4 ms·
Goldman Sachs Demanding E-Mail be Deleted
- SatoshiPacioli 12y agoI use GPGTools when sending sensitive client information, to avoid situations like this. GS has zero excuses, they could very easily code a Microsoft Outlook version of it that is seamlessly integrated. Instead they fail at proper risk management and rely on government intervention, sound familiar?
- SatoshiPacioli 12y agoLink for those interested: https://gpgtools.org/ https://gpgtools.org/
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- smackfu 12y agoDo you also use encryption when sending information internally to a colleague? That's the situation here: it was an internal email accidentally sent to GMail instead of Goldman Sachs. I bet a lot of firms fail in this case.
- eru 12y agoInternal email should be easier to encrypt, if anything. Because the company can control both end-points, so can make the encryption automatic.
- viraptor 12y agoNot sure why this was downvoted. If you're in an outlook/exchange integrated environment, you only have to click "encrypt/sign this". It's almost transparent to the user and in addition it would raise an error for the original sender. (saying the key for user blah@gmail.com cannot be found)
- yebyen 12y agoAnd how would it help to automatically encrypt internal e-mails when an e-mail accidentally gets an external delivery address because someone fat-fingers?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- SatoshiPacioli 12y agoDo you understand how PGP encryption functions?
- yebyen 12y agoYes, I understand (on a superficial "don't actually use it on a day-to-day basis, but have encrypted e-mails before" level) I am imagining this program that looks through your To: field for recipients in your address book that have shared their public key with you. If it finds any, those people get a copy sent to them which is encrypted and only they can read... Now what happens if you accidentally try to send mail to someone not in your address book? I guess hopefully you get a big popup that says "Warning: mail will not be encrypted!" Maybe not? I've used the command-line tools to encrypt files and send encrypted attachments. It's nothing like "automatic" and it's certainly not an envelope for the whole message.
- andreasvc 12y agoYou can set up the encryption so that it requires a verified public key. If you mistype an address, you won't have their public key, and can't encrypt the message to them.
- fpgeek 12y agoSome firms have email triggers that tell you when you're sending something outside the firm to minimize those accidents (and to make the employee carelessness associated with any remaining accidents clearer).
- brisance 12y agoOS X Mail does this for quite some time.
- Marazan 12y agoI would be extremely surprised if GS didn't have a system like other investment banks that popped up an ugly and obvious "you are sending an external e-mail. Are you sure?" dialog when sending to non-internal e-mail addresses.
- eru 12y agoAnd I guess, people are trained by now to automatically click away those dialogs. A 30 second (or so) undo window would be better.
- twistedpair 12y agoI've worked for two of GS's competitors. Any email with confidential information (internal or external) has to be encrypted and signed. Standard operating procedure. I assume it is at GS too and this fella, like most folks on the investment side, just didn't give a hoot about the SOP.
- cjslep 12y agoI assume the email forgot to include the standard legal disclaimer and "delete-if-unintended-recipient" footer notice? Would that actually protect them if that was present on the email?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- couchand 12y agoNo.
- UnoriginalGuy 12y agoThose things don't do a darn thing. I've Googled it extensively and the only justification I can find is: "Why NOT include it? It does no harm and it might help." I'm yet to find a single legal case where an email signature made or broke the case. It strikes me more as legal mumbo jumbo voodoo at this point than anything of merit. Not least of all as a contract is between two parties, the recipient cannot be auto-magically placed into a contractual position just by receiving the email. That would be like me sending a snail mail letter to someone with the words "By reading this mail you agree that all your stuff is now mine" and pretending like any court in the world (any country) would take that "contract" seriously. That's essentially what these signatures do. Try to set up a contractual arrangement with one party "agreeing" to that arrangement just through the virtue of receiving an email?
- jarman 12y ago> to avoid the risk of unnecessary reputational damage to Goldman Sachs What horrible injustice, being known as failure in security for being failure in security. Poor Goldman Sachs.
- vehementi 12y agoIsn't the reputational damage already done? The leak happened.
- wglb 12y agoWhy not post the source article: http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/07/02/us-google-goldman-leak-idUSKBN0F729I20140702 http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/07/02/us-google-goldman-... Bruce isn't adding very much here.
- mpclark 12y agoBruce "just" added the right audience to get the story picked up on HN -- nothing wrong with that.
- chaz 12y agofrom ~11 hours earlier: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7981002 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7981002
- nobbyclark 12y agoHis lack of commentary speaks loudly. gs.com > gmail.com > nsa.gov > irs.gov who will love to see those accounts
- raldi 12y agoWouldn't it be easier for the NSA to go straight to gs.com?
- mpyne 12y agoOr even for IRS to subpoena such records directly, it's not like NSA is the only agency in the whole USG that can order relevant documents to be turned over for investigations in their bailiwick. Maybe it would need a warrant instead but it can't be too difficult for IRS to just get it themselves.
