6 ms·
The longevity gap
- kfk 12y agoIf you speak Italian head over noisefromamerika and search “modello superfisso”, there you can see why this reasoning is flawed. Prices of stuff are not fixed, they are a function of demand and offer. The true problem here is how you innovate enough to make the offer high enough that prices will drop. Instead, the writer is focusing on the myth of the 10% owning the 90% and he gets lost in yet another useless complain about spreading the wealth. Go look at why health services are so expensive in US, hints: monopolies, artificially low number of doctors, lobbies, patents… By the way, about 44% of my gross salary is managed by the State (tax and social contribution). How much more does the writer want to tax people in order to “help” the poor?
- thewarrior 12y agoBut I bet that these drugs would be patented and would be selling at very high prices for decades. Countries like India wouldnt want to encourage generic production of these drugs as that would make the existing population problem worse.
- lukasm 12y agoWriter does not want to tax people. Writer wants more page views so a bit of controversy helps. Is it really 44%? What about sales tax/VAT, Social Security, Property Tax, Quantitative easing. In perfect world gov would take 5% of my income. I'm not against helping people - far from that - but the State is very bad at allocating resources.
- capisce 12y agoWhy is labor income taxed so much more than capital gains? Effectively those with large fortunes are paying a way lower effective tax rate than most salaried employees.
- paganel 12y ago> Why is labor income taxed so much more than capital gains? Like most of the regressive taxes, I think it's because of power imbalances. The vast majority of people paying 40% on labor taxes do not have the same power influence as those with far greater fortunes who benefit from capital gains. The same thing held true in "Ancien Régime" France in the 18th century and even in my small East-European country, where, according to a book which I'm just reading, the local rulers used to "absolve" rich people from paying taxes because they "had been helpful" to said rulers in the past (mostly they had lent money in times of distress to those rulers), while most of the taxation felt on the poor people. As for a solution to all this, I honestly don't know which one might be best. Right now democracy and universal suffrage seems like the best we can do, but IMHO we're always just a couple of steps away from reverting to other solutions which we tried in the past, the ones that involved people like the Jacobins or those that started the October Revolution. Time will tell.
- dkyc 12y agoBecause the capital that you invest has been taxed before, when it was earned. Kind of harsh to tax 40% on your income, and when you save it, tax again the same amount on your returns.
- nasmorn 12y agoSo is Sales tax which regressively Hits the poor the hardestas they spend 100% of income. This is a non argument. Tax what least inhibits growth or like alcohol and cigarette taxes things that you would like to be used less.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoIf savers eventually consume whatever they saved, they too will be hit by the sales tax. Their tax rate will be 1-(1-Income tax)(1-savings tax)(1-sales tax), compared to the consumer who will pay only 1-(1-Income tax)(1-sales tax). If they never consume what they saved, they have effectively given it to society anyway. The idea that a sales tax is regressive (w.r.t income) is simply an artifact of your measurement period. It's strictly speaking a flat tax over the long term, but it becomes regressive for a single individual if you break his lifetime up into year-long chunks and if his income or consumption isn't stable. tl;dr; do the math, the "sales tax is regressive" meme is silly. Any true regressivity is solely an artifact of progressive income taxes and vanishes when you measure progressivity w.r.t. after-tax income.
- casualobserver 12y agoKind of misleading title after clicking through: > Costly new longevity drugs could help the wealthy live 120 years or more – but will everyone else die young? Drug research is costly, but it's not wealthy benefactors of the clinical application that pay for it. Some research is privately funded, much is government funded but it's also costly to fail to pay for it. The age gap due to wealth discussed in the article is not related to the cost to the individual of drug research and development. Once the research is done, most drugs become inexpensive to produce and if they prevent the burden of ageing on healthcare and society. Reason to fund gerontology research if it decreases healthcare expenditure. The then minor cost could be subsidised and there would be little argument in limiting its availability beyond that of aspirin and clean drinking water. The current longevity gap due to poverty/environment discussed isn't a reason to discount increases in healthspan/lifespan that might benefit the rich more immediately. Gerontology/drug research is not mutually exclusive of improving access to education, mental health and reducing pollution etc.
- pawelkomarnicki 12y agoI dont' want to live 120 years, do you?
- GotAnyMegadeth 12y agoI'd be happy to live as long as the Sun, longer if we start colonising new planets. As long as I can die before the heat death of the Universe.
- FranOntanaya 12y agoNo way! Give me then a few mirrors and I'll start trapping far-red photons to restart the Universe again.
- jacquesm 12y agoYou're going to have to construct your mirrors from far-red photons, that's sort of the problem. Without stable matter you're not going to be doing much of anything (or even be much of anything).
- Filligree 12y agoAnd I'm happy to worry about this problem for as many trillions of years as it takes.
- ownagefool 12y agoYeah. Why wouldn't you?
- philbarr 12y agoBecause I don't want to live so long that I spend a large portion of my life in ever increasing pain and feeling my mind slip away from me. Just give me a short sharp shock around 80, if you can please. Of course, that's what I think now at 36. Maybe by the time I'm 80 I'll be thinking, "reckon I can handle a few more years...."
- netrus 12y agoNota bene the high cost of such meds won't be the meds themselves, but cost for the social system. Will those super old people work until they are 100 years old? If not, it has to remain the luxury of a small minority.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- adwn 12y agoI don't see a single argument why the life spans of the less wealthy should shorten further, even though this is claimed several times in the article. Did they just take two data points and extrapolate from there?
- Tycho 12y agoIt's the politics of envy at its worst. Better that the rich die earlier to make things more fair, than everyone live unevenly longer.
- rayiner 12y agoI think that's unnecessarily dismissive. More even societies are higher trust, more orderly, and by most accounts more pleasant. The U.S. is much richer than Finland, but I doubt the majority of Finns would rather be Americans.
- Filligree 12y agoWhile thinking about these things is important, it would be good not to lose track of the greater picture. I couldn't possibly say it as well as Nick Bostrom, so I won't try: Death is bad; it needs to go. This seems like an apropos time to re-read http://www.nickbostrom.com/fable/dragon.html http://www.nickbostrom.com/fable/dragon.html
- Turukawa 12y agoI think the idea of revolution as a result of age-disparity is a tad overstated. At the point most people would become sufficiently aware of any age-gap, and angry-enough to want to riot about it, you'd probably be suffering age-related effects and want a nap. Also, drugs eventually fall out of patent and become available at far lower prices to everyone. The poor have far larger problems than whether they get to live an extra 10 years or so once they get to 70.
- jorleif 12y ago> College-educated white men can expect to live to age 80, while counterparts without a high-school diploma die by age 67. I wonder if reality is as bad as it sounds here. Factors that cause early death might very well correlate with bad education outcomes. Any kind of lacking self-control could result both in bad education outcomes as well as early death.
- Sambdala 12y ago> might very well correlate with bad education outcomes So would dying at age 16. It's definitely possible (probable?) they've taken the appropriate figures here, but there's definitely a chance for bad statistics here.
- dorfsmay 12y agoWhat about A. de Gray's theory that states with universal healthcare will pay for this tpe of treatment, as it will be cheaper than treating diabetes, cancer, etc...?