4 ms·
I still don't really understand libertarianism. I'm not sure what it is that gives someone the moral right to reserve a section of the surface of the earth by
by Nursie 12y ago
I still don't really understand libertarianism.
I'm not sure what it is that gives someone the moral right to reserve a section of the surface of the earth by force of arms in a system where all violence is considered morally wrong (and so many things can be apparently considered violence).
If you can use violence to take away my access to land, I don't see how that differs from the rest of us taking some of your income.
- jMyles 12y agoMany libertarians, including some as this festival, don't regard land property as absolute, or in some cases, even just at all. For example, some believe that they have a right to build and defend a home, but not a right to prevent people from reasonably traversing the land, so long as they don't disturb anything. Come to the festival and ask these questions; you'll be surprised at the diversity and sophistication of the answers you'll get.
- mercer 12y agoThat's a great recommendation, actually. I'm still shocked and embarrassed at how I once lumped all forms of libertarianism into the 'primitivist anarchism' pile, only to discover that a lot of thought and practice has gone into the various libertarian systems. I assumed, for the longest time, that they were all basically people who couldn't make life work or were lazy, and decided to rationalize this as a choice. The weed-smoking, squatting type who badly needs a shower and a haircut, and secretly relies on others for money and a safety-net (mind, all of these things don't necessarily go together!). Ironically, I spent much of my life as a Christian battling stereotypes that were based on American right-wing evangelical extremism. I should've known better. Experiencing some of these 'libertarian' environments and reading some of the literature painted a much more nuanced picture, and enriched my views tremendously, even if just because the views were so radically different from what I was familiar with. At some point in my life I decided that it would be good to spend significant effort to learn about views that are alien to me. Because even if they don't make a convincing argument in the end, they make me question whatever system I have in my head, and I feel that that's always a good thing.
- LordKano 12y agoI get how you could not agree with it but what's not to understand about "Leave me alone while I leave you alone" as a distilled worldview?
- Nursie 12y agoNo, that's fine, I understand it as a philosophy and have some sympathy with the motivations behind it. I also think it would be a horrible thing to put into practice for a variety of reasons. But the inconsistency strikes me as odd.
- zo1 12y ago"But the inconsistency strikes me as odd." Hello, I'll be your friendly anarcho-capitalist for the day. If you have any questions, please feel free to ask away.
- Nursie 12y agoOK, well at the basis of it, how can taxes be considered a form of violent theft if property (particularly private real estate defended with deadly force) is not? (apologies if this is not the view you take! I'm getting the picture this is not a consistent thing across libertarians, I may be getting confused by objectivists....)
- zo1 12y agoThe main difference, if I understand what you're asking, is consent. As an example, I'll use myself. I currently live in a sort of "shared" property. We have private components (houses), and shared components (facilities, gardens, pool, etc) in between that we all have access to. We all consent to paying a monthly levy so that maintenance and communal things are taken care of. This includes insurance for damage to our property, and all sorts of stuff. We also have a set of rules that we all agree on, and vote on periodically, etc. Not much unlike a state. The main difference being I can just up and move to a different one if I don't really like this one. As someone who's also emigrated a few times, I'll let you know that it's not as easy as they claim. No one assumed, or coerced us in to this agreement. We as sound-minded individuals consented to it. We weren't automatically put into such an agreement by virtue of being born on this land. Would you call it theft if I went and mowed your lawn (without you asking), and then had your employer deduct my fee/charge for doing so from your paycheck? Also, take care when discussing this topic. Libertarianism is a bit different to anarcho-capitalism. Libertarians generally feel that we still need government to do basic things such as enforce "laws" and provide state protection. Not ideal, but for a lot of people, it's a starting point into attempting to devise a perfectly moral system founded on sound first-principles.
