3 ms·
According to the Supreme Court, the acceptable timeframe for a detention is around 20 minutes. http://criminal-law.freeadvice.com/criminal-law/arrests_and_sear
by enraged_camel 12y ago
According to the Supreme Court, the acceptable timeframe for a detention is around 20 minutes.
http://criminal-law.freeadvice.com/criminal-law/arrests_and_searches/arrest-detention.htm http://criminal-law.freeadvice.com/criminal-law/arrests_and_...
>>In a detention, the police only need reasonable suspicion to stop an individual, and a reasonable person would feel as though they could leave in a short amount of time. This timeframe can vary a bit based on the circumstances, but the U.S. Supreme Court has held that 20 minutes or so is a reasonable timeframe for detaining someone.
In other words, if you're being forced to wait in some office for hours (as is usually the case in these types of matters), the Supreme Court would say that it no longer counts as detention at that point.
But would it count as an arrest? Further down in that article, it says:
>>An arrest is characterized by the idea that a reasonable person would not feel free to leave due to the actions of the law enforcement officers. This usually means that the officers take the individual into custody. Custody can mean a number of things. An individual may be taken into custody by driving them back to the police station. However, courts have also held custody to mean any situation in which an individual reasonably believes that they will not be able to leave within a short period of time.
Aha. So being forced to wait in an office while they arrange for your return flight home is indeed an arrest.
Of course, like you point out, these are not the types of situations in which one can challenge the authority of the state officials. Still though, I do want them to detain the wrong person one of these days and get their asses pwned in a lawsuit.
- schoen 12y agoBut see, for example, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Border_search_exception https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Border_search_exception
- bequanna 12y ago>Aha. So being forced to wait in an office while they arrange for your return flight home is indeed an arrest. Not so sure about that. Are they detaining you, or simply not allowing you to enter the US? Let's say you walk up to my front door, and I won't let you into my house. Would I be 'arresting' you on my front step by not granting you entry into my home?
- legedemon 12y ago> Let's say you walk up to my front door, and I won't let you into my house. Would I be 'arresting' you on my front step by not granting you entry into my home? No, but it'd be an arrest if you told me that I couldn't leave your porch unless you let me in or forced me out.