9 ms·
My advice to people who want to work in a startup is always very simple: Ignore any equity. If you'd take the job without any equity then take the job. If the
by onion2k 12y ago
My advice to people who want to work in a startup is always very simple: Ignore any equity.
If you'd take the job without any equity then take the job. If the equity is part of your reason for taking the job, you probably shouldn't take it.
Base rate neglect[1] means we are terrible at evaluating the probability of equity being valuable. For every story about someone making millions out of their equity when the startup they're working for exits there are thousands of stories of people who walked away with nothing but a few years having fun solving challenging problems. That is the reason to work in a startup, because that is the definite, concrete thing on the table. If you want to make millions in software, get a job writing code at a bank and invest your salary.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Base_rate_fallacy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Base_rate_fallacy
- wahsd 12y agoIt has always struck me as little more than a fraud when employees are hired with promises of equity and then additional rounds or other trickery simply dilute their share and contributions to approaching zero and they walk away having put their work, effort, and innovation into making the parasites of our society wealthy just for investing.
- Afton 12y ago> making the parasites of our society wealthy just for investing. Are they less parasitic if they just sit on their money, or are they parasites just for having the money in the first place?
- nullspace 12y agoVery true, and thanks for the link. I think that this also applies the other way around. If you're a founder building your early team, you should not hire people who want to join because of the equity. You should be bringing in people because they want to work on the problem for the salary that you can give them or promise to give. If you hire someone who has an expectation that he will make a million dollars in 4 years - it can lead to a lot of bitterness while you are building the product - especially when you are having a few bad months. Have seen this happening a bunch of times. Equity != Money, equity ~= the percentage of ownership and responsibility. Edit: Salary AND relatively high ownership of the company / product. Some people don't mind taking risks if they have an opportunity to build and own something great.
- ssumit 12y ago@equity ~= the percentage of ownership and responsibility. I think this holds in starting but ownership and responsibility is more on people's attitude. The equity will also remains the same(in %). I like your point about not joining/hiring to make few millions in 4 years. It probably is a driving factor in start but wont sustain for 4 years. Again people's attitude.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> equity ~= the percentage of ownership and responsibility. The entire point of the corporate form is separating degree of ownership from degree of responsibility.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- goldenkey 12y agoYour analogy is analogous to swiss cheese. It's near given that a volunteer firefighter will encounter a fire. However, most startups fail and provide poor job security. Equity should not be factored unless it is a tremendous amount. A couple percent is a joke. 10% and up becomes reasonable, and should be understood to be merely a bonus for working for an early-stage company. Just the job security alone is enough to balance out the equity. A shitty salary is not an excuse.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pessimizer 12y ago>This is like telling people thinking about becoming a volunteer firefighter that they should factor out of consideration the possibility of a fire. No, it's the opposite. The vast majority of firefighters eventually have to fight a fire. The vast majority of startups never catch fire.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- nawitus 12y ago>If you want to make millions in software, get a job writing code at a bank and invest your salary. Really? Even if some 'banks' pay better, these banks tend to be located in a handful of cities in the world - but there are startups in a lot of more locations. And it doesn't seem clear that finance firms pay that well: > The average base salary for a software engineer at a finance firm is $92,000, not far ahead of the average base salary of $87,000 for a software engineer at a tech company, according to salaries self-reported by employees on the jobs and careers site Glassdoor.com. http://www.marketwatch.com/story/silicon-valley-vs-wall-street-in-talent-war-2013-05-30 http://www.marketwatch.com/story/silicon-valley-vs-wall-stre...
- Wilduck 12y agoI think you may be missing the point. The way to make millions was less about "work at a bank" and more about "invest your salary". With any decent salary and good financial planning, a few million dollars by retirement is easily within reach.
- pnmahoney 12y agoThe best in finance have most of their compensation on a perfomance-bonus basis. so for a highly sought after trading associate (real example, really high valued financial institution), get 100k base but also getting forward guidance for a 200k bonus at an absolute minimum - e.g. if not turning out to be completely incompetent.
- cellis 12y agoAnd the best in software make tens of millions. What is your point? If we're comparing outliers, software engineers at software firms win by a long shot.
- pnmahoney 12y agoI think you've misunderstood my point, and in the process of doing that you've made one about which you are, in my experience, wrong. 1.) My point was to answer (here, I'm quoting) > And it doesn't seem clear that finance firms pay that well: > The average base salary for a software engineer at a finance firm is $92,000 by saying (and here I'm quoting the first sentence of my post) > The best in finance have most of their compensation on a perfomance-bonus basis. which is a relatively straightforward clarification, and on which point I went on to cite 100k base + 200k bonus. As to the second point? 2.) I've yet to meet anyone "software engineers at software firms" who "make tens of millions". Or maybe that's just biased to my age group? But the best from my circles turned a 200+ offer to found a startup, and then a year after that didn't work out, has since taken a 300+ offer. I can assure the level of talent required for something like this is, indeed, atypical. But I also can't say that you're wrong, since I can't say I'm familiar with every outlier case. Just that your experience has been different? Well, at risk of sounding nasty, I actually don't think what you're talking about -- again, people working as software engineers at software firms making annual incomes measured in multiple 8-figures -- exists anywhere, even as an outlier.
- dreese 12y agoI think about startup employee equity like this: Salary = compensation for doing the job Equity = compensation for taking the risk of working at a company with a high chance of failure Therefore, in the future, an employee with lots of equity should still be paid a normal salary/raise/bonus because the equity isn't "current" compensation for doing the job, but a reward for taking a risk long ago. But ignoring equity entirely is silly. Much better to say that you should consider salary and equity separately. One is for doing the job and the other for doing it now when uncertainty and the possibility of failure are high. Also, some people (like me) would trade an increase in equity for a smaller salary, so it's not a perfect separation. I had a job offer once that gave me two options to choose from, which was really cool.
