8 ms·
Segway Inventor Dean Kamen Thinks New Stirling Engine Will Get You Off the Grid
- mattdeboard 12y agoWait, I thought Segway inventor died after driving a Segway off a cliff. Not trolling.
- teraflop 12y agoNope. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_inventors_killed_by_their_own_inventions#Popular_myths_and_related_stories http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_inventors_killed_by_the...
- Mandatum 12y agoHad the same reaction, this poor bastard must get that a lot..
- smokinn 12y agoThat wasn't the inventor, it was the CEO: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jimi_Heselden http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jimi_Heselden
- AceJohnny2 12y agoNot the inventor, the new CEO who had bought the company: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jimi_Heselden#Death http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jimi_Heselden#Death
- YZF 12y agoThere's a Canadian startup that I think is doing something pretty similar: http://www.etalim.com/ http://www.etalim.com/
- joncp 12y agoDoes this seem like a step backward to anyone else? We want to generate electricity with renewable sources instead of fossil fuels. Also, I'm skeptical that a small in-home generator of any type could compete with the efficiency of a commercial power plant, even if that plant burns natural gas.
- obvious_throw 12y agoRenewables like wind and solar need EITHER enormous storage capacity, OR baseline supply to work with modern consumption patterns. Storage is both expensive and environmentally destructive - these engines could be a good fit for baseline generation to dramatically reduce the need for storage in a renewable system.
- Sanddancer 12y agoThis is the first product, and is targeting areas where cheap natural gas is plentiful. However, because it's an external combustion engine, I imagine it wouldn't be too difficult to build a future product where the heat differential is created from a different source, like solar tiles, or through geothermal differences.
- maxerickson 12y agoThe electrical generation probably isn't more efficient, but the household/facility is, at least during times it has a use for the waste heat. The waste heat will be roughly 50% of the energy involved. The difference between the generators won't be that big. So each unit of fuel provides more energy to the end user (which is what I am calling efficiency, the energy utilized for something vs the energy consumed making it available).
- Lagged2Death 12y agoI'm skeptical that a small in-home generator of any type could compete with the efficiency of a commercial power plant, even if that plant burns natural gas. A small local generator will certainly be behind what a big commercial generator will do, but if the waste heat is also being harnessed ("Combined Heat and Power," or CHP), combined efficiencies of 60%-80% are possible. Commercial electrical generation is typically around 40% efficient, so CHP really can offer very big benefits. Of course, there's nothing fundamentally efficient about a single family living in a huge mansion with a 10KW energy demand and a big heated swimming pool. I would have guessed these things would be most attractive to hotels, universities, airports, truck stops, apartments and condos, and other institutional-scale places that have a significant round-the-clock demand for electricity and hot water. I wonder what it says about the device and the market that they're planning to sell to well-heeled homeowners first.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jimmcslim 12y agoI'd say its quite inaccurate to say that Stirling engines will get you 'off the grid'. You are exchanging one grid, electricity generation and distribution, for another, natural gas production and distribution. Your engine may be physically connected to a residential gas distribution network, or practically connected to the gas industry 'grid' if you are expecting large gas bottles to be trucked to your door every few weeks...
- byerley 12y ago'off the grid' has gotten very overloaded because some people take it to mean the power grid, some people take it to mean all utilities, and some people take it to mean self-sufficiency for extended periods. An engine that could run off a wood-burning fire and was built to last a couple decades would strike me as really neat - this not so much. I suppose other places have more issues with the power grid reliability, but it's presumably more efficient to maintain the current infrastructure than to get one of these into every house. Natural gas is also going to get much more expensive if they ever push fracking regulations through - the current pollution from gas leaks is actually worse than burning an equivalent amount of petroleum.
- eru 12y agoWhy would you be interested in burning wood? > Natural gas is also going to get much more expensive if they ever push fracking regulations through - the current pollution from gas leaks is actually worse than burning an equivalent amount of petroleum. Interesting. Do you have links to further reading?