- MCRed 12y ago>... in a system where all violence is considered morally wrong (and so many things can be apparently considered violence). You seem to be referring to the non-aggression principle. Libertarians believe that the initiation of force is immoral. This is not the same as "all force". Thus, self defense is moral to a libertarian, while aggression is not. >If you can use violence to take away my access to land You seem to be claiming a right to access any land anywhere at any time? Doesn't that conflict with government's belief that it owns the land? >I don't see how that differs from the rest of us taking some of your income. You also seem to see libertarians as land owners and "the rest of us" as taking income in compensation (for the land?) Taking away someones' property is roughly equivalent. If you want to argue that nobody can own land, you can do that. But that argument is orthogonal to libertarianism. There are libertarians who believe nobody can own land.
- Nursie 12y ago>> You seem to be referring to the non-aggression principle. Libertarians believe that the initiation of force is immoral. This is not the same as "all force". Thus, self defense is moral to a libertarian, while aggression is not. Yup, that's exactly what I'm talking about. >> You seem to be claiming a right to access any land anywhere at any time? Doesn't that conflict with government's belief that it owns the land? No, I'm not really talking about governments, more the abstract idea that on some level all property is theft from the commons, particularly land which is a limited resource. It seems to be a common theme amongst libertarians I've talked to on the net that they consider tax to be theft at the point of a gun, but not private land ownership even though the point of the gun is very much still there. >> You also seem to see libertarians as land owners and "the rest of us" as taking income in compensation (for the land?) It's not my view that libertarians are landowners, I'm talking about the attitudes of libertarians towards their land and the rights they assume around it. >> Taking away someones' property is roughly equivalent. If you want to argue that nobody can own land, you can do that. I don't dispute land ownership rights under our current model at all, from a utilitarian standpoint they allow society to operate, without them we would have a hard time doing a lot of things. It's the aspect of application of force being bad in one circumstance (taking my money) and not in another (get off my land or I'll kill you!). >> But that argument is orthogonal to libertarianism. There are libertarians who believe nobody can own land. Then I have previously only encountered the internet libertarian breed that are inconsistent in this way.
- john_b 12y agoBy that argument, how can you justify reserving the section of earth (by force of arms if necessary) that your house resides on? Aren't you taking away others' access to that land? Presumably they paid to reserve the land for a week, just like you can pay to reserve a house and the land it sits on for a period of time. I don't understand what is complicated or un-libertarian about that.
- Nursie 12y ago>> By that argument, how can you justify reserving the section of earth (by force of arms if necessary) that your house resides on? Aren't you taking away others' access to that land? That's actually exactly what I'm talking about! Not the festival but the general principle. >> Presumably they paid to reserve the land for a week, just like you can pay to reserve a house and the land it sits on for a period of time. Who are you paying? You presumably haven't paid the whole of the rest of humanity in perpetuity, yet it can be considered right to defend a piece of land you consider your property with deadly force? All I'm saying is that it's not really consistent with the non-aggression principle.
- icebraining 12y agoIt's not an inconsistency, it's a disagreement over property and aggression. To you, land belongs to whole humanity and therefore it's an aggression on others to prevent them from accessing. But you shouldn't assume that everyone believes the same. To many a libertarian, lands initially belongs to nobody, and anyone can appropriate it freely: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homestead_principle http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homestead_principle And of course, there's a whole field of libertarians who reject property, regardless of what the prevalence of right-wing libertarians on the Internet might indicate: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Left-libertarianism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Left-libertarianism
- Nursie 12y ago>> It's not an inconsistency, it's a disagreement over property and aggression. In the same way that I disagree that taxes are a form of violence, yes. However if we're reducing everything to violence (as libertarians tend to) then I don't see these as different. >> To you, land belongs to whole humanity As something of a pragmatist, I consider property rights to be useful rather than absolute and have no particular views on universal owenership. I'm not exactly a Marxist. But I wonder what the philosophical basis is for appropriation of land in a system that (on the surface) claims to be absolute, particularly in the principle of non-aggression. Homesteading is wonderful in a system where land is unlimited, it can be seen as an extension of the moral right to the work of your own hands. But in a system where land is limited, the very act of appropriating does deny the resource to others, and any defence of that appropriation would surely be violent? In fact Locke appears to have acknowledged this (from the page you linked to) - The Lockean Proviso. And yes, left-wing libertarians are not often encountered on tech boards in my experience :)
- arethuza 12y ago"If you can use violence to take away my access to land" Of course there are countries, including parts of the UK, where you have a right to go pretty much where you want in terms of access to land (with some sensible restrictions - powered vehicles etc.) and civilization doesn't seem to have ended. NB For a fascinating account of the extremely dubious history of land ownership in Scotland I can recommend "The Poor Had no Lawyers: Who Owns Scotland and How They Got it": http://www.amazon.co.uk/The-Poor-Had-No-Lawyers/dp/178027114X http://www.amazon.co.uk/The-Poor-Had-No-Lawyers/dp/178027114...