- kristiandupont 12y ago>Equity = compensation for taking the risk of working at a company with a high chance of failure But if you are getting a normal salary, what is this risk?
- LaGrange 12y agoIncreased risk of losing your job.
- potatolicious 12y agoRight, but for engineers working in startup hubs, is that really a risk? You can pick up a phone and have a parade of offers on your desk in a few days. At most your risk is missing out on, say, a week's wages between jobs.
- ambrood 12y agoThere are many of us on an H1-B here potatolicious. Technically I get 10 days to wrap my affairs and leave the country, not to mention losing any greencard application...
- IgorPartola 12y agoSo why the hell do startups bother offering equity? It seems like for the founders there are only downsides in offering it, while for the employees there is no upside at all. Perhaps a better model for a two founder startup looking for a first employee is to just find a third partner who will only take equity (that is in double digit percentages), then actually start paying only salaries to person 4+.
- diego 12y agoThat's the same as asking why do startups bother with starting a company. If the startup succeeds, you want employees to be aligned with the company success and motivated to stay and vest. If the company doesn't succeed, the equity is worthless.
- IgorPartola 12y agoFrom a strictly monetary point of view (as in, not counting the type of environment in which you want to work, etc.), let's say E1 is the expectation value of a payout of your equity in cash. So E1 = probability of a sale where your type of stock does not get screwed * cash value of your stock in this deal. E1 is by all accounts and all advice incredibly low. Now let's look at E2 which will be the expectation value of a payout from investing your salary difference between a high paying corporate job and a startup. Let's set this number at a safe value of $50,000/year. Invest $50k a year for 10 years in some safe stock and bond mutual funds and I bet E2 and much higher than E1. Heck, invest $50k year in lottery tickets and you might make out better than working at a startup. That's not to say you should ignore startup jobs. They have a ton of other benefits. Just seems like equity is not one of them unless you are a founder.
- diego 12y agoMy former employees from IndexTank would differ. Our acquisition was life-changing to them. They didn't value equity at all when they joined, yet it worked out really well. You can think of employee equity as insurance against "I joined Facebook early and all I got was this lousy t-shirt."
- birken 12y agoEquity clearly has some value though, based on the fact that in any successful startup investors pay a lot of money for it. If you are considering taking equity, you should treat it like a potential investor would. Ask hard questions. Look at the balance sheet. Look at the company deck. Look at the previous funding rounds. Research the backgrounds of your potential coworkers. (If the company wont share this information with you... don't work there). Now even with this, you might say that a person would be terrible at evaluating that equity, and that is probably right. But investors are terrible at evaluating equity as well (considering that most funded startups also fail). But you do the best you can. Of course you need to decide whether you are interested in having a high-risk investment as part of your income, because if not you should not work at an early stage startup anyways. But don't ignore it completely.
- scrozier 12y agoYes, but investors spread their risk, as an essential part of their strategy. Employees have no such opportunity.
- silverlake 12y agoAren't common shares far down on the equity totem pole? Investors get preferred shares w/ liquidation preferences. Employees get diluted to nothing.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mason55 12y agoI think you're confusing some concepts here. Dilution happens when new shares are issued causing your percentage ownership to go down. In general it's not a bad thing - when there's a new funding round the new cash will increase the value of the company to balance out the dilution and you end up with your equity being the same value. The thing people forget about when they talk about dilution from new rounds is that the cash added to the balance sheet increases the value of the company, probably even more than 1:1. Liquidation preference is what happens when the preferred shares have a clause that says they are guaranteed 2x or 3x what they put in on any liquidity event. So if you take $10mm at 3x liquidation preference then that means any exit has an immediate $30mm taken off the table. A $30mm exit now becomes a $0 exit for the employees. Remember that generally the founders are holding common shares.
- eloff 12y agoI know you're not being serious about the bank thing, but I just want to say, if you're a programmer and you love what you do, and you're good enough to be choosy, don't work for anyone (especially banks!) whose main job is not software. There are a few exceptional companies, but mostly it's a good rule of thumb. Working for Dilbert's pointy haired boss is just not a recipe for happiness - who cares if it pays well. Life is short, if you don't enjoy your job, change your job! At any rate that was advice given to me by my father, who worked in the IT department of a large oil company, had a long line of pointy haired bosses who took the credit for anything that went well, which was eventually gutted and outsourced leaving just him and a couple others as insurance. I've regretted it when I did not heed that advice.
- georgemcbay 12y agoWell onion2k's premise was that you wanted to make millions in software. If that is your #1 priority, then working in finance is probably your best bet (unfortunately, IMO). Working for a "pure" software company is great advice if you are optimizing for overall happiness, but not so much for maximizing your income.
- Domenic_S 12y agoLike every industry, "finance" spans a wide gamut of jobs both low and high paying.
- georgemcbay 12y agoWell, to be more specific, when I say "finance" I basically mean doing HFT/quant software development. High stress, high burnout, but also really high reward/bonuses on success when compared to most software jobs.
- 7Figures2Commas 12y agoLots of "software" companies are just as political as big corporations, and startups in particularly are often much more chaotic/stressful and offer far less job security. Notwithstanding the fact that a ton of companies that would like to believe they're "software" companies really aren't, the high turnover at Silicon Valley firms suggests that working for these types of software-centric employers isn't the happiness panacea you make it out to be.
- simonreed 12y ago>If you want to make millions in software, get a job writing code at a bank and invest your salary. This is actually a very good piece of advice.