6 ms·
The Amish are fascinating from so many different angles. Their history of surprisingly successful legal clashes with the US government (no selective service, no
by baddox 12y ago
The Amish are fascinating from so many different angles. Their history of surprisingly successful legal clashes with the US government (no selective service, no Social Security contributions, no education past 8th grade). Their decentralized legal system, which despite being famously strict, is pacifist and arguably anarchist. Their theology/philosophy, if you're into that. Their local economies. Rumspringa. Meidung (shunning). And of course, their extremely fast growth (estimated around 5% per year), which I've heard attributed to "traditional birth rates and modern medicine."
- rurounijones 12y agoIt is certainly interesting from a "segregation" viewpoint. If the Amish were immigrants arriving in American today they would (Warning: generalization incoming) probably be demonized by a decent % of the population for refusing to integrate into mainstream American society, the fact they arrived a long time ago insulates them from that. From reading about the selective service / social security bit it is almost like they are not US citizens and their lands are not US lands. Weird situation.
- baddox 12y agoI think their "PR" is just really good, for some reason. I feel like most Americans that live near Amish communities (I did growing up) might gently joke about how weird it is to live like that, but I think we tend to think of them as a romanticized version of pre-industrial American farmers, despite that not being very accurate. I don't think they are considered not US citizens or their lands not US lands. They pay local and state property taxes on their land.
- icelancer 12y agoThey are largely pacifist, known for incredible work ethic (work alongside one at a manual labor job and you'll understand), and isolationist. Basically they are how we perceive older generations of Americans (romanticized no doubt given the "pacifist" label isn't quite applicable to early-stage Americans). They don't try to force their views on general society and leave well enough alone while providing unique cultural contributions for those who visit them and purchase goods/services. Not really "PR," they just leave others alone and have enough positive traits that everyone seems to respect. EDIT: I countered the random downvote you had.
- bryanlarsen 12y agoMuch of the tolerance for the Amish has been able to happen because they didn't pose any sort of threat to their neighbours or Americans in general. With a combination of a high birth rate and a large amount of money, this may change. The Hutterites in Alberta, Saskatchewan and Montana form colonies similar to those of the Amish. From an outsider's perspective, the major difference between the Amish and the Hutterites is that the Hutterites embrace more technologies that have a primary work purpose. They may not have cars, but they do have trucks and million dollar combine harvesters. The nature of their colonies makes the Hutterites very good at surviving and thriving the boom and bust cycle of modern farming. They save up money during boom years (like the past few years), and then buy up a large amount of land and equipment during the bust years (excessive rain has already drowned a large portion of this year's crop). The birth rate of the Hutterites means that they're always expanding. Non-Hutterite farms are expanding too due to the ever increasing cost and efficiency of farm machinery, but they're also selling out to the Hutterites as sons and daughters move to the city. Having a colony expand into your area can destroy a community. Hutterites are good neighbours, but they are not part of the community. Your community school may close due to poor attendance. Machinery dealers that have a good reputation may thrive, but other businesses wither.
- rmc 12y agoHaving a colony expand into your area can destroy a community. Hutterites are good neighbours, but they are not part of the community the community? or your community? Aren't they part of their own community?
- jimktrains2 12y agoYou don't think that's always been the case with immigrants? At least since the Civil War.
- A_COMPUTER 12y agoThey were here before there was a United States of America, and they never really signed on for that whole social experiment, so I guess you could say they are like Native Americans in that regard.
- xsmasher 12y ago> the fact they arrived a long time ago insulates them from that Being white doesn't hurt either.
- billpg 12y agoHow did they pull that off? I know several Americans who would love to be able to just opt-out of selective service and social security.
- baddox 12y agoBasically they just fought both in court. I think their public perception is positive enough that the courts accepted it.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- dalke 12y agoThey are required to register for selective service. If drafted, they declare themselves to be a conscientious objector. This may include working in a hospital or other non-military role, but usually they request and get a farm deferment, to work on Amish or Mennonites farms, producing food as their "war effort." See http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Academic/Course_Pages/Legal_Systems_Very_Different_13/Book_Draft/Systems/AmishChapter.html http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Academic/Course_Pages/Legal_Sy... for more details. Basically, the Amish found that of the men who do non-combantant military service or work as nurse aides in hospitals end up being away from the Amish community for a couple of years, "only about half of them chose to return to their communities when their service was done, and not all of those chose to join the church." The Amish set up a committee to negotiate with the US about a solution which would work with both the US government and their own community.
- cgtyoder 12y agoThe main reason for their exemptions is their demonstrated track record of self-sufficiency. They have a very strong sense of taking care of each other - there are no poor people in Amish communities. So the courts allowed them to opt out of Social Security, because they have shown they provide their own. Similarly with education - their system works with only a minimal formal education, so the courts were happy to leave them be at that point.
- tzs 12y agoYou left off the one that is perhaps most directly relevant to HN: their approach to technology. Contrary to popular belief, they are not opposed to adopting modern technology. They are just cautious about it, wanting to understand both the good points AND the bad points of it first (unlike most of us, who ignore the bad points until we have become dependent on the new technology and it is too late to do anything about the bad). There's a great article called "Amish Hackers" that goes into this here: http://kk.org/thetechnium/2009/02/amish-hackers-a/ http://kk.org/thetechnium/2009/02/amish-hackers-a/
- drdaeman 12y agoJust wonder what bad sides of electrical engineering they had found, then. I totally get conservativeness of not jumping right onto the hype wagon for the latest tech fad of the year or even decade, but I find it strange they oppose more than a century old scientific concept that hadn't shown any negative effects (some particular implementation did, but as I get it they're generally opposed to the applied use of the very phenomena, not case-by-case implementations like avoiding those fossil-burning stations).
- tptacek 12y agoHere you go: http://amishamerica.com/do-amish-use-electricity/ http://amishamerica.com/do-amish-use-electricity/
- baddox 12y agoTo summarize tptacek's link, the Amish generally refrain from using the public power grid, but they use electricity from their own generators or even solar panels. The idea isn't to ban things that are modern or things that save time, but rather things that make members more influenced by the world and less dependent on their own community.
- baddox 12y agoYeah, that's what I meant by their theology/philosophy. As I understand it, they evaluate technologies on a case-by-case basis, the key judgement being whether the technology makes members less dependent on the community, without regard to "how modern" the technology is. And the decision is on a per-community basis, and their communities are quite small (although they do generally fall into larger regional groups that share many decisions). The Amish near where I grew up have what appears to me to be a fairly modern lumber mill that must be powered either by grid electricity or (more likely) internal combustion generators.