- byerley 12y ago> Why would you be interested in burning wood? Something you can stick in a cabin to power odd appliances or a computer and not have to worry about carrying fuel in (not very practical I admit). Simple thermoelectric generators are tricky because you have to maintain the temperature difference - generally only good for brief use or with a battery. > Interesting. Do you have links to further reading? To be honest, it's information I got second hand from some climate researchers I used to work with. I wasn't planning to weigh in with google results, but this blog does a very impressive job of documenting the back and forth with links to papers - http://www.carbonbrief.org/blog/2013/08/shale-gas-more-or-less-polluting-than-coal/ http://www.carbonbrief.org/blog/2013/08/shale-gas-more-or-le...
- richardc12345 12y agoA similar product called WhisperGen was around a number of years ago: http://www.whispergen-europe.com/productspec_en.php?fm=whispergen&fp=Product%20Specs http://www.whispergen-europe.com/productspec_en.php?fm=whisp... Stirling Engine combined heat and power appliance the size of a dishwasher. About 10,000 Euros for 1KW of electricity output. I don't think it made it in the marketplace.
- uptown 12y agoTangentially related - Anybody know anything about the progress or success of the BloomBox from Bloom Energy? They were billed as a close-to-magical way to produce energy when they were first announced, but I haven't heard much about them since then.
- hedgehog 12y agoSounds like they're making progress: http://gigaom.com/2013/11/18/apple-solar-farm-fuel-cell-farms-exclusive-photos-investigative-report/ http://gigaom.com/2013/11/18/apple-solar-farm-fuel-cell-farm...
- mhb 12y agoNo mention of the cost of the output electricity?
- alex_duf 12y agoNo mention of how much more efficient is it compare to any other generator either...
- Sanddancer 12y agoMaybe I'm just failing at finding the info, but does anyone know how much natural gas is used to create that 10kw of power? As the Stirling engine is a heat engine, my first thought is that one could potentially have a dual-mode generator here, using solar thermal, etc, to help generate power in those areas where it's amenable to do so.
- dredmorbius 12y agoStirling (and other thermal-cycle engines) are about 30-35% in converting heat energy to useful work. In this case electricity. So dividing 10 kW by 30% will give you the rough energy input. Casting that in therms/hr. (usual natural gas billing unit in the US is therms), it's about 1.14. Residential price is on the order of around $0.80 - $1.50/therm, so you're looking at about $25/day for 10 kW of continuous power. Which isn't far from what you'd be paying for electricity: $21 - 29 at $0.09 - $0.12 per kWh. In terms of volume, 1 ft^3 is about 1025 btu, a therm is 10,000 btu, so you're looking at 97.5, let's call it 100 ft^3 of natural gas consumption per day. As for running a Stirling engine on solar energy, or another heat source, yes, you could do that. Again, you need 33 kW of input power, which means a 33m^3 collecter surface -- that's 5.8m on a side, or 19 feet. Because the Stirling's hot end is a point, you'd need tracking systems or a working fluid to deliver heat to it from your mirrors. Incidentally, you can answer a lot of these questions using GNU units, written by Adrian Mariano. The great thing about it is conversion between different units and relationships, e.g., energy per hour per unit area. I find it invaluable in looking at energy, renewable, and related issues.
- Crito 12y ago> "Kamen believes that aside from mansion owners, the Beacon 10 is just right for businesses like laundries or restaurants that use a lot of hot water. With commercialization partner NRG Energy, he’s so far deployed roughly 20 of the machines." If the primary use for a potential customer is going to be heating water, essentially doing heat->generator->electricity->heat->water, how is this a good idea? Surely people who want to heat lots of water would do better if they cut out the middlemen and just did heat->water. Of course electricity is more versatile than hot water, but if your primary focus is on heating lots of water and you are already committed to making heat yourself, it seems senseless to me to not just apply the heat directly to the water.
- lutorm 12y agoThe hot water is a byproduct, you don't use the electricity for it.
- fryguy 12y agoI think the idea is that you're heating up water anyways [for laundry/dishwashers], you might as well get power out of it. It's kind of the same principle as if you're using an electric heater, you might as well run a bunch of bitcoin miners that generate heat to lower the amount the heater has to be on, since they're both resistive loads. And with the miners, you get some coin as well.
