3 ms·
>> It's not an inconsistency, it's a disagreement over property and aggression. In the same way that I disagree that taxes are a form of violence, yes. However
by Nursie 12y ago
>> It's not an inconsistency, it's a disagreement over property and aggression.
In the same way that I disagree that taxes are a form of violence, yes. However if we're reducing everything to violence (as libertarians tend to) then I don't see these as different.
>> To you, land belongs to whole humanity
As something of a pragmatist, I consider property rights to be useful rather than absolute and have no particular views on universal owenership. I'm not exactly a Marxist.
But I wonder what the philosophical basis is for appropriation of land in a system that (on the surface) claims to be absolute, particularly in the principle of non-aggression.
Homesteading is wonderful in a system where land is unlimited, it can be seen as an extension of the moral right to the work of your own hands. But in a system where land is limited, the very act of appropriating does deny the resource to others, and any defence of that appropriation would surely be violent?
In fact Locke appears to have acknowledged this (from the page you linked to) - The Lockean Proviso.
And yes, left-wing libertarians are not often encountered on tech boards in my experience :)
- john_b 12y ago> "However if we're reducing everything to violence (as libertarians tend to)" Libertarians tend to reduce arguments to discussions of violence since it is the fundamental primitive around which most governments (or lack thereof) are organized. Specifically, a government (at least from a libertarian view) is any institution which exercises a monopoly on violence in a particular region. The mechanisms by which they maintain and exercise this monopoly serve to classify them. This reduction is just a starting point though. It is to philosophies of government what evolution is to biology: a founding principle that serves as a lens to understand the rest of it. But there is much more to biology than just a knowledge of evolution, and likewise libertarian thinking. Libertarians also, as a rule, follow the non-aggression principle and are not opposed to violence in all cases (e.g. self-defense, defense of others who did not initiate violence themselves, etc) [1]. This is a little less common amongst left-leaning libertarians, however. > "Homesteading is wonderful in a system where land is unlimited, it can be seen as an extension of the moral right to the work of your own hands. But in a system where land is limited, the very act of appropriating does deny the resource to others" Any philosophy of government has to deal with the blunt fact that the world is one of finite resources. Libertarians of different stripes have a lot to say about property in various forms; it's not something they always agree on. Libertarianism does not have as its direct goal maximizing the efficiency of resource usage, though many would argue that libertarian policies would have that result indirectly. Virtually all would argue that privately owned resources are at least available to others via the market (i.e. for a price), whereas any resource that is publicly monopolized is only available to others if the controlling government decides to share it (which is more likely in democratic societies, but not by their nature, required). [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libertarianism#Personal_autonomy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libertarianism#Personal_autonom...
- Nursie 12y agoWhat that seems to come down to is a pragmatic argument about land use rather than an absolute one about morality. In which case libertarianism is no more fundamentally correct or moral than any other system, we're simply arguing about the extent of the state and personal vs. group rights. Which is fine by me, so long as libertarians stop proclaiming to have a consistent and correct system.
- mercer 12y ago> And yes, left-wing libertarians are not often encountered on tech boards in my experience. This fascinates me. It seems both very American and very 'techy' to be a right-wing libertarian (or is that the wrong term?). In many ways both views are very opposed, but there are striking similarities too (especially on a 'social' level, which interests me as a social scientist). It's like we're siblings: entirely different personalities that often clash, but a strong mutual understanding and similar 'values' through similar background/upbringing. With the disclaimer that I'm still very much investigating and that I might very well be wrong, it seems to me that the left wing tends to be more on the 'social' side of things, and more burdened/informed by the European past, and perhaps too theoretical and big in scope. The right wing seems to focus more on the individual side of things, is perhaps a little too uninformed by Europe's past (and the role of property in that), and sometimes seems a little too much like 'let's change everything without questioning our basic assumptions'. I find that the techier, more entrepreneurial side of myself is more attracted to the right-wing libertarian views that seems more optimistic, but that the social scientist side of me combined with a very communal, religious upbringing (in a 'socialist' country) is more attracted to the left-wing libertarian views that feel a little more pessimistic/cranky at times. Perhaps that is why HN seems to have more right-wing libertarians, whereas my intellectual and often decidedly anti-technology circles ar almost entirely left-wing libertarians (if they're libertarians to begin with). Some thoughts from my armchair...