5 ms·
Of course this happens, and it's an obvious technique. I'm sure that not having a facebook account adds to your score, using AdBlock adds to your score, mention
by pessimizer 12y ago
Of course this happens, and it's an obvious technique. I'm sure that not having a facebook account adds to your score, using AdBlock adds to your score, mentioning the NSA online adds to your score, refusing cookies adds to your score, using Linux adds to your score, etc.
That's how a police state works. (XKeyScore += 5)
My mother was involved in civil rights, so she has a file. It's fine that I have a file too. Hopefully I'll be gone before they start going door to door.
edit: http://www.linuxjournal.com/content/nsa-linux-journal-extremist-forum-and-its-readers-get-flagged-extra-surveillance http://www.linuxjournal.com/content/nsa-linux-journal-extrem...
- Holbein 12y agoYeah, and if you don't even have an internet connection, NSA is putting you on their most wanted list. Give me a break. Not doing something can't make you more suspicious.
- pessimizer 12y ago>Not doing something can't make you more suspicious. That's just stupid.
- Holbein 12y agoNo. That's common sense. If you don't do something on the internet, there is no data. No data = nothing suspicious.
- pessimizer 12y agoThere is no state of no data. You are known to exist, you are known for not participating in something that is common for your group. That, in combination with the thousands of other data points about you will determine whether you are of interest. That may determine whether your car gets searched during a traffic stop, or whether you're put on a no-fly list. This is not complicated to build, it is simple to build, and the only logical way of accomplishing what the government claims that they're attempting to accomplish.
- Holbein 12y agoI think you're overestimating the NSA's capability to cross-reference your actions and compare them to "what people like me should typically do". My point is, you should not change your behaviour to be a lesser target to the NSA. You'd just quickly become super paranoid. Instead you should live your live exactly the same, and if the NSA tries to make your live bad, that's the moment when you call them out on it - after all, it's the NSA that is behaving out of line. So they should change, not you. Oh, and http://defundthensa.com/ http://defundthensa.com/ , sure.
- pessimizer 12y agoI think you're overestimating the difficulty of the problem. The difficult part is access to the channels of information. After that, it's a matter of applying well-known algorithms while filtering and processing streams. The only reason that I suspect that the government is still terrible at this is because they have to rely on government contractors to implement it. If they're intentionally funding startups that happen to be developing tools in the spaces they need, though, it's only a matter of a (short) time until the systems they have are settled and dependable, and they can concentrate on innovation. >it's the NSA that is behaving out of line. So they should change, not you. This is also silly. That's like people who walk into speeding traffic because they have the right-of-way. You won't get to hear about how the trial turns out from your grave.
- Holbein 12y ago> You won't get to hear about how the trial turns out from your grave. Well, in contrast to you, I plan to enjoy my life instead of wasting it by worrying about some possible bad actor spying on me, which is what I'm must read is how you spend your life. Sure, fight the NSA by engaging a little bit politically, and buying the right things. But apart from that, don't worry so much, man.
- pessimizer 12y agoI'm not worried (edit: about anything immediate), I'm not failing to partake in anything that I ever would, and I don't live any differently than I ever have. You're projecting something onto me, and that's not a great way to have a productive discussion.
- NotAtWork 12y agoThe lack of data about you on the internet is likely more anomalous than whatever data you're trying to hide originally was. Not finding something when you should find something is suspicious.
- happyscrappy 12y agoEven if you go full Stallman data leaks everywhere. Credit card purchase data is bought and sold daily as is satellite imaging time.
- rosser 12y agoThe absence of data is, itself, data.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoNo data may be very suspicious if some data is expected to be found. See http://abstrusegoose.com/396 http://abstrusegoose.com/396 for an illustrative example.
- sliverstorm 12y agoHave you never heard the classic movie line? It's quiet. TOO quiet.
- psykovsky 12y ago> Hopefully I'll be gone before they start going door to door. Why care about the rest of your family that will still be here to endure the rest... or the rest of us. You have no kids, right?
- pessimizer 12y agoI don't. If you want to fight, I'll support you. I donate money to causes that I know raise my XKeyscore, and I subscribe to magazines that I know raise my XKeyscore. My long term plan is to find somewhere where this is not happening, and move there, though. If I were planning to stay here for the rest of my life, I wouldn't risk political posting on the internet, donating, or subscribing. You'll get more help for me as long as I can rationalize it as only worsening a temporary situation.
