10 ms·
Just how much is that 2% really worth?
- chiph 12y agoUnderwater means no big payday. :(
- georgemcbay 12y agoOr worse. You can get screwed on AMT tax on fictional gains, you can also lose real upfront money if you exercise at a strike price early for long term cap gains [almost always a bad move for common stock employees, but lots do it because of their borderline irrational hatred of the idea of taxes].
- jhaile 12y agoLike the design. Good job!
- colinbartlett 12y agoI think people forget just how complex cap tables can get. Add in rules about vesting and strike price, and dilution in future rounds and debt financing, and the likelihood that lowly employees receive meaningful amounts at an acquisition diminish further. Sure, big time paydays and public offerings are possible, but these are the exception. Bottom line: Insist to get paid what you're worth and take any options as a free lottery ticket that will probably never get you anything.
- zorpner 12y agoAnd equally importantly, get paid for the work you do (i.e. don't let anyone convince you to work nights & weekends for a year to "build the company" based on a hypothetical payout).
- geertj 12y agoCap tables are indeed very complex. Often there's also a preference on preferred stock, meaning that the preferred gets a minimum return (often 300% or 400%) before the common gets anything. Fully agreed with the other comments: ignore equity in early stage startups and go for a market rate salary. The one situation where I would take a lower salary is if there's concrete plans that a company will go public within 12 months, and you're going to be in a senior enough job that you'll be in the know about it.
- lightblade 12y agoI wonder what if I used the stock options money to purchase lottery tickets, would I have more chance of winning big? Since stock options vests over 5 years and lottery tickets draws every week, I tend to think you have better chance winning the lottery than winning on your options.
- newcf 12y agoI'm not entirely sure the calculations work.. Maybe I entered data wrong, but I was trying to model the acquisition/startup that I just went through. with our numbers, and our dollars, and my shares.... I walked with a heckuva lot of money, but that's not what the site said.
- calebclark 12y agoThere is a bug that triggers when you add a funding round. It takes your equity percentage down to zero, regardless of the amount raised or pre-money valuation.
- x3c 12y agoRaise an issue in bug tracking. Name it the Zynga bug.
- drcoopster 12y agoThat's not a bug.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- SeoxyS 12y agoHow so? I agree that as soon as you add a round of funding, the math gets wonky. For example, I'm trying to model what a ~5% ownership looks like, and as soon as I add a round of funding that creates 10% dilution with no liquidation preferences, the site says the final ownership percentage is zero. It doesn't even matter what the exit is for at that point, without liquidation preferences, the ownership should still be ~4.6%.
- drcoopster 12y agoBecause in real life, you still end up with nothing of value. :)
- 12y ago
- onion2k 12y agoMy advice to people who want to work in a startup is always very simple: Ignore any equity. If you'd take the job without any equity then take the job. If the equity is part of your reason for taking the job, you probably shouldn't take it. Base rate neglect[1] means we are terrible at evaluating the probability of equity being valuable. For every story about someone making millions out of their equity when the startup they're working for exits there are thousands of stories of people who walked away with nothing but a few years having fun solving challenging problems. That is the reason to work in a startup, because that is the definite, concrete thing on the table. If you want to make millions in software, get a job writing code at a bank and invest your salary. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Base_rate_fallacy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Base_rate_fallacy
- wahsd 12y agoIt has always struck me as little more than a fraud when employees are hired with promises of equity and then additional rounds or other trickery simply dilute their share and contributions to approaching zero and they walk away having put their work, effort, and innovation into making the parasites of our society wealthy just for investing.
- Afton 12y ago> making the parasites of our society wealthy just for investing. Are they less parasitic if they just sit on their money, or are they parasites just for having the money in the first place?
- nullspace 12y agoVery true, and thanks for the link. I think that this also applies the other way around. If you're a founder building your early team, you should not hire people who want to join because of the equity. You should be bringing in people because they want to work on the problem for the salary that you can give them or promise to give. If you hire someone who has an expectation that he will make a million dollars in 4 years - it can lead to a lot of bitterness while you are building the product - especially when you are having a few bad months. Have seen this happening a bunch of times. Equity != Money, equity ~= the percentage of ownership and responsibility. Edit: Salary AND relatively high ownership of the company / product. Some people don't mind taking risks if they have an opportunity to build and own something great.
- peterjancelis 12y agoI'd include in this calculator a negative value per 'passion' speech given by the founders to convince the employees they are building something 'bigger than themselves'.
- zhte415 12y agoNice skit. Small point: Fixed positioning of column on right (contaning calculations) obscures the bottom few lines on desktop (the result), probably due to expecting a greater vertical resolution. On mobile (Android) it completely obscures all input forms.
- nilkn 12y agoThis reminds me of the early-stage startup that offered me a $55k salary in a big city and zero equity to be engineer #3. They told me that if after a year I'd become an integral member of the team then we could discuss equity. Meanwhile they tried to sell me on the job by saying that if the company succeeded we'd never have to work again.
- hkmurakami 12y agoI really don't understand what these companies try to accomplish by essentially lying to you and trying to defraud you of your value. Do they really think you'd sitck around for long under these terms after you find out inevitably how badly you're getting fucked?
- mattzito 12y agoA lot of the startups that I see that try this are doing it because they really believe that they're bringing the value in this relationship - that they're going to be so successful, there's so much money here, they have SUCH a good concept, that the applicant should be grateful to get in on the ground floor. Of course, 90%+ of the time they're totally wrong about everything about what they're bringing to the table, and in the other times, they'll often conveniently change things around to benefit them, like, "Well, you know, I know we said 4% of the company once we raised series A, but honestly, your contributions have not been what we expected, and so you really only are entitled to 1%" To quote "The Spanish Prisoner": Jimmy Dell: I think you'll find that if what you've done for them is as valuable as you say it is, if they are indebted to you morally but not legally, my experience is they will give you nothing, and they will begin to act cruelly toward you. Joe Ross: Why? Jimmy Dell: To suppress their guilt.
- Jemaclus 12y agoI got an offer last year from a company who offered me a 25% salary cut from my current salary and some negligible equity percentage, and then got all huffy when I tried to negotiate the salary. In their mind, the equity was worth so much money, they could pay me peanuts and I should still take the job. It was a huge turn-off. The guy basically told me to go off. "Why bother with startups, then?" he says. Completely missed the point of equity/salary.
- OhHeyItsE 12y agoI think it's even more complicated than this. But props on the design. Nice to look at.
- good-citizen 12y agopretty good job! my only comment is to make more standard options to select from a list vs. typing in any value.
- josh33 12y agoDon't forget taxes will take a large chunk of any payout away. Sometimes as much as 50% when you factor in state taxes.
- acgourley 12y agoIf you get an early stock grant and file your 83(b) you'll actually be taxed as long term capital gains.
- thecage411 12y agoNot necessarily, it only starts the long term capital gains clock: you still need to hold the stock for a year and have the grant be at least two years in the past to qualify. Also, the company may not allow you to early exercise. Ask them before accepting an offer!
- lhnz 12y agoInstead of working for a big company you could just freelance and temporarily contract out to large companies. You get all of the $$$ but also the flexibility for high-optionality events afforded to you from copious free time to build startups and side projects (as well as time to network with others.) In my opinion it is far better to secure a high salary and the free-time and autonomy to work on your own higher-risk pursuits, than it is to secure a low salary and share a tiny percentage of optionality and autonomy with others on a high-risk pursuit. The only exception I'd make is when you're truly enamoured with a vision, a founder, prone to loneliness and need to belong, or don't wish to focus on your economic livelihood at all. At the end of the day the likelihood is that the high-risk pay-off never comes. Just like almost everybody else you'll become old, have a family and want to be able to provide for them.
- ranran876 12y agoMy impression (and I may be wrong) is that you need to be pretty connected or have some a very niche skill-set to be able to freelance for a living. I'm a full-time C++ programmer and I'd love to freelance, but I wouldn't know where to even start. Maybe this makes more sense for web developers
- joshdance 12y agoWhen friends ask me where I work, and I tell them a startup, they always ask if I got stock. I tell them yet, but it isn't worth anything until it is. I agree with the idea that you should take the job if you would without equity.
- dkador 12y agoShouldn't this have a field for the salary you make at the startup?
- Swizec 12y agoAs I always like to say, equity doesn't pay rent in SF or put food on the table.
- vectorpush 12y agoDon't forget that equity doesn't vest immediately. If you take a pay cut in exchange for equity but you leave or are let go before your cliff, you've essentially forfeited a portion of your compensation package in exchange for nothing. I guess this should be obvious, but it may not seem like a real consequence when the founders are asking you about what kind of car you think you'll buy when the start-up explodes.
- Airic 12y agoCool resource but it seems like there's a risk that an employee would inadvertently reveal sensitive financing information by completing this form.
- jaksmit 12y agoEven as a company founder, I don't keep half the stuff mentioned on here top of mind, so I doubt that any employee is going to have enough information to complete it correctly. e.g. to model what you "would have made" if you'd joined Uber at X stage, you'd have to know the pre-money valuation of each funding round they received, along with the investors' liquidation preferences etc and who knows, they may take on even more funding before going public, which would mean your shares would get diluted even further. Overall, if anything, this just serves to illustrate all the complexities involved in trying to model how much a startup's equity offer is actually "worth" in the long-run and that trying to do calculations to model it against an offer at a big company is totally the wrong way to go about it. It just validates what Mark Suster says here: http://www.bothsidesofthetable.com/2009/11/04/is-it-time-for-you-to-earn-or-to-learn/ http://www.bothsidesofthetable.com/2009/11/04/is-it-time-for... don't join a startup because you could potentially make millions of $. Join if you want to learn; any money you make would be if you got really lucky and is a nice side bonus.
- mahmoudimus 12y agoThe most interesting thing is that this website is licensed under GPLv2. Seems excessive.
- mrb 12y agoThere is a blatant bug in the computation. Do not trust the site! Enter $100k as the startup salary, and zero equity (0 shares, $0 strike price, no funding round, any sale price for the liquidity event happening after 12 months). Enter $150k as the big co salary, and the default 5.75% rate of return. The result should be Total Big Co Earnings = $152,875 ($2,875 is the interest gained on the $50k salary diff for 12 months), but instead it shows $196,947!
- zeeboo 12y agoIt appears to apply the interest rate monthly. I'd love to have a 5.75% interest every month. Here's the calculation. It's a little high because we should be getting 1/12th of the 50k per month and compounding, but I'm assuming we got the full 50k up front and got a 5.75% interest compounded per month. 50000*(1.0575 ^ 12) 97799.02314394798212000000 edit: I take it all back. It's super broken. Just mess around with the interest rate and nothing makes any sense. For example, a 0% return still gives you $195,833.33 big co earnings on a 150k salary! edit 2: The bug is in this function and the one below it: https://github.com/vijedi/equity_calculator/blob/master/js/app.js#L161 https://github.com/vijedi/equity_calculator/blob/master/js/a... If your interest rate is zero, the calculated interest is 11 * the monthly difference. Then it's added to your base big company salary, which is clearly wrong. It should be 12 * the monthly difference added to the startup salary. edit 3: Opened a pull request with what I think is the fix: https://github.com/vijedi/equity_calculator/pull/4 https://github.com/vijedi/equity_calculator/pull/4
- vi_jedi 12y agoI'm the guy that wrote this. Thanks for playing with it and fixing the issue. I guess writing interest calculation functions late at night is a really bad idea.
- benmanns 12y agoI think the 5.75% return is over the 48 month vesting duration, on the extra money you would have earned (and invested). So, the excess (per year) would be something more like (50(1.0575^3)+50(1.0575^2)+50*(1.0575^1))/4. (Though it seems I'm a little off, so maybe they do the calculation monthly or biweekly). Edit: Search http://www.tejusparikh.com/projects/equity_calculator/js/app.js http://www.tejusparikh.com/projects/equity_calculator/js/app... for bigCoInterest.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- optimusclimb 12y agoI'm starting to feel like the entire equity offering model is broken. While I agree that you should take a job at a startup for reasons intrinsic to the job itself, and not just the comp (or possible comp) - it is still part of the offer. If someone is offering you a form of compensation, that means you should be able to evaluate it. Otherwise the offer might as well come with a guarantee of two unicorns after four years. Additionally, almost EVERY startup trying to entice people to work for them mentions the equity as part of the sales pitch. "Meaningful equity", "Ownership in the company", "Shares of a pre-IPO company", etc, etc. So if you're pitching people based off of an intangible, almost meaningless number, that smells like a problem, to me. I understand all of the complications, the effect of future rounds being an unknown, etc...but is there a way to improve this? Perhaps if, at the time of offer, and with each change in funding - there was a clearly spelled out, given possible outcome at this time, here's the breakdown of what you get - that could help? I.e., If were were bought out at $100M right now, the founders would receive $12M, and you would end up with $37k...maybe people could evaluate better how "worth it" it is to them. Additionally, when things happen like founders getting cashed out for some sort of comfort effect, like "OK guys, you each at least got a million out of this, run the company now with some security behind you"...employees should be made aware. I guess I just feel like there needs to be more transparency, but I'm not savvy enough to know a good way to offer that.
- dreese 12y agoI think that's why it's best to know the percentage of the company you are being offered. Share count is meaningless without knowing total number of shares. Once you know the percentage (say 0.1%), you can figure out some other stuff. Asking about the company's hopes to go public or be acquired, and at what valuations, can lead to a lot of good discussions.
- smileysteve 12y agoCool site. Re Onion2's top post, could add this into a 90%, 8%, 2% calculator of different liquidation events.
- cgtyoder 12y agoThe typical number of shares created for startups these days is 10M, so it might be worth putting that in as the default number of shares issued.
- nwatson 12y ago(All this is from US tax viewpoint ...) Also factor in the huge one-time payout and how that's taxed at a higher rate than your normal big-company earnings. I know people who got hammered at Federal + California + special-California/Federal-taxes at 50%+ tax rate, all because the acquiring company decided to close a few days into 2013, when tax rates went up considerably, with special surtaxes to boot. A few days earlier would have cut the tax rate by a lot. That tax is magnified if you don't pre-exercise for long-term capital gains advantages -- the whole liquidity event becomes straight income.
- chrisbennet 12y agoIf the founder is motivated by equity it would be disingenuous to expect an employee to be equally motivated for a much smaller slice of equity. I.e. if a founder can expect a payout of $X for working 16 hrs a day he shouldn't be surprised if an employee; who can expect 1/100 of that, only feels motivated to work 8 hours a day.
- ejhabammeg66 12y agoGood job!