3 ms·
> Creating jobs is a strange goal. Why? Who says efficiency should be humanity's goal? Is humanity a machine to be optimized? Are we just evolved cogs, one of
by pron 12y ago
> Creating jobs is a strange goal.
Why? Who says efficiency should be humanity's goal? Is humanity a machine to be optimized? Are we just evolved cogs, one of nature's crueler jokes, or are we (also) agents that can put up a fight? You know, Dostoyevsky extolled the virtues of intentional self harm -- or spite -- as a person's noblest goal, asserting freedom from "laws of nature". I'm not saying spite should be a matter of public policy, but it's very important to avoid seeing some mechanistic, or even natural, process as a desirable outcome just because that's how things work (this is the naturalistic fallacy[1]). Public policy should be crafted subject to consideration and political debate.
> People miss the whole point of companies. The goal should never be providing jobs but creating value.
Says who? That's a peculiarly American view of the role of corporations. Another valid goal for companies is providing sustenance to their employees first, and "value" later. I.e. generating value is just a means to an end.
[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturalistic_fallacy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturalistic_fallacy
- pfortuny 12y agoIt also depends on the meaning of "value." In the US it looks like "value" is interchangeable with "cash-able goods," which as you point out is quite restrictive. And, on the other hand, it goes straight against most of companies' "visions" (which are usually non-monetizable).
- jsweojtj 12y ago>> Creating jobs is a strange goal. > Why? Who says efficiency should be humanity's goal? Is humanity a machine to be optimized? I think saying that creating jobs is a goal is more accurately the viewpoint that humans are cogs. Say there's an efficient way to do something, for example: a machine that weaves fabric. If the goal is to create jobs, we could stop the machine and hire people to do the job. In fact, I bet we could force people to do it in a really inefficient and tedious manner that would require lots of people to replace a single machine. The disadvantages: slower. more expensive. more error-prone. people's time-wasting. The advantages: these people have a job so now you have a 'valid' excuse to give people an income.
- pron 12y agoI'm not arguing that one goal is better than another, just saying that goals cannot be (solely) derived from logic, because nature or logic cannot dictate what is good for humans. Deciding on common goals is exactly what politics is for.
- gone35 12y agoThat's a peculiarly American view of the role of corporations. Another valid goal for companies is providing sustenance to their employees first, and "value" later. Indeed. Even stakeholder-driven commercial institutions like co-ops or credit unions are somehow culturally not-quite-corporations in the (American) usual sense.