- tsotha 12y agoThey wouldn't be using electricity to heat the water. Of course you would end up using less gas if you just heated the water directly like most of us already do for our morning shower. The efficiency of any heat engine depends on the gradient between the input and output temperature. So if you have a constant supply of cold water the Stirling engine can operate very efficiently, and the cold water becomes hot water which you can use for other things. Of course, like I said, this is true of any heat engine. You can do the same thing by heating a boiler and using the steam to drive a turbine, which also generates waste heat for other things.
- chris_va 12y ago> So in 10 years will everyone have one? > “I’d say yes. Ten years from today the probability that you are depending on wires hanging on tree branches is as likely as that you’ll still be installing land lines for telephones. Close to zero.” Well this seems out of touch with reality. This is how I read it: "Why maintain 1 power plant when you can instead ship and maintain 100000 instead?"
- tsotha 12y agoRemember, this is the same guy that was telling us the Segway would revolutionize travel.
- johnpowell 12y agoI remember when Kamen was going on all the morning shows saying that he was going to change the world and transportation. Many speculated that it was a Sterling Engine. It was the Segway.
- tsotha 12y agoBut the Sterling engine is 200 years old. It's hard to imagine he's going to be able to do something spectacular with it.
- vidarh 12y agoEspecially given as having access to a home natural gas supply is not a given. I didn't even know that was a thing until I moved to the UK.
- bryanlarsen 12y agoA Stirling engine just requires a heat source of some kind. Unless you don't cook your food, you have access to fuel of some kind.
- bryanlarsen 12y agoConsidering that most Americans already have two power plants sitting mostly unused in their garage, maintenance personnel should not be hard to find.
- mkoryak 12y agoThis article reminded me of a very log blog by some guy in south america who detailed building his own hydroelectric power plant. I wanted to find it so I could link it here but I cant. Help?
- AceJohnny2 12y agoWas this it? http://ludens.cl/paradise/turbine/turbine.html http://ludens.cl/paradise/turbine/turbine.html
- mkoryak 12y agoYes! Thank you
- andrewflnr 12y agoWhy do they keep talking about pool heating? If I just want to heat up something up and have natural gas on hand, I'm just going to burn the gas, not run it through some engine and use the electricity.
- Lagged2Death 12y agoThe engine's waste heat heats the water. That's why it's efficient; some of the "waste" heat is recovered and put to use. A Stirling engine in particular needs an explicit heat sink to cool some parts of the mechanism; shuttling a working fluid (and its heat) back and forth between a hot end and a cold end is how it works. In this case, the cold end is the swimming pool.
- auxym 12y agoAny thermodynamic machine (gas turbines, ICEs, your fridge) needs a hot end and a cold end/heatsink. It's the second law [1]. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_law_of_thermodynamics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_law_of_thermodynamics
- Lagged2Death 12y agoYes, I know that, but in familiar cases (like an internal combustion engine) the heat sink is mainly just venting exhaust to the atmosphere. The heatsink exists as a part of the environment, almost an accident of the design. It's a sort of implicit heatsink as opposed to an explicit one.
- hrjet 12y agoGenuine question: if we wrap an IC engine with a heat sink that captures the excess heat for re-use, what do we get? And is overall more or less efficient than using the sterling engine in article?
- bryanlarsen 12y ago
- chadpaulson 12y agoAndrea Rossi's Energy Catalyzer, which uses LENR (Low Energy Nuclear Reaction), is far more interesting and will actually get you off the grid. http://ecat.com/ http://ecat.com/
- wglb 12y agoDean Kamen is one of my heroes, actually. In particular, his effort to make water purification machines for poverty-stricken areas is likely to have more health impact than anything currently doable. Given that some significant fraction of diseases are water-borne. This is what we as engineers should be doing.
- keehun 12y agoYes and his work in FIRST. It may not be as philanthropic, but I've seen it save lives in the US. Kids who otherwise would turn to substance abuse/vandalism/crime, FIRST teams (at least my team) provided a safe, loving, and an actually exciting/engaging/educational experience to kids in not-so-nice homes and families. That man is doing something really great.
