3 ms·
One possible solution to this would be for Firefox to integrate Tor with their private browsing mode. That would give the Tor network a huge spike in traffic. I
by IgorPartola 12y ago
One possible solution to this would be for Firefox to integrate Tor with their private browsing mode. That would give the Tor network a huge spike in traffic. I have no doubt in my mind that the NSA can and probably does monitor every bit of traffic everyone sends, but the more inconvenient and muddled we make it the better.
I think we can all assume we (HN readers/posters) are on the NSA lists. Lots of us mentioned Tor and the NSA online. "He who must not be named" will show up as soon as you say his name and all that. The question is whether this puts you into actual risk. I sincerely hope not, but this shit is really getting out of hand.
- Taek 12y agoI'm sure that the NSA also has a large array of lists. Having a list called 'extremists' and 'terrorists' helps you get warrants, even if the list is merely composed of people interested in protecting their anonymity. Tor will never take off on its own. There are many stigmas, and many barriers. Furthermore, in the past year to two years, pretty much every service has blacklisted all Tor exit nodes. It used to be moderately easy to sign up for Gmx (and, three years ago, even gmail) over Tor without needing a phone number. Many websites block all exit nodes from posting (though most at least allow viewing). I would dislike to see this as a feature in Firefox until Tor is easier to use. In principle it makes sense and I support the idea, but in practice it would make private browsing very frustrating. I also imagine that you'd have a much more extreme supply vs. demand problem if this happened, reducing an already slow Tor to barely usable speeds.
- javajosh 12y ago>One possible solution to this would be for Firefox to integrate Tor with their private browsing mode. I really like this idea. The practical downside is that Tor is generally very slow. BTW I'm not entirely sure how the NSA can justify an anti-Tor stance, when anonymous speech is clearly protected by the First Amendment. Without something like Tor, true anonymous speech on the Internet is impossible; therefore Tor, or something like it, is a necessary tool to maintain that right. (Anonymous speech has been historically important, when people would print and distribute anonymous pamphlets about political issues. Honestly, I am concerned about criminal use of Tor too, and would be perfectly happy to have a version of Tor limited to political speech and organization.)
- john_b 12y ago> "BTW I'm not entirely sure how the NSA can justify an anti-Tor stance, when anonymous speech is clearly protected by the First Amendment." Well, at least they are consistent with their stance on the Fourth Amendment. Namely, that both are subservient to the 0th amendment: "The right of the people to be monitored^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H protected by their government, even against their will, shall not be questioned."
- IgorPartola 12y ago> BTW I'm not entirely sure how the NSA can justify an anti-Tor stance, when anonymous speech is clearly protected by the First Amendment. Welcome to America, where the constitution is up for interpretation by agencies who have no obligation to disclose anything to anyone. The problem with the NSA is not even that it does all these things. It's that they operate as a sort of rogue arm of the government and if anyone tries to question what they do from within the government they can choose not to answer questions.
- jeorgun 12y agoI really like that idea; enough so that I do all of my private browsing through Tor. Of course the downside to that, besides all the inconveniences of Tor, is that it gets associated in the public mind with both extremist criminals and porn. Maybe the NSA isn't so concerned with the latter, but Tor's image is bad enough has it is. I doubt this would really make it more politically savvy to support it.