- icebraining 12y agoI'm not a libertarian in part due to my doubts about land property, but having read a little about their position, I have to say it's a little more nuanced than that. Here's Rothbard on the issue: http://mises.org/rothbard/ethics/eleven.asp http://mises.org/rothbard/ethics/eleven.asp
- TallGuyShort 12y agoI don't subscribe to the extremes that libertarianism can be taken to, but I support most of the party's candidates because I simply want to be left alone. I give a huge portion of my income to charities and causes that I feel are good for humanity, I want to take responsibility and pay for everything I personally consume, and then I want to be left alone. I find so often that the 2 major parties in the US interfere in how I want to live my life when I'm not hurting anyone. So I don't think there should be no emergency services and no public infrastructure, but I think the government should be a fraction of the size it is, and there should be a fraction of the laws that there are. In keeping with the "take responsibility" theme, I think booze and marijuana are a horrible thing to have near guns, and I was very alarmed at the initial description of this event...
- falcolas 12y ago> I find so often that the 2 major parties in the US interfere in how I want to live my life when I'm not hurting anyone. The sad truth is that most of these laws exist because there exists a minority of people who are not as reasonable as you. We get more and more laws in large part because those people are finding loopholes in current laws and getting away with murder. The unfortunate thing is that our attempts to reign in the minority bone the majority.
- icebraining 12y agoReally? Are most laws actually justified on the basis of "we really wish we could be libertarian, but we need to curb this behavior"? I don't think I've ever saw a law justified on those grounds.
- mercer 12y agoMaybe most laws are not justified in light of libertianism(s) specifically, but I do find that a common theme in the justifications is that without these laws there will inevitably be chaos and humanity will implode. It's the basic 'think of the children' argument.
- 12y ago
- kitd 12y agoOn the spectrum of theories of how the human race might best thrive, libertarianism occupies the extreme right, where the free market and evolution reign completely over community and self-denial for the common good. While the extreme left theory has been shown in the 20th C to be unachievable, we haven't seen yet an extreme right version in real-life (or if we have, we've forgotten what it looks like). The libertarians want to try it out and I predict a similar disaster.
- Nursie 12y agoI would agree with you there. Libertarianism seems to me to be a recipe for a society that collapses into neo-feudalism as an ownership class of corporations and individuals emerge and (without any government controls in place) effectively forms a new aristocracy. One may say we're not too far from that now I suppose, and I have a lot of sympathy for the idea that we're over-taxed, over-ruled, over-governed etc etc. But yeah...
- MCRed 12y agoSo, because you're afraid that we might become slaves of a new aristocracy, you support us being the slaves of the current government, which can't even operate a fair election?
- Nursie 12y agoEnjoy fighting your straw man there. Looking at patterns of human activity in the past, I do believe that libertarianism would go that way, yes. That doesn't automatically mean that I'm a huge fan of the status quo, though. There is more spectrum to political thought than libertarians on one side who want to change everything and statists on the other who want to change nothing.
- icebraining 12y agohttp://www.amazon.com/Markets-Not-Capitalism-Individualist-Inequality/dp/1570272425 http://www.amazon.com/Markets-Not-Capitalism-Individualist-I...
- 12y ago