in this article I think, and any other company gone bad, is that the interests of consumer and customer become misaligned to such an extent that the company no longer serves its customers in the sense of seeing to their needs, but in the sense of serving them up to others.
- 7Figures2Commas 12y agoThis isn't an issue of middlemen, value or the alignment of interests between customer and company. It's an issue of legality. Google operates a legal business. It sells advertising on a service that it owns. Period. The parking companies in the article are knowingly inducing their "customers" to violate local laws that forbid the buying and selling of on-street public parking. These companies seek to profit from this and as a result are now in legal hot water themselves. As for ReservationHop, I believe restaurants may have legal recourse. California's unfair competition laws are fairly broad and I think an argument could be made that intentionally booking fake reservations for the purpose of advertising and reselling them would constitute an unfair and perhaps even fraudulent business practice.