3 ms·
A market for recorded performances is about 100 years old. It is a novelty in human culture as well as commerce. Cartels controlling this market are an even mor
by Zigurd 12y ago
A market for recorded performances is about 100 years old. It is a novelty in human culture as well as commerce. Cartels controlling this market are an even more recent and dubious "innovation."
Expecting them to have lifespan and protection of the property under one's house, or to even be analogous to that property, is delusional.
- pessimizer 12y agoWhat we need is more small scale live music. Every birthday party or romantic dinner should hire musicians. Recorded music will be a musician's calling card. People will again be primarily interested in local musicians, rather than specks in an arena 100 yards away from them. I'm happy this is happening. That will disadvantage more produced, machine-assisted music that is hard to recreate live (or unconvincing when played at a moderate volume), but if there's anything the internet has taught me, it's that people will make that stuff for free, extremely well.
- Nav_Panel 12y agoI totally support this. I'm doing a summer internship in San Francisco and one of my favorite parts of living here is being able to see fantastic local music in small venues. I've been going to a cafe in the Mission where I can just hang out after work and listen to a jazz group play from around 8:30 until midnight. I noticed that as a result of seeing live music in my spare time, my consumption of recorded music has dropped dramatically. I pretty much only put on my headphones when I go for a run (I will occasionally listen to an album while I'm programming, but I prefer not to).
- Zigurd 12y agoThis is already the reality, and always has been. Recorded performances enable 0.0001% of professional and "semi-pro" musicians to earn a living from recorded performances. For everyone else, life is as it was before recorded performances: You perform live, and you may have a day job, maybe teaching music, maybe something unrelated to music. If the money from recorded performances goes away, the impact on music as an artform will be nil.
- dharma1 12y agohow is it different from say, a book?
- graylights 12y agoWell plenty of books are the same. Meant to be consumed, used up and then just take space. But a quality reference book doesn't really have an analogue in music. That book can be a key tool to someone performing their profession. This applies even in a digital medium.
- dharma1 12y agoMusic usually performs a different function to non-fiction books in terms of conveying practical information, but an analogue for a quality reference book could be an original composition recorded by a master musician/composer. That recording can be a key tool to a another musician or composer learning her trade, no? Whether the book or recording is digital or not doesn't really matter
- Zigurd 12y agoThat's the question, isn't it: Copyright became mainstream in the era of books, printed sheet music, and other publishable symbolic encoding of information. Performances were not protectable. Why do you think a recorded performance of a work should be protectable under copyright? It's NOT an original work of the intellect. It's a performance of what is often someone else's work. Just because it is recorded, should it be protected? Does the technological innovation of recording make it protect-able? And, if so, shouldn't the technological innovation of infinite copies at zero marginal cost make performances un-protectable?
- dharma1 12y agoThere is plenty of music which is only recorded in an audio form and cannot be encoded as sheet music, and is original work of the intellect. I don't see any difference in a book and an original music recording in terms of why one should be subject to copyright and one not. Whether recordings or books are protectable in practice is another matter, as it is very easy to make digital copies of both. But if one takes the stand that an author of a book (be it an e-book or a printed one) has the right to set a price for a copy for her work, and benefit from protection by copyright if she so chooses to, I don't see how a recording of an original piece of music is any different.