- EEGuy 12y agoLet's look at who's behind it, what it is, how it can be used, and where the benefits accrue: * Who: NRG, while not a utility, is an owner of utility-scale generation capacity. They wholesale electricity to utilities for distribution and resale. Their portfolio is largely fossil-fuel but increasingly renewables [1]. They see themselves in the "death spiral" some other generation suppliers do [3][4]. * What: Per [2], it's a combined natural-gas-in ( 50KW Th ) heat-out / grid-power-in / gas-to-electrical-power-out (Stirling engine, 10 KW max ) / grid-and-home-power-out (15KW max) / solar-power-in / battery-power-both-ways (15KW max) / inverter system, tech specs subject to change. More per [2]: "A single unit can integrate natural gas, solar panels, wind turbines and batteries for storage," NRG says. "The device is connected to the grid, which allows the two to work seamlessly together. But if the grid's power goes down, the engine's energy stays up. Any excess generated energy can be sent back to the grid and may be credited for your benefit." . Aside from the 15 kW maximum electrical output, output can be used for space heating (35 kW or 0.12 MMBTU) or hot water (200 gallons per hour at 70° rise). Additional uses include snow melt and spa and pool heating. . The technical specifications are subject to change. . When necessary, the unit seamlessly transitions to a backup power system, to maintain continuous operations, NRG says. . The Beacon 10 unit's dimensions are 3 ft. 8 in. long by 2 ft. 6 in. wide by 4 ft.high, which NRG says is slightly larger than a washing machine. . The unit weighs 1,500 lbs. * How it can be used: Disrupt the utility's business by selling or leasing equipment directly to end users, and by doing energy arbitrage with the utility. The whole business of solar integration and battery integration is optional, and smells of "greenwashing-by-association" to me: The cheapest install of this machine would not include a solar component nor battery, each of which might be very expensive in addition to this machine. Who could afford all that? Certainly not everyone. * Where benefits accrue: See [5] for the long story, but it looks like NRG mainly. If you lease it from NRG, you may not get as much of the benefit of energy arbitrage. * What I think of it: Regulators should insist on a "connection charge" for this and accept energy sold at wholesale prices, while selling to the user at retail prices. Disclosure: I own a solar system with net metering, but believe a "connection charge" is entirely reasonable /for those who have their own generation capability/ and thus use the grid for sale of distributed generation, but /not/ for those who don't. ======= [1] http://www.nrg.com/renew/renewable-generation/ http://www.nrg.com/renew/renewable-generation/ [2] http://www.energychoicematters.com/stories/20131022a.html http://www.energychoicematters.com/stories/20131022a.html [3] http://www.utilitydive.com/news/facing-decline-nrg-energy-forges-new-business-models/234896/ http://www.utilitydive.com/news/facing-decline-nrg-energy-fo... [4] www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/NRG-Energy-Deploying-Dean-Kamens-Solar-Smart-In-Home-Generator [5] http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2013/11/who-will-compete-with-energy-companies-in-the-future-apple-comcast-and-you/281109/ http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2013/11/who-wi...
- zurn 12y agoThis is traditionally called "micro CHP". It has potential in places without district heating infrastructure, otherwise DH CHP is much more efficient. These aren't really new. Eg here is an article looking at an existing commercial gas powered Stirling micro CHP that's quiet and designed for your house: http://www.f09.fh-koeln.de/imperia/md/content/personen/sommer_klaus/forschung/rehva_micro_chp.pdf http://www.f09.fh-koeln.de/imperia/md/content/personen/somme... - there's also a comparison to an ICE based equivalent and it has much better electricity generation efficiency. The total efficiency is going to depend a lot on where you use it. The heating output is locked to the electrical output so you're always going to generate the 5 kW of heat per each kW of electricity, so you have to stop the plant when your hot water tank and house is heated up - or start throwing away all the heat and just run it as a low efficiency genset. The large pool case sounds like a fit, but from another perspective it's just greenwashing the huge energy sink of the pool. The laundries & restaurants case sounds better here. Or regular houses in climates where a lot of heating is needed most of the year.
