8 ms·
I think it's plenty arguable that rich people create jobs. For example: if rich people don't create jobs, then how can it be their fault that there are not eno
by snowwrestler 12y ago
I think it's plenty arguable that rich people create jobs.
For example: if rich people don't create jobs, then how can it be their fault that there are not enough jobs? If jobs really come from the middle class, why hasn't the middle class created more of them? It would be in their self-interest to do so.
Arguing that wages for middle class jobs should go up raises the question of where that wage money should come from. The answer is capital, i.e. rich people.
Societies without rich people are also societies that struggle to create well-paying jobs. The USSR and China attempted to eliminate rich people by adopting a communist economy. What happened is that the people in the government were the only ones who got rich, and the government was the only source of jobs. That is not a coincidence.
Since the end of the 20th Century, both Russia and China have relaxed government control of capital, and the result has been an increase in both rich people and well-paying jobs in those countries.
Finally, consider technological innovation; a rich source of job creation. It is created by investment, sometimes seemingly far-fetched or speculative investment. Google and the iPhone are two examples of products that were not guaranteed success, and were even dismissed by some industry experts when released. Each has directly created thousands of jobs and indirectly enabled at least tens of thousands more in supporting or related fields.
But before there was Google or the iPhone, there were rich people writing checks to the people who envisioned them.
BTW this is NOT an argument against a higher minimum wage. In fact I think the questions of "where jobs come from" and "what is the ideal minimum wage" are only very loosely connected.
edits: spellings
- clavalle 12y agoHoly smokes, where to begin... > if rich people don't create jobs, then how can it be their fault that there are not enough jobs? No one is blaming rich people. They are blaming the system (aspects of it, at least) that we have collectively created. >If jobs really come from the middle class, why hasn't the middle class created more of them? Much like fire needs heat, oxygen, and a fuel a successful business needs entrepreneurs, capital, and demand. If the middle class doesn't have disposable income that limits available capital and demand for creating and sustaining a business by middle class entrepreneurs. >Arguing that wages for middle class jobs should go up raises the question of where that wage money should come from. The answer is capital, i.e. rich people. Creating value creates money. That's how this whole thing works. It doesn't have to come from rich people, it comes, ultimately, from profit. >The USSR and China attempted to eliminate rich people by adopting a communist economy. You are jumping a bit far, there. I don't think anyone is advocating communism. >But before there was Google or the iPhone, there were rich people writing checks to the people who envisioned them. Capital doesn't have to come from rich people. Just as centralization of economic control is inefficient and ultimately harmful in communist systems you cite, it is just as destructive in a capitalist system.
- snowwrestler 12y agoThe terminology makes it very difficult to have a productive discussion. "Rich people" are not rich the way that Asian people are Asian. A rich person is simply a person who has the legal right to direct large amounts of wealth. Conversely, every piece of wealth has at least one person who has the legal right to direct it. So when you make a statement like "It doesn't have to come from rich people, it comes, ultimately, from profit," it's a somewhat meaningless distinction because every piece of profit is controlled by a person somewhere. A rich person is just a person who has the legal right to direct large amounts of profit (i.e. wealth). Therefore their decisions will have larger effects on job creation. Ultimately it doesn't matter that jobs are created by rich people. What matters is what policy steps we can take to improve job creation, wages, and opportunity for U.S. citizens. Unfortunately actual policy discussions are too frequently railroaded by framing arguments like "do rich people create jobs."
- clavalle 12y ago>So when you make a statement like "It doesn't have to come from rich people, it comes, ultimately, from profit," it's a somewhat meaningless distinction because every piece of profit is controlled by a person somewhere. It is not meaningless at all. Rich people are individuals that control large amounts of wealth. This is opposed to groups of people who collectively control large amounts of wealth. A superintendent of a large school district can control a billion dollars of wealth but that doesn't make him or her rich (though they make a good salary I'd still classify them, personally, as solidly middle class). And it certainly does matter if we rely increasingly on fewer and fewer individuals (due to increasing inequality) to make economic decisions for everyone. It is inherently inefficient. What we are talking about is identifying this trend as a problem and implementing policies to counteract it before it becomes intractable.
- snowwrestler 12y agoSchool districts don't make a profit, they are funded from profits. Before a school district can have a billion dollars to spend, that wealth has to be generated somehow. > And it certainly does matter if we rely increasingly on fewer and fewer individuals (due to increasing inequality) to make economic decisions for everyone. I agree with this, but it doesn't disagree with the idea that rich people create jobs.