- canvia 12y agoUnless the first amendment has changed, there is no risk for consumers.
- pessimizer 12y agoI don't know what this means.
- dredmorbius 12y agoYeah. Sure. http://vault.fbi.gov/cointel-pro http://vault.fbi.gov/cointel-pro
- higherpurpose 12y agoAmplify this by 100, and welcome to Minority Report, where you get a arrested for having a "very high score". This is where the "mass surveillance" and "let's monitor everyone just in case they might do something bad" thinking inevitably ends up.
- acqq 12y ago> Amplify this by 100, and welcome to Minority Report, where you get a arrested for having a "very high score". Or maybe welcome to Oceania of 1984, having to deal with Thinkpol: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thoughtcrime http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thoughtcrime "The Thought Police (thinkpol in Newspeak) are the secret police of the novel Nineteen Eighty-Four. It is their job to uncover and punish thoughtcrime."
- runiq 12y ago>thinkpol Yup, we don't have thinkpol yet (and hopefully we never will), but we do have a pretty damn good analogy to it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predictive_policing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predictive_policing
- sliverstorm 12y ago... you get a arrested for having a "very high score". Considering this is PRECISELY how spam filtering works, it doesn't seem entirely irrational. Much like spam filtering, it would all come down to dialing in your filters and picking a good threshold. Hell, if the system was good enough, it could actually improve freedoms. We currently arrest many innocent people as part of the legal process (who are later exonerated). What if our "arrest filter" outperformed the current system, in terms of percentage of innocent people arrested? It doesn't have to be perfect to be better.
- pyre 12y agoThe 'arrest filter' is only as good as the inputs. As it currently stands, I'm sure that things like "uses drugs recreationally," "is black," "is Muslim," and "is not Christian," would end up counting towards your 'arrest score.' And also because your arrest score is computed by a machine rather than a human, that will be used as an excuse to call it unimpeachable. E.g. "Machines can't be racist, so the arrest score going after lots of poor, Black men must mean that there's something to it."
- tomphoolery 12y agoI wish I could find out my XKeyScore. I'm genuinely interested in how threatening the NSA believes average people are.
- pessimizer 12y agoXKeyScore is the new credit report:)
- lucb1e 12y agoCredit report? Wait until fiancés gets the legal right to see your score.
- digitalengineer 12y agoSomeone should be a Check-My-XKeyScore site. Answer several questions (do you have a VPN? Use Linux, etc) and show the submitter how high he ranks in the NSA's eyes. 'share via Twitter etc' Could be fun and easy way to show people just how crazy this is...
- anigbrowl 12y agoThat's how any sort of metric works - your credit score, your Acxiom consumer category score, whatever metrics Facebook and Google use to score user engagement. This is just how life is when databases are ubiquitous. After I bought a house and my name began appearing in property tax databases I started getting lots of (paper-based) commercial spam for things homeowners are more likely to buy, like different sorts of insurance, refinancing, satellite TV service yadda yadda. When it emerged after 9-11 that various government agencies had failed to 'join the dots' by not sharing intelligence information effectively, there was a lot of public support for better-coordinated and more proactive intelligence gather, notwithstanding warnings about the risk to civil liberties. So collectively we got what we asked for. The lack of public outrage or mass demonstrations against the NSA strongly suggests that a large majority are OK with this state of affairs, especially since they're used to data collection in a commercial context.
- pessimizer 12y agoI think people are too busy, too desperate, and too badly educated to do anything about it. Most people were only being kept solvent by credit cards, borrowing against the equity in their houses, and taking massive loans for major purchases - and when credit got tight, people started setting up tents on Wall Street. The next crash is going to be a terrifying experience. A little bit of war, however, will probably dull any of that.
- cargo54 12y agoThis is the agenda that justifies all this: http://100777.com/nwo/barbarians http://100777.com/nwo/barbarians and was planned before internet was mainstream. This is information released in 1989. Read and judge for yourself
- paletoy 12y agoAnd people don't really believe that protest(at least a peaceful one) can create a meaningful change. and judging how things are going lately ,they might be right. Case in point: obama care.
- deleted 12y ago
- andy_ppp 12y agoNot doing any of those things will massively bump up your score; you must be trying to avoid detection.