2 ms·
The earth was created over 4.5 billion years ago. I think 1986 is looking pretty young. One of my least favorite arguments on HN goes like this: foo is old. Fu
by asveikau 12y ago
The earth was created over 4.5 billion years ago. I think 1986 is looking pretty young.
One of my least favorite arguments on HN goes like this: foo is old. Full stop. Entirety of argument. As if by virtue of being "old" (definition varies) it should be obvious to everyone that it's not as suitable as whatever thing popped up overnight.
- PeterGriffin 12y agoThat's quite insightful to compare a 1986 network protocol to a 1986 planet, thank you for enlightening me. Now I feel justified comparing a 1986 network protocol to a 1986 pizza. Would you take a bite?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- asveikau 12y agoMy point was that old is not a cheap way to boost your argument. TCP is also old. So? A list of reasons why it doesn't work would be more convincing. IMAP works.
- PeterGriffin 12y agoUnderstood. Saying "old" is an invalid argument, even among people who are supposed to understand the context. But comparing IMAP to Earth is very valid. It's a marvel of rational thought. You must be very popular. Everyone who uses IMAP knows its weaknesses. I'm not going to write a book here. It's very, very slow; it has bizarre choices - I still don't understand why I need to delete my message, and then delete the deleted message; it doesn't support now commonplace modern features like tags; its push extension is so naive and resource taxing, companies just implement their own, even when otherwise trying to use IMAP. But just being slow is an argument enough. I use a few email clients, only one client uses IMAP, and my stomach curls into a ball every time I open it, because I know it'll be synching forever. Even if IMAP being old is a poor argument, me getting old while waiting for it synching, sure is.
- ebiester 12y agoHow about this: There are use cases in 2014 that are not covered by a standard built in 1986. As such, to accommodate these things, people have made incompatible extensions to the format, making interoperability very difficult. As such, we need to standardize the way we do these expanded things, whether we put some formal extensions to IMAP or we replace it.