- dredmorbius 12y agoIf you run the number on based on an assumed 30% efficiency and retail gas costs of $0.8 - $1.50 a therm (I think that's reasonable), then you come up with a cost per kWh of electricity within the $0.09 - $0.12 range many US utilities charge. That is, on a cost-of-electricity basis it's a wash. Mind: gas delivery networks likely would crumble (hopefully not literally) under the increased demand. Depending on system costs, this could be viable as a back-up power generation option (blackouts, etc.), where electrical service might fail but the gas supply would still work. Capturing and making use of waste heat could indeed be useful. I see the possibility of full grid independence as very slim, and not particularly compelling (with distributed small, renewable, and intermittent generation, the grid is a useful way to move surpluses and deficits around). Though being somewhat immune to major grid disruptions is a possibility. I'd also keep an eye on natural gas trends. Supplies aren't endless, though the US EIA's estimates suggest a reference resource case of increasing extraction through 2040 at least, the less optimistic low resource case suggesting a peak by 2030. With fracked oil extraction very likely to peak before 2020, a transfer of fuel and energy uses onto natural gas will change market dynamics considerably. I've got my doubts as to how long gas will remain cheap. And suspect that its increased use in transport (EIA sees a large role in trucking) other uses may be limited.
- cjbenedikt 12y agoThe approach is not entirely new. A company called Sunmachine in Germany built a similar device producing 3KW and fed by wood pellets made from saw dust - so even more carbon friendly. Sunmachine had to file for bankruptcy as it couldn't find the working capital to produce the neccessary machines it had in its order books to bridge the gap before getting paid after installation of the units. It was aimed at the residential property market.
- Lost_BiomedE 12y agoSurprising that they could not get a loan given their order backlog. Were the margins terribly small or something?
- cjbenedikt 12y agoit was during the 2008/2009 credit crunch - banks just wouldn't loan. It was eventually auctioned off. They also had a technology to run the stirling engine via a solar dish that tracked the course of the sun...pretty cool stuff
- ChaoticGood 12y agoSterling Engines are cool. Here is one being used in combination with a Fresnel lens. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A_AFnW1bZL8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A_AFnW1bZL8
- regularfry 12y agoAn interstitial, a popover to explain the site's navigation, then an ad which scrolls over the content? You've got to be keen to want to read this stuff.
- secondForty 12y agoKamen has demonstrated a great talent for generating media coverage of his products - think back to the incredible level of media attention around launch of "It"... which turned out to be the segway. If he's working on a new product, expect a similar level of media engagement. There's a good book about development and launch of the segway "CODE NAME GINGER: The Story Behind Ginger and Dean Kamen's Quest to Invent a New World"[1]. It's in paperback as "Reinventing the Wheel: A Story of Genius, Innovation, and Grand Ambition"[2]. It also has some interesting coverage of what happened inside the company during that time. [1] http://www.stevekemper.net/disc.htm http://www.stevekemper.net/disc.htm [2] http://www.amazon.com/Reinventing-Wheel-Genius-Innovation-Ambition/dp/0060761385 http://www.amazon.com/Reinventing-Wheel-Genius-Innovation-Am...
- Istof 12y agoI thought he died using a Segway, but it was the owner of the company, Jimi Heselden [1]. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1315518/Segway-tycoon-Jimi-Heselden-dies-cliff-plunge-scooters.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1315518/Segway-tycoo...
- menubar 12y agoOh, it's Mr. Ultra-Hype again.
- orillian 12y agoAs cool as this is. Even with the fact that in the US it's decided you'd hook it up to a gas line. There is still the issue of "leasing it" to the homeowner. Seriously, why would anyone lease a home generator. Maybe I'm old school, but I can't see the benefits to the homeowner if you're undercutting your savings from installing one of these devices by paying "RENT" on the generator?
- rbanffy 12y agoI have serious objections to anything that increases reliance on fossil fuels. Or anything that releases more carbon to the atmosphere for that matter. There are clean ways to get you off the grid. This is not one of them. At least not entirely.
- driverdan 12y agoI'd love to see someone make a smaller, inexpensive stirling engine that can be used to recapture waste energy, eg turn some AC heat into electricity.