- wes-exp 12y agoUnderstandably GS is not a very sympathetic figure, but in general I don't think it's unreasonable to wish for an email "undo" if you fat-finger the recipient address and realize it immediately.
- raldi 12y agoThat already exists. Visit the "GMail Labs" section of your settings.
- criswell 12y agoIf you don't realize you did it in a few seconds you're still shit out of luck, though. I imagine most people won't realize they sent it to the wrong person until they're notified of the other party not receiving it, or there's an unusual length of reply time. I wonder how people would feel about emails being undoable until the other party opens it.
- glandium 12y agoMicrosoft Exchange has that feature, exposed in Outlook. The fun thing is that IIRC it sends a special email to trigger it. So if the recipient is not using an Exchange server, he sees both emails.
- duncans 12y agoIf you want people to read your email, recall it: "fred@example.com would like to recall the email 'Foo bar'" [OK] [Cancel]
- ggambetta 12y agoA reply to the email with a single line saying "recall", IIRC. I got one of these from a business partner years ago... it was intended as an internal email between them, not as a response to us. It was kind of hilarious. I was very tempted to reply "no" :)
- snowwrestler 12y agoI'm having a hard time getting outraged at either party. We give companies a hard time for lax security practices. GS recognizes an error and is trying to take steps to reduce the likelihood of a data breach. What's wrong with that? Google wants to protect its users from unnecessary interference in there email accounts, so it asked for a court order. What's wrong with that?
- probably_wrong 12y agoI'm not outraged, either, but curious. What if this had happened with physical mail? Does it make any difference whether it was read or not? Can the destination account argue and keep it? There are many interesting questions raised here. It could be interesting to see how it plays out in the end.
- snowwrestler 12y agoGoogle should be able to tell whether the email has been opened or not, or whether the receiving account is active or has been logged into recently. It's interesting to think about this email landing in my Gmail inbox. I'm pretty sure I'd reply and inform the sender that they screwed up and ask if they want me to delete it.
- peteorpeter 12y agoIn the early 2000's I worked in a school system that used a faux-email system where un-sending messages was completely possible. Any user could un-send messages that no recipients had read, which was _great_ as a user. Only sys-admins could un-send read messages. The only time I remember the latter happening was after someone got fired and flamed their way out the door. It was a bit chilling if you did read their messages before all evidence of their outburst erased by the invisible hand of the sys-admins.
- greggman 12y agoThis is off topic but I found out the hard way that then you delete a google docs account all documents you shared with others are deleted from their list of documents. I suppose on the one hand something like that is a solution for gs. On the other hand, while I understand the model, I'm not 100% it's the right one.
- mbrutsch 12y agoThe VA's internal system also had "email" like this (before email was widely used), where we could unsend messages. Fun fact: The VA's system was called Decentralized Hospital Computer Program (DHCP). When that acronym was overloaded by Dynamic Host Configuration Protocol, they changed it - to VistA. Either they had really bad luck picking names, or were very prescient.
- cliveowen 12y agoFrankly I've never understood why email doesn't work this way, it looks backwards to me. As long as the recipient hasn't read the email the sender should have the right to delete it. Even if the client has already delivered the email in the recipient's inbox there should be a way for the SMTP/IMAP server to notify the client and remove it. Even Whatsapp works this way: once you've sent a message, you can't unsend it. The message is first relayed to their servers and then relayed to the client, but even if the recipient isn't online and the message is only on the server, deleting it only removes it from your conversation. You'd think that in 2014 we would have addressed these kinds of flaws.
- 12y ago
- tensafefrogs 12y agoThey shouldn't be emailing around "highly confidential brokerage account information" in the first place. It should be locked down in some internal system. Poor practice from GS that caused it all in the first place.
- twistedpair 12y agoHaving worked at a similar iBank, I can assure you most people don't give a rat's ass about proper procedures until they're caught. Why it was even possible to send an email to an external address with such an unencrypted attachment is a bigger question. I hope the lucky recipient finds a high bidder for said information.
- snowwrestler 12y agoThis is 100% true, but does that mean that they should experience a data breach as a means of teaching them a lesson? Seems like that could create a lot of collateral damage among the affected account holders.
- hluska 12y agoUpdate: Google has apparently blocked access to the email. source - http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/07/03/google-goldman-leak-idUSL2N0PD2R620140703 http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/07/03/google-goldman-lea...
- burncycle 12y agoWhoops. http://www.mcsweeneys.net/articles/whoops http://www.mcsweeneys.net/articles/whoops
- alandarev 12y agoThat is why a 30 minutes delay before sending emails feature is a must-have in any email client. The reason I used "The Bat!" for ages, and now prefer Thunderbird/Postbox-inc.