5 ms·
In the eighties, lots of young ideologues were worried about a Malthusian future; there would be more people in the world than we could feed. They decided that
by bryanlarsen 12y ago
In the eighties, lots of young ideologues were worried about a Malthusian future; there would be more people in the world than we could feed. They decided that genetic engineering was going to save the world by adding micro-nutrients to rice, by making essential food crops drought resistant and higher yielding, et cetera. So they studied genetic engineering in University and joined Monsanto, which was obviously the company that was most likely to make this happen.
Thirty years later, they are vilified by very similar ideologues.
- biohax2015 12y agoSeriously. At this point it's either we use the biotechnology that many scientists have made their life's work, or millions of people starve.
- Pxtl 12y agoThe differences in yield between fully modern farming techniques and modern organic farming is not that massive. It's substantial, I'll grant you - something like 13-25% difference. And that's with the fully bevy of certified organic practices - non-fossil-fuel soils, natural pesticides, etc. How much incremental improvement in yield do you actually think comes from the GMO side of things? The primary difference seems to be in manpower - Organic practices require far more manpower... but the world isn't short of manpower. There is more than enough food in the world. Starvation happens because of infrastructure and economics, not insufficient yields. Norman Borlaug's green revolution would have happened with or without GMOs. My main criticism of GMOs isn't the genetic alterations themselves, but the way they enable excessive pesticide use, IP law abuses, and monoculture.
- sp332 12y agoThere is more than enough food in the world. Starvation happens because of infrastructure and economics, not insufficient yields. That's true now, but it won't be true when we add another billion or so people. That's only 15 years from now!
- sampo 12y ago> Norman Borlaug's green revolution Actually, in Norman Borlaugh's time, also his plant breeding methods (crossbreeding etc.) and the resulting crop cultivars were considered "unnatural" by some [1]. Also, when the potato was brought to Europe centuries ago, people were first very suspicious: "Even peasants refused to eat from a plant that produced ugly, misshapen tubers and that had come from a heathen civilization. Some felt that the potato plant's resemblance to plants in the nightshade family hinted that it was the creation of witches or devils." [2] [1] http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2007/jul/18/he-saved-a-billion-lives/ http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2007/jul/18/he-saved-a-b... [2] http://www.history-magazine.com/potato.html http://www.history-magazine.com/potato.html
- gusfoo 12y ago> My main criticism of GMOs isn't the genetic alterations themselves, but the way they enable excessive pesticide use, IP law abuses, and monoculture. You clearly know nothing at all about GMOs, because if you did you'd be cheering on the fact that GMOs use less pesticide and herbicide than organic crops do, and the ones used are less toxic than the organic equivalents. And monocultures have nothing to do with GMOs. Why would you spend time typing up such nonsense?
- Blahah 12y ago> There is more than enough food in the world. Starvation happens because of infrastructure and economics, not insufficient yields. Norman Borlaug's green revolution would have happened with or without GMOs. Norman Borlaug's green revolution did happen without GMOs - it was all about breeding (e.g for shorter stems) and intensification of nutrient inputs. While food distribution is a major problem, it's simply not true that food supply is not also a problem. It is entirely unfeasible for all the food in the world to be efficiently distributed to everyone who needs food from the places it is currently grown in the time we have available before peak population. Food supply is a limiting factor. Enabling people to grow more food close to where they live will save lives. This is why we (plant geneticists) continue trying to raise yields. Try telling a starving family in (Indonesia|Tanzania|Bangladesh) that the problem isn't their pathetic rice crop yield, it's that Americans are throwing away cheeseburgers. We can feed a lot of those people with better agricultural technology. > My main criticism of GMOs isn't the genetic alterations themselves, but the way they enable excessive pesticide use, IP law abuses, and monoculture. GMOs don't enable any of those things. Monoculture is a route to efficient food production - it was around long before GMOs. We have it because it was the path of least resistance to massive scale food production. Total amount of pesticides might be increased in some cases with GMOs (though in many it is reduced), but the important thing is that current GMOs enable us to use much, much less harmful pesticides. Glyphosate is probably the safest herbicide the world has ever seen. Some of the alternatives are just terrifyingly harmful. IP law is certainly used by some seed companies, but I'd argue it's generally not abused to anywhere near the level it is by tech companies. If you read the court documents from Monsanto cases they are almost always reasonable and subsequently misrepresented by activists.
- bryanlarsen 12y ago"13-25% difference." Where do you get those numbers from? Anecdotally in my experience, organic crop yields are well under half of those from conventional crops. Often organic crops are left in the field to rot because there's so little there that it'd cost more to harvest the field than could be gained selling the crop. In our area, organic cropland is typically left fallow 1 year in 3 to control weeds, so there's an automatic 33% yield loss before any other factors.
- zenogais 12y agoThe point is that its food - something everyone who eats it has an active interest in - but it's privately owned and therefore no one has the transparency or say they'd like in how it is produced.
- abofh 12y agoBut, like all privately developed technology, buyers have the choice not to purchase it. Monsanto isn't saying that they own corn any more than Microsoft says they own OS's, or google claiming they own search. At the end of the day, you put up money to purchase something (or make a choice to use something) -- be it a product made of corn, the OS you use, or search engine - do you look at price, profitability and compatibility with your workflow, or "GMO free", "FOSS" and "Privacy Protecting"? You may answer the latter in all cases - and I can respect that, but there's a large number of people to whom added productivity/profitability is worth a commercial or financial commitment that may come with legal restrictions.
- zenogais 12y agoThis is one of those classical myths we tell ourselves - that buyers have an encyclopedic knowledge of the commodities they buy. In such a world oversight and protection wouldn't be needed. Unfortunately, we don't live in that world.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- gusfoo 12y ago> I love the science. It's the non-competitive market I don't like. "Get your seeds from us under any terms we dictate" isn't a healthy state, or in the public interest. But that is not an accurate reflection of reality. Any farmer is free to buy any seed from any company at any time. They can even visit the seed banks and grow ancient varieties if there would be someone to sell the resultant food to. The whole "you must buy our seed" thing is just the another mimetic anti-GMO trope. > And thanks to a number of factors beginning with patent arsenals and ending with good luck with that, your chances of leaving Monsanto to start a viable competitor are somewhere a few orders of magnitude below "disrupt Facebook. And yet Monsanto are not the biggest seed company by a long way. That accolade